Topic

TD Caldera Cone for an MSR Titan Mug

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
PostedApr 22, 2010 at 3:31 pm

I picked up an MSR Titan Mug recently because I like the compact size and I don't need to boil very much water. I thought I would go online and pick up a caldera cone for the mug from Trail Designs. Turns out, they don't make one for the Titan.

I contacted TD, we exchanged a couple of emails and they agreed to make on for me. I made arrangements to meet at Russell's "lab" in San Jose to pick it up.

When I arrived Russell tried the mug in the cone and didn't like the fit, so he says "Let's make a new one".

Good for me! I got to see one produced from scratch.

Russell has it down to a science with specialized tooling and jigs. He cuts the Ti to shape with a custom wheeled cutter tool thing, punches the holes with an, um, punch; then presses the grooves with a custom hydraulic die press and voila, caldera cone!

A nip and tuck here and there and it's all done.

I used the cone in anger for the first time this last weekend and it worked very well….boiled my water quickly with no fuss. The cone makes up part of a 5-6 oz cook kit.

It was a real pleasure to meet Russell and watch him work. Trail Designs really treated me right and I appreciate it.

. . BPL Member
PostedApr 22, 2010 at 10:38 pm

Wow Watson, so it took you 20 minutes to conceive (oh wait, that was someone else), take measurements, calculate proper air flow, design the cone, make a template, purchase the materials, pick up the materials, get the tools, make the dovetail, drill the holes, test the fit, reinforce the connection, adjust, test to make sure it is up to proper efficiency, and then make the alcohol stove as well, plus purchase a fuel bottle and find the perfect protective case?

Can I hire you?

I commend your DIY spirit, but lets also give props where props is due: the gentlemen at Trail Designs are wonderful to work with and have provided a labor of love at reasonable prices to cover their IDEA, time, tooling, operational expenses, and materials, that many have benefited from.

Yo – a shout out to Russ 'n' crew/ peace y'all.

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 8:32 am

david, i have a 550 cone setup. its been my favorite piece of gear since i've had it! although, i just got a fosters keg setup and have yet to try it out. doh!
best stove system out IMO

te – wa BPL Member
PostedApr 23, 2010 at 8:38 am

this has piqued my ear now, since ive been wondering if there is a caldera cone that will fit the 10cm imUSA aluminum mug. it has a rolled lip around the rim, so it seems it will work great and possibly the same size circumference as one of the cones already available. anyone have a clue?

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 4:26 pm

I guess this video is legal…

But, Mr. Watson, I hope someday you get to personally experience the theft of your creativity and labor.

…end rant

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 4:30 pm

Ah, so all cars are made by the same company, vcr's, dvd players etc.
why, isn't this website the product of copying itself, or was it the first ever online forum. ?

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 5:07 pm

Btw, for your info, i contacted TD for a cone for my litech trek kettle, they didn't do one. ; )

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 5:12 pm

I dont see people go apesh!t when members make their own bushbuddy, tarps, bivies, etc, why so protective of the calderas?

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedApr 23, 2010 at 5:22 pm

I wouldn't worry about it, one way or the other.

The guys at TD are always a step or two ahead of a garage shop design. They can make them slightly better and cheaper than a DIY guy.

I watched that video clip and took notes on how many design "gotchas" there were. It showed a good garage shop design, but there are design holes.

–B.G.–

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 5:28 pm

Yup, it is flawed in some ways but does make a working cone for us who can't get an off the shelf one.
Edit: Just to add, i can easily make a cone for any pot now but i'd never do it for anyone besides myself, making a profit on someone else's design i totally disagree with.

Rand Lindsly BPL Member
PostedApr 23, 2010 at 5:33 pm

I have no record of any "G Watson" contacting me about a litech trek kettle. In fact we have made cones for one version of the litech trek kettle them in the past…..and make other "off the menu" cones for people all the time.

As to not seeing people explode over copying the BushBuddy….seriously?!?!? Dude…..go look up the international melt down that happened when backpackinglight.co.uk put out the "BushCooker"….omg….

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 5:43 pm

I e-mailed you maybe 18 months back, maybe longer when trail magazine featured the cone in a stove comparison test, i also asked on Outdoors Magic if anyone knew of a pot on your list that was the same dimensions as the litech.
Fair enough it wasn't mailed under my user name here but my personal e-mail address.
with the attitude here i'm not posting my e-mail addy for you to check but feel free to pm me on OM or LFTO and i'll supply it you.
Geoff.

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 5:57 pm

Btw, been accused of being a thief and dare i say a liar, any more for any more.
Thanks for the kind welcome. : )

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 6:01 pm

Brandon,
A few posts up from my rant you can see where G Watson edited his brag on ripping the Caldera Cone. Posting the video link was his spiteful retort to the slapdown that followed.

I don't object to copying good stuff, but the video specifically says "Caldera Cone". Not 'Make a Cone'. There is no attribution to Trail Designs or props for their good work. If someone follows the video and then things perform poorly, for various reasons, and they then badmouth the "Caldera Cone", that is not good. If they do this with a canister stove and it blows up, and they blame the "Caldera Cone" that is not good.

The cone is simple and easy to make. So call it a MYOG Cone and give credit to Trail Designs for inspiration.

But my real objection here is someone actively advocating "rip and run." That doesn't belong on BPL, IMHO.

And since it is obvious that "entitlement" supersedes all else, only a personal loss would drive the point home.

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 6:08 pm

I didn't "brag", i didn't make the video either, i said it was possible to make a cone for a 3rd the price in 20 minutes, shall i post a vid of me doing so. ?
No i don't have a machine shop or intend to help other or myself making money on someone else's design, as i've said already i'd never agree with such underhand practises.
Currently i'm using a 2 piece cone, made by myself.
As i've proved i tried to buy an original cone, at the time it wasn't possible. !
Anyway, call me al you like, take me to court, your pathetic.

Btw David, sorry for turning your thread into a free for all, my original post was with the best of intentions.

PostedApr 24, 2010 at 5:36 pm

Well 24 hrs on and no pm from Rand, my link proved my point any way, i'll now leave with my integrity intact, if a moderator can delete my account. (please)
I have no wish to be involved with such a spiteful accusatory and defamatory community, well those who accused me of such things any way.
Good luck on the trail all.
Geoff.

Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
Loading...