After staring at a lot of stove images online, it seems that there are basically five kinds of windscreens.
1. screen remote from the stove (ie kite screen). I see this usually with cannister stoves which I believe is to avoid the risk of explosion.
2. tightly hugging screen (ie Caldera cone). Just from observation, this appears to trap hot air around the pot.
3. screen that overlaps over the pot (ie simple aluminum foil in a cylinder around the pot and stove). I assume this also keeps the pot warm and shielded from wind.
4. screen just for the flame (ie Snow Peak screen/Giga stove). Seems this is just to protect the flame.
5. no screen (ie Bushbuddy).
Ignoring #1,is there really a significant difference on the effectiveness of a screen that encompasses the pot+flame vs. just the flame?

