Topic

Bottle filters and justdrink.net

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Jim Nordby BPL Member
PostedJun 28, 2006 at 8:35 am

Hi,

My last trip my partner and I just used bottle filters (both Katadyn, mine was a filter, he had the purifier w/ iodine matrix). Though the bottles were not the easiest to get water out of, I loved not having to pump water! All the other water we used (for cooking) was boiled so I didn’t worry about that.

Two questions:
– has anyone used the bottle filters found at justdrink.net? If so, how did they perform? I noticed they also produced an inline _purifier_ that inactived viruses, similar to how the First Need filter works.

– can anyone especially recommend other brands of bottle filters (I’m looking for something that would get both protozoa and bacteria, not just protozoa). I may have to get another filter this summer, and the Katadyn ones were fine, but I was wondering if any others are especially good.

PostedJun 28, 2006 at 11:27 am

Advice: I would do a little research inside the NSF Site too see if a filter is tested & certified to reduce the contaminants you desire. Multi-Pure Introduces “Emergency Drinking Water Unit” In response to customer and distributor demand for a drinking water unit for emergency use, Multi-Pure has repackaged its plastic countertop unit specifically for that purpose. The Model MP400PCE comes equipped with a quick-release inlet fitting, hose and diverter valve, and a handpump. The easy-to-use inlet fitting can be connected to the hose and diverter valve or to the handpump without the need of disconnecting and replacing the inlet fitting, making it much easier for the user to convert from countertop use to emergency handpump use. Although the system is designed for emergency use, it may also be used as a countertop unit. This unit uses the CB5 replacement filter. MP400PCE

This is Chris Anderson,
I have been educating consumers & others in the drinking water field for over 10 years.
How do you choose a water filter? What does the filter actually reduce or remove? And finally what does it cost? These answers are found by doing a little research or home work will call it. Doing such will save you a lot of money and provide you with pure “healthy” drinking water. The bottom line is you must get a Data Performance Sheet by the NSF national sanitation foundation to compare filters. These “proof of performance” sheets show exactly what the filter does and for how many gallons. If you can’t get one from the manufacturer or from who ever is trying to sell you one, simply say no thanks!

Please visit my Water Filter Facts site and bookmark it for future use.

http://www.solidcarbonblock.NET

The direct link to view products, prices and gather more information is here.

http://www.multipureusa.com/canderson

Ps. Should you have any questions in the drinking water field, please write.
waterfilters@gmail.com
Thank you for your time and consideration,
Chris Anderson Independent Distributor of Multipure Drinking Water Systems #223193

Consumers Digest BEST BUY!
Multi-Pure is pleased that a Multi-Pure Drinking Water System has been selected as a BEST BUY in water filtration systems by Consumers Digest. Consumers Digest’s BEST BUY products must have their performance certified under NSF/ANSI Standards.
“We are honored to, once again, receive this recognition,” says H. Allen Rice, CEO of Multi-Pure International. “With so many drinking water systems to choose from, NSF certification helps consumers make the right choice — Multi-Pure.”
Multi-Pure Drinking Water Systems provide consumers the best in performance, the best warranty, and Consumers Digest BEST BUY!

PostedJun 28, 2006 at 2:40 pm

Jim, when you say that it’s not easy to get the water out, do you mean that the water passes through the filter very slowly? I’d been thinking about getting one of the Katadyn bottle filters, but when I tested it at REI’s water filter setup, the water just seemed to dribble out of the bottle at an extremely low rate. My plan had been to use the bottle filter to fill up a second water bottle, but that seemed like it would take far too long.

Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedJun 28, 2006 at 2:53 pm

I got one of the Bota bottles and was dissapointed. You won’t suck the water through– not much at least– your ears will touch if you really try. Squeezing is the thing and it is still no downpour. Once I thought about it, it makes sense– consider the pressure and mechanical advantage needed to use a pump.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJun 28, 2006 at 2:57 pm

Joseph:

I was thinking exactly the same thing! Wouldn’t it be nice to scoop one bottle of water, squeeze it through the filter to a second bottle, then scoop again. Voila, one bottle already filtered, and the second to be filtered as I drink (suck).

But the devil is in the details (as always). Reading your and Dale’s feedback, it seems like my plan wouldn’t really work any faster or easier than just old fashioned pumping?!?

Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedJun 28, 2006 at 3:23 pm

“Reading your and Dale’s feedback, it seems like my plan wouldn’t really work any faster or easier than just old fashioned pumping?!?”

I didn’t throw mine away– it might be okay for the retrn leg of a day hike or travel. IMHO, if you already have a resonably lightweight pump, stick with that.

Jim Nordby BPL Member
PostedJun 29, 2006 at 11:39 am

Yes, it takes a certain amount of sucking _and_ squeezing the bottle to get the water out. I know others have found this too tedious, but I didn’t consider it a problem. Trying to fill another bottle from the filter bottle, though, would be a big pain.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...