Oct 16, 2010 at 10:23 pm #1264471
I need a sleeping bag. I need one that will last and one that will be useful in as many situations as possible. I need ONE bag. i.e. I can only afford one bag.
What are your suggestions?
Montbell Ul Super Spiral #3?
Nunatak Catabatic SL?
WM MegaLite? SummerLite? AlpineLite? UltraLite?
Should I get a quilt? What temperature rating?Oct 16, 2010 at 10:36 pm #1655254
@b-g-2-2Locale: Silicon Valley
Paul, you are asking open-ended questions.
If you don't know what temperature rating of sleeping bag you need, then you don't want to buy _any_ now.
Do some reading, talk to people, figure out your intended outdoors travel, and get a good idea of what you are getting into. Then, when you have a temperature rating in mind, you can begin shopping.
–B.G.–Oct 16, 2010 at 10:42 pm #1655258
full zip 10-20 F down bag … any good brand name
zip it up and layer with clothes in the winter … as long as its not crazy cold
unzip it and use it like a quilt in the summer …
fall/spring …just use it regularly
WM s always excellent … other brand names on sale are always good … just make sure it meets the EN temps
should weight between 700-1000 gramsOct 16, 2010 at 11:30 pm #1655263
Dan DurstonBPL Member
Since you want this quilt for a possible thru-hike, I would look for a rating around 20F (not that I have experience with long thru hikes). That will keep you realistically warm to about freezing and then on colder nights you can wear your insulating jacket to bed.
My suggestion is to look at a quilt over a bag. I made the switch last summer and I was nervous about whether it would be a pain to keep the quilt tucked in around me. As it turned out, it was a very painless switch and I actually prefer using a quilt. It's easier to get in and out, which makes those middle of the night washroom breaks that much less painful. It's also easier to reach an arm otu and check the time. Keeping it tucked in isn't a pain and I switch sleeping positions a lot. A quilt is a lot more like sleeping in your bed at home than a sleeping bag.
It's not the lightest possible quilt, but the GoLite 3+ season quilt (rated to 20F) is well made and very affordable:
The retail price is $275 and GoLite occasionally has online sales around 30-40% off. I wouldn't be surprised to see one before christmas. The last one was for the national trails day this summer. This quilt has 11.5oz of down, which should keep you quite warm. GoLite also has generously wide quilts so they are easier to keep tucked in compared to more radical quilts with a slimmer cut.
The Katabatic Sawatch (15F) is another nice 3 season quilt but with 15oz of down you might find it too hot in the summer…a better option might be the Katabatic Palisade (30F, 9.2oz down) with some overstuff (2oz is $18) if desired. With 9.2oz of down, you'd want to have some decent other layers on hand for the shoulder seasons.
This quilt is very light (17oz) and it's $315. I'd get it overfilled it with 2oz, you'd be looking at a 19oz quilt for $332 which contains 11.3 oz of down. That's a pretty sweet package. The only downsides here are a rumoured slimmer cut than the GoLite quilts, and the price. The GoLite 3+ season is 5oz heavier for the same warmth, but if you could get it for 30-40% off ($165-$192) then you'd be looking at a big savings compared to $332.
If you're really looking for value, the GoLite synthetic 1+ Season quilt (40F rating) is normally $120, but BentGate has it on for $101 and then you can use this coupon code (rockandice2010) on top of that for another 15% off. That would give you a 40F rated, 24oz synthetic quilt for $85 and free shipping too I believe.
That would be a sweet quilt for the summer, but you'd want to layer up well for the shoulder seasons. When it's going to be cold I use down pants (7oz) and a down vest (7oz) in addition to the montbell UL down inner jkt (8.5oz) in my 30F bag. You'd want something similar. With the right layers, you could put together a pretty versatile system, but carrying a bunch of pieces is always heavier than just carrying a warmer bag unless you want the insulating pieces for use outside of sleeping.Oct 17, 2010 at 9:33 am #1655318
Richard LyonBPL Member
@richardglyonLocale: Bridger Mountains
"One bag for most seasons" is usually a quilt. I think my Nunatak Back Country Blanket is my most versatile bag; with different clothes it's kept me warm from 15-50 F. I do have several ounces of overfill, as I sleep very cold. If considering a quilt talk to Tom Halpin at Nunatak about customizing.
Let us know what you decide.Oct 17, 2010 at 10:59 am #1655336
Michael RayBPL Member
I'm no expert, but was in the same situation and did exactly as Mr. Chan suggested. While not an "excellent" brand, I couldn't pass up $120 for a new REI Sub Kilo 20F bag. I have used it on nights from just below 0 to maybe 60F. Has worked great so far, but I've only got maybe 25-30 nights in/under it.Oct 17, 2010 at 12:21 pm #1655358
Erik DanielsenBPL Member
@er1kksenLocale: The Western Door
I'll echo Dan on the Golite quilt, if you can get a good price on it. I snagged one for $150 in the clymb sale and being a down quilt it's been a revelation for me coming from synthetic sleeping bags. You can wear it loosely for comfort in warmer temps or snug it close for comfort in the cold. I am a cold sleeper, and with my old 20 degree synth bag, I was always cold from about 35 degrees on down. Last week when it got down to the low 30s I wore my down jacket to bed with the quilt, figuring I'd need it (I often sleep out to test the temp limits of my gear) and within a few minutes of bundling up I was HOT. I had to ditch the down jacket and sleep in just my normal baselayers. I have never been able to do that below 40 degrees before.
There are lighter quilts out there for the same performance, by a few ounces, but at a steep premium compared to the prices you can probably get the golite at if you wait for a good deal. So keep an eye out.Oct 17, 2010 at 7:26 pm #1655457
" Paul, you are asking open-ended questions.
If you don't know what temperature rating of sleeping bag you need, then you don't want to buy _any_ now.
Do some reading, talk to people, figure out your intended outdoors travel, and get a good idea of what you are getting into. "
…Well thanks. Maybe it would be okay with you if I came to the BPL forums to talk to some people…
Anyway, I really appreciate the help and suggestions. I've been looking into bags a lot recently and have found that a lot of people prefer quilts to bags. I was skeptical. But the comment of it being more like sleeping in your bed at home finally made me understand. Thanks Dan.
I've been wondering about temperature ratings as well. My trip through the Maine section of the AT this summer was done with a cheep bag liner that was on clearance. It went up to my nipples and was probably good to 60 degrees. I had a couple retched nights around 40 degrees or so. And I figure that I'm a pretty cold sleeper, being 6'4" 180lbs with little to no fat (haha that's what College track will do to you). I think a 20 deg bag seems to be a pretty standard three season temp, so I might steer clear of the 30 deg Montbell #3.
I posted a question a couple of days ago about the possibility of making a bag/ quilt. I'm wondering if any of you have found much success with that. Was it worth the materials and labor to make it over buy one?Oct 17, 2010 at 7:39 pm #1655462
Jeffrey McConnellBPL Member
If you have some sewing skills thru hiker has a great quilt kit. Its competitively priced if i remember right. I thought about making my own for a while and I was going to take a basic sewing class, but due to lack of time I had a forum member make me a quilt. I still may take a stab at one later on. I think its worth it if you have the time.Oct 17, 2010 at 7:46 pm #1655466
I'll second what Eric posted- if you can only have one bag, a somewhat roomy mummy bag with a full zipper is extremely versatile (can be a quilt, or can be fully zippered).
I used to use quilts and topbags, but I never found them as warm as a good mummy bag. I'd highly recommend renting a decent mummy bag (try EMS) and fully unzipping it to use as a quilt- then you will know what you prefer. I went through a handful of very expensive options (Rab,WM, Nunatak) based on what worked for other people before finding what I liked.Oct 17, 2010 at 8:05 pm #1655468
Great point. I never even considered this.
Haha, I will definitely do this and see what is going to be best for my body before making a possibly regrettable purchase. Thanks Michael.Oct 18, 2010 at 3:31 pm #1655727
Not to start a bag vs. quilt flame war, but bags are inherently more versatile than quilts. It's easy to open up a sleeping bag & use it like a quilt, but if it's cold out it's much easier and more effective to just zip up a sleeping bag and cinch down the hood and draft collar.
Temp rating really, really depends… 20*F is generally accepted as a good starting point. But do you see yourself doing 50% winter camping, in Minnesota? Then you'd want a warmer bag.
MegaLite is basically wider Summerlite, Alpinlite is wider Ultralite. If you were going 20, say the Ultralite for avg. build.Oct 20, 2010 at 1:42 pm #1656352
I have tried a quilt (Golite), and it did not seem like sleeping in my bed at home (I also had a MB UL spiral down #3). The closest I have gotten to a "at home" experience is sleeping in my Big Agnes Horsethief bag. I have a 2.5 inch insulated Kookabay pad (66" x 20" mummy). It's rated 35 degrees (even though it has 10 oz of 800 down) , but with a pair of MB down pants and a MB down jacket it is plenty warm into the 20's (and I am a 45 year old cold sleeper). With the Sleeping pad inserted into the bottom of the bag (which has no bottom insulation) you cannot roll off the mat, and when you toss and turn the bag stays put. The MontBell #3 rolled around with me, with quilt I moved off the pad because I am a restless sleeper. My BA bag weighs 22 oz and the insulated pad weighs 15 oz.Oct 20, 2010 at 3:11 pm #1656388
@areichowLocale: Northern Minnesota
I'd go with a Montbell UL Spiral #3 (Super if you want it) or a GoLite UltraLight 20 degree quilt. For me, a proper 20 degree bag is more 2-season than three; it's too warm to use in the summer, and too heavy to justify carrying it around. I only recently acquired my Montbell UL Super Stretch #3, but have camped out a few nights with it in the low 30s. I was plenty comfortable in nothing but underwear, t-shirt, and socks on a summer-only sleeping pad (POE Ether Compact 6, R <= 2). I'd feel comfortable taking it below 30 with a UL down sweater, proper base layer, and possibly a light bag liner.
I'm not going to lug around a 15 or 20 degree bag weighing 2.5 lb all summer long, but that's just me. Not everyone can afford having a bag for each use-case, including myself. I try to be as modular and flexible as I can.
Obviously, any recommendation depends on where you plan to use it. I'm in northern Minnesota, which is colder than most of the US year around.Oct 20, 2010 at 4:05 pm #1656419
Something to consider …. If the 10-20f bag is too warm for summer … You can buy a cheap light quilt for summer
you can get away with more mistakes in summerOct 29, 2010 at 9:15 am #1659259
Before I start, I realize that this is a very opinion-based Q&A.
I also realize that the best option for me would be to get two bags for different conditions. I realize this, however, I'm not in a place financially to get two high quality bags.
I've looked into sleeping bags a lot recently and I feel like a mummy bag will be a better fit for my needs. Looking into which bag I should get, I have found very few bad reviews of WM bags.
For some more details on my needs, I'm looking to do the Colorado trail next summer.
Questions for you all:
1) Is the extra 12 F worth the extra $75 and 6oz or so?
2) Would a 20F bag be bearable in summer?
3) Would a 32F bag with a Montbell UL inner jacket be bearable in the fall or early spring or even around 15-20F lows in winter?
4) What other suggestions do you have?Oct 29, 2010 at 9:32 am #1659262
Josh NewkirkBPL Member
I have a montbell ultra light super spiral #1 rated for 15. I might have to get a lighter and cooler bag for summer but i wanted just that extra little bit of cooler weather versatility compared to a 20 degree bag.Oct 29, 2010 at 12:39 pm #1659310
Five StarBPL Member
@mammomanLocale: NE AL
JMHO, but I would purchase a 32 degree (properly rated) down bag or quilt (probably bag in your case) with a full length zipper. You can open it up quilt/blanket style in summer and keep from roasting, and if you properly layer up with a down jacket and pants, etc. in winter you can take it down into the teens any maybe a little further.
Beware though- you may find yourself with this one do-it-all bag, and then in a couple of years you come into some money and want to buy that 2nd bag….which one then? You MIGHT be better off getting a dedicated winter bag (20 degree) first, and make sure you get one season or two nailed right. Then, when you get some more money, you could get a cheap summer quilt. I personally have a 15 degree FF bag, and a 32 thin down Nunatak quilt, and between the two, I'm always comfortable.Oct 29, 2010 at 12:44 pm #1659311
I have a WM Alder MF. It is a 25 degree full zip bag that can be used as a quilt.
I use that in the fall and winter and a Lafuma x600 in the summer. I know you said 1 bag, but for 45 bucks it is nice for summer/spring use.Oct 29, 2010 at 12:50 pm #1659312
a 20F deg bag opened up and used loosely as a quilt can take you up to around 60F deg on the top end … higher than that and you pretty much can get away with sleeping in yr down jacket, some fleece and a bivy
the same bag can likely take you down to 10F or less with yr down jacket, some fleece, long underwear, and maybe a garbage bag for a VBL if needed
in an absolute emergency the same setup might be survivable down to 0F or so … note survivable … not comfortable
IMO a properly rated 20F bag is the way to go for "all seasons" if you needed a single bag … a usable range of 10F-60FOct 29, 2010 at 1:09 pm #1659315
Mary DBPL Member
@hikinggrannyLocale: Gateway to Columbia River Gorge
For the Rockies (you mentioned the Colorado Trail), below-freezing nights and snow can happen any month of the year. An accurately rated 20*F bag is therefore a good idea if you're going there. I'd say the same for the PCT For hot, muggy nights back east you can either use it as a quilt or just sleep on top of it, depending on the temperature.
I have used my 20* WM Ultralight in the midwest (Michigan) and have started nights lying on top of the bag, moved into it (unzipped) or used it as a quilt in the middle of the night and sometimes zipped it most of the way up by morning. I've also had the same experience during hot spells in the Pacific Northwest, although humidity is extremely low when we get those. On the other hand, I have rarely had the bag unzipped even a little when hiking in the Rockies!
Be sure to check the girth measurements of the bag and measure your own to be sure there's room inside for you. Be sure to measure shoulder girth over your arms and over all your insulating clothing (in case of a really frigid night).
Note, since you have a budget issue: You won't find any sales or % off coupons for Western Mountaineering bags, so for a 20*F bag I'd look at the appropriate Montbell bag or the Marmot Helium. Especially the last is more apt to be on sale. With no draft collar, I'd rate it as nearer a 20* bag than the published 15* F. You might save enough to be able to buy an inexpensive 40*-45* F bag for those hot eastern nights!Oct 29, 2010 at 1:11 pm #1659316
I agree with Eric that my do it all bag is a 20 degree, full-zipper, high quality down bag. In my case, a WM Alpinlite.
(Of course, I also have a WM Caribou MF for those warmer summer nights, which packs smaller and is a bit lighter.)Oct 29, 2010 at 1:15 pm #1659319
I use my Summerlite for most 3-seasonish trips with a warm pad at or near the bag rating. It's usually pretty good. However, there are times in early spring or later fall when it's definitely not enough.
Note that if you got the Ultralite, you can easily shift some down underneath you and functionally make it a 50*F bag, so I wouldn't worry at all about it being too hot. The added loft and bomber draft collar would be great if you were pushing seasons or hitting that 15*F mark. If you were going to try to push a Summerlite to 20 or below, I'd plan on wearing a big, hooded poofy jacket, warm pants, and great socks.
If you were primarily thinking summer use with rare times in the 20s, the Summerlite would probably be ok with a warm pad. However, if you're specifically looking for one bag for all/most seasons the Ultralite is probably the safer bet for most people.
Note that the Ultralite is 1.75 pounds (not 2.5#) vs. 1.25 pounds of the Summerlite or MB#3. Also note that there are some discrepancies in Ultralite weights… they hadn't updated their specs from before the "Super" option became standard, so the UL is spec'd at 1#13oz, not 1#10oz… more of a 10oz diff w/the Summerlite. Again, depends on how much use you get at the edge of the shoulder seasons, how warm you tend to sleep, etc.
Edit: @ 5'6" and 165# I'm not exactly a skinny guy, but find I fit in the Summerlite w/a down vest or other insulation just fine. On the other hand, a thinner friend finds the wider-cut bags just barely tolerable in only baselayers. Probably best to try on the bags if you can.Oct 29, 2010 at 4:22 pm #1659375
Eric BlumensaadtBPL Member
@danepackerLocale: Mojave Desert
I've owned a WM Megalite for 3 seasons and found it to be a great bag.
1. As a cool weather bag I've used it down to 24 F. with extra clothers on and slept well. The Megalite is wide enough that when camping in Colorado's Indian Peaks Range in October in low teen temps I had enough room in the bag's wider girth to wear my Thermolite insulated jacket and pants and sleep very comfy.
2. On hot nights in southern Utah's Escalante region I've had my most comfortable nights ever with the Megalite zipped all the way open, foot hooked over my old full length Thermarest Lite and using the bag as a quilt. Closest thing to sleeping at home I've experienced while backpacking.
Remember, the Megalite has no side baffle opposite the zipper side so you can shake some down to either the top or bottom, depending on expected temps. Since the 800 cu. in./oz/down has such great loft ther is only about a 25% change in loft one way or the other using this method.
This bag is extremely versatile and a TRUE 30 F. bag for even cold sleepers like me.Oct 29, 2010 at 4:48 pm #1659388
Ditto on Eric's thoughts on the Megalite. Wide enough to add layers and dip below its rating. Full unzip and it has quilt-like ventilation.
There may still be one fs in the gear swap forum.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.