Esbit – what am I doing wrong?

Bad esbit tabs? Old or damp? You shouldn't have that much trouble lighting them.

I had a couple of bad experiences with Esbit cubes a few years ago. As you know, the surfaces of a cube are pretty smooth and solid, and that helps avoid the cube breaking up prematurely. That also makes it harder to light. So, if I think that I will have any difficulty lighting a cube, I use a knife to carve up the edges where I want to light it. That produces tiny surfaces that are easier to light, but it takes only a few seconds to prepare. The extreme case would be using the knife to chop the whole cube up, but I've never had to go that far.

I found a lot of difference between real Esbit cubes and off-brand cubes.

The other thing is the lighter. I admit to using a mini-bic currently. However, if the weather is colder or I suspect that I could have lighting difficulty, I carry an oversized standard butane lighter that has an adjustable flame control. Then, assuming that I store the lighter in my pocket to keep it warm, I can get a good flame out of it, and that helps light the Esbit.

–B.G.–

Brand new tabs. Came in the red box.

I've found they're much easier to light if I hold the cube at one end and light the other with my Bic. Once it lights and stays lit, I transfer it to my stove and put the Caldera Cone over it.

A drop of alcohol hand sanitizer on the cube gets them started even faster.

When there's any kind of a breeze blowing, you have to have a windscreen of some sort in order to get them to go.

I also used Esbit for the first time on my last trip, same type as Piper. They were much harder to light than I expected. While I didn't have as much trouble as Piper I questioned how easy these would be to light with matches in anything but ideal conditions.

Piper, how were your 6 days on the JMT? (BTW, do you want us to call you Piper, or Diane?) How did the equipment choices you asked for advice about turn out? Hope you had a great time.

Bottom line: They're hard to light.

I also hold the Bic Mini or match under the tab, which I hold in the other hand and transfer to the "stove" after it begins to burn.

The alcohol hand sanitizer idea is brilliant. I'll be trying it this weekend.

Stargazer

I suspect the fuel.

I've used Firelite solid fuel with my BPL Titanium stove with no problems.

There are many youtubes you can watch like http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tq3INcYOy38

You'll see like I've found in my experience that you should be able to light with a match.

Light a match and then rest it on top of the esbit cube such that it will burn for a couple of seconds before the flame reaches the fuel.

If there is not sufficient room for the match to get burning nicely it might snuff out before the fuel is lit. No need to hold the match in your hand while you are waiting for the fuel to catch. For this reason I think matches are the ideal firelighter for esbit. Works equally well for coughlans fuel. Obviously all this should occur inside the windscreen.

Thanks everyone. I will try the sanitizer. I usually will lay the burning match on the cube but there was a breeze. I think the matches were duds, too. Many would not light. I prefer matches to lighters because they're less environmentally toxic. All those poor birds in the Pacific ocean eating lighters bothers me.

My equipment choices worked well. I really liked wearing Chaco sandals. My feet were never happier. I liked my mosquito tent and tarp combo. I could sleep under the stars or use the tarp for privacy (no rain). I liked the skirt, too. Just like shorts only better. If I was cold I could slip on long underwear bottoms and when warmed up take them off without undressing!

I was quite flabbergasted by the enormous packs on the JMT. Some people were really suffering under their loads. One guy had a pack that was so huge but he still added a huge garbage bag and a day pack crammed full on top of it. He admitted to never being able to get into the backcountry far enough.

I passed almost every person I saw because they were all laboring and struggling under their huge loads. Many people made excuses like "I just want to take it slow and take in all the sights." But they walked with their heads down and didn't look very happy. I know that I intimidated one macho man who didn't like a girl in a skirt and sandals blowing by on the way up to Dusy Basin. He wanted to convince me my attire and gear were inappropriate. He also said not to be surprised if I had to step aside later when he needed to pass him. Ha! That never happened!

Call me Piper or Diane. Don't matter.

take your knife and scrape a portion of the cube- enough that it leaves a small pile of "crumbs"- light the "crumbs" w/ either a lighter or a match

I've had very good luck w/ that method- not scraping the cube will definitely take more of an effort

I basically do the same thing, but drill with the tip of my knife. The powder lights pretty easily.

Putting the match on top won't do much– gotta get under an edge. The alcohol gel works great and you can light it off with a firesteel or a spark wheel.

when i use them, i bring a minidropper of alcohol–one or two drops on top and i can get it going right away with a firesteel, match or lighter

http://www.turboflame.co.uk/turbostick.php something like this works well apparently. I haven't used esbit stoves in 30 years after having to use them to cook meals requiring 30 minute simmers, without a wind shield using a tent with no vestibule on Dartmoor in February.

I had the same problem last year- I had bought a Big Stash of a couple of brands and did not use them for about 2-3 yrs. They were stored sealed as shipped and placed inside a tight ziplock the whole time in the basement.

Very hard to light…

I got rid of them all after that trip.

I always did notice a strong fuel odor from them and now assume much of the fuel evaporated out of the solid base and through the packaging over time.

My advice is to buy small qtys, date them, and plan on testing one from each batch before every trip.

My wife and I just got back from the Wind River Range and used esbit for all of our cooking. I use the REI light under water matches or their equivalent. At 10,000' bic lighters don't don't work for s—.

Have some aging tabs so I did a test. Have been stored in ziplock. The one I tested had the foil off, but was still in the plastic container.

I put on stove and held a match by corner. Was surprised that it lit with one match (the match burned half way through when it lit) – a matter of seconds.

Convinces me that the fuel tabs are the culprit. If you get a bad batch or they get too old then your chances of failure increase. But, like my test showed – sometimes they work well when you don't expect them to do so.

I have used esbit a lot using the match-under-a-hanging-edge method. Good to know of the other "tricks' listed above. I have had problems with old matches not lighting, too.

"I have had problems with old matches not lighting, too."

Me too. Those Coghlan's matches are the worst.

Now I carry the cheapest paper match book plus a mini-bic lighter.

–B.G.–

I was expecting failure when I tested my old fuel tabs. I got the Coghlan matches in 2004. I think there were four or more boxes packaged together when I got them.

Most of the boxes contained mostly duds. But this sole remaining box (have not bought matches like that since then because of the high failure rate) has matches that always light. They gotten wet a few times.

Like the solid fuel tabs, you never know until you use one. But I believe you can be confident on the box level in the case of matches or the package for tabs. Must be the result of the manufacturing process.

I guess now I'm really disappointed by esbit. I used to use it long ago. I got it at an army surplus store. The cubes were smaller and it normally took two of them to make breakfast or dinner. But I never had a problem with them.

Now I buy "consumer grade" esbit and I have to worry that it might be bad even if brand new? I have to carry alcohol to get it to light?

I think I will stick to my alcohol stove.

The only good thing to come out of this whole experiment was that I made a really nice pot stand/wind screen out of a Fosters can.

I found a big difference in the lightability factor between true Esbit cubes and the generic fuel cubes. I quit using the generic ones.

–B.G.–

Here's another thought. You said you're using the bottom of a pepsi can as a platform for your esbit fuel. That might be contributing to the problem because (if I am visualising it properly) you have a shallow bowl holding the fuel tab. Esbit needs quite a lot of air to burn properly. That's why the official folding stove has those 8 small air holes surrounding the fuel platform. If it's not getting enough air it might be harder to light…