Topic

tent for me, me + friend, me + 2 kids

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
PostedApr 29, 2010 at 12:39 pm

I'm starting the journey into UL by replacing my really heavy old 3-season tent. I'm hoping to find a mostly 3-season tent that will work for me solo, me plus a 2nd adult, and me plus my 2 kids (7 yrs. and 5 yrs.). I'm thinking a tarptent Rainshadow2. I'm curious if anyone else out uses a tent for a similar set of circumstances, or any comments on the Rainshadow2 in general (I've read the 2 comments in the user reviews, and would love to hear more.).

For what it's worth, I've never had a single-walled tent, and I also suspect I won't be hiking with hiking poles.

PostedApr 29, 2010 at 1:07 pm

I'm trying to get back into backpacking, so things may change, but…

I envision one 5-7 day trip with a friend somewhere in North America in the summer, and May – September solo or with-kid trips in the Colorado mountains. I'd like something that I don't mind using if there's a few inches of snow on the ground, but I don't envision using this for winter camping.

I'd guess a temperature range of 15 – 55F for lows. I tend to like to hike at higher elevations (I live in Colorado).

Nico . BPL Member
PostedApr 29, 2010 at 1:11 pm

I don't have lots of experience with all the various lightweight shelters out there but I do have a rainshadow 2, so I can speak to that tent.

The Rainshadow 2 has quite a bit of room. I'd say it's a pretty legit three-person tent in terms of usable floor area. I often use it for trips with my girlfriend and our 90 lb dog. It's more than enough room for the three of us. Without the dog, it starts to feel palatial. By myself, it would be way over the top in terms of size, but not really that much of a weight penalty over say, the Squall 2, in the bigger scheme of things if you're trying to get by with a one-size-fits-all approach to your shelter.

On the other hand, if most of your trips are with just one other, you might be able to squeeze yourself plus two kids into a slightly smaller 2-person tent on the occasional basis. This would cut down the weight a little. On a lot of the tarp tents you can flatten out the bathtub floor when rain isn't expected to gain a little extra usable floor space.

Set-up is easy. Workmanship on all of the tarptents is top notch. Stormworthiness probably depends on where you live and what kind of conditions you anticipate to use it in. Where I camp, we get wind and rain (not very much of it though) and the tent has worked great so far.

The only thing you'll probably need to work on a little is managing condensation. This isn't unique to just this tent though, it goes for just about all single wall shelters. Pitching the rear end into the wind, utlizing a higher pitch in nice weather, leaving the vestibule (and if possible, no-see-um doors) open will all serve towards effectively managing condensation. Obviously the amount of condensation in the tent goes up with the number of people sleeping in the tent.

If you haven't already, try giving Henry Shires a call or email and ask him for his input. He's been super helpful with trying to select the right tent for the right needs.

PostedApr 29, 2010 at 1:53 pm

Nicholas,

Since a 90lb dog might be as spazzy as 2 kids, do you ever worry about the dog ripping the bug mesh or anything of that sort?

PostedApr 29, 2010 at 1:57 pm

William, it looks pretty cool. But I think the 54" floor width might preclude me plus kids from sleeping in it. Or do you think it might be feasible?

I think it may be better to err on the large side for this purchase, in the hopes (naive?) that my wife will let me get a solo tent in the near-ish future :)

Nico . BPL Member
PostedApr 29, 2010 at 2:54 pm

Yeah, the dog has gone through the bug mesh door once. He wanted to find the fastest way out of the tent to go play with another dog and one good swipe with his paw and a lunge forward was enough to tear the mesh with his nails.

Henry fixed up the door and it's as good as new now.

Other than that, the tent has held up really well. The floor and walls are pretty tough. No tears, etc. from the dog or people so far.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedApr 29, 2010 at 3:17 pm

OK, I think I have this straight: It's you solo, you plus second adult OR you plus two young children, right? It's another poster that has the 90 lb. dog, right? And you plus the second adult won't be going with the children? That would probably be OK now but not when the kids get a bit bigger. The same would be true of a two-person tent like the Tarptent Double Rainbow or the SMD Lunar Duo–they'd be fine now, but in a couple of years they'll be too crowded.

The Tarptent Rainshadow works fine for my son plus two of his kids (now 8 and 10). They have used it for several years, although not in the high mountain conditions that you'd be using it in. However, the tent has been well-tested a number of times by two kids plus my dog running at full speed through the guylines! (No damage!) With trekking poles or with the poles that Henry Shires sells extra, you'd want two of them for more stability. Using two poles makes it easier to get in and out, too! With this tent, IMHO, it's mandatory to add the optional side guylines and stakes. We haven't had any condensation issues with the Rainshadow, even in fog and drizzle on Washington's Olympic coast. This was at the same time that I felt like I was swimming inside my SMD Lunar Solo pitched right next door! Condensation would be more of a problem on a cold night with the tent pitched out in a meadow (which I know you often have to do in Colorado to avoid being within reach of the bark beetle-killed trees).

While the Rainshadow is fine for two or three, I suspect that eventually you'll want a lighter and smaller tent (the Rainshadow's footprint is pretty big) for solo use. There are lots of used Tarptent Contrails for sale now because a lot of folk have switched to Henry's newest tent, the Moment.

If four of you go together when the kids are a little bigger, you'll either need a four-person tent or, better IMHO, a second two-person tent.

PostedApr 29, 2010 at 3:43 pm

You are correct, I do not have a dog. And I do not anticipate having 2 adults and 2 kids in there. Sounds like the Rainshadow is the way to go for me, at least now.

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
Loading...