My wife and I both have MB thermawraps that we really like. Here goes the million dollar question…Can you justify having both the thermawrap and inner parka in the closet. Would there ever be a case where you would carry both in the field? When would you leave the thermawrap at home and carry the parka?
Topic
MB down inner parka
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
This is kind of like the down v.s synthetic argument for sleeping bags I would think?
Synthetic (Thermawrap) better for wet conditions at the cost of weight.
Down (Inner Parka) Lighter at the expense of it getting wet its not that good.
but since the actual weight difference is really only ~2/3ish ounces depending on size.. I don't think it really matters but is a personal preference.
I would carry the down inner if colder temps were expected. It is a lot warmer than the thermawrap. If rain was expected I might consider the synthetic.
During a particular cold stretch of trail…We had been out on the trail for months and we were into fall season. With temperatures predicted to fall rapidly, I added a the thermawrap as a just-in-case measure. It dipped below 10 degrees in the North Cascades and while I didn't hike with both on more than just to get warmed up in the mornings, it was great when I was in the bag at night. I had a 10 degree bag with me and I needed every bit of insulation as it never got much above freezing for a week. But it was a strange time, I was thin, lean hiking machine and operating at a calorie deficit most of the time. I felt I needed it and the extra ounces didn't matter much by that time.
Having used both, I really like the down a lot better as it is much warmer. You just can't afford to get it wet.
If I had both jackets I would probably never take just the thermawrap. The parka is warmer and lighter. As far as getting it wet … well don't do it. Whatever you use to protect yourself from rain will also work great at protecting the down parka (its shell is pretty resistant by itself). Also, neither will be terribly warm when wet.
If I didn't have a thicker parka I might consider bringing both when temps were going to drop below ~20degF while I want to be in camp but then I again if I didn't have a warmer parka and I had both the thermawrap and the down inner I would probably just sell the thermawrap for a warmer down jacket (like the alpine light)
Become a member to post in the forums.

