Topic

Need some help on a pack for a small framed lady

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedApr 21, 2010 at 2:40 pm

My fiancee and I are having the worst time trying to find the right pack for her. So far we've tried the Golite Jam 2 and one of those cuben fiber packs with no luck at all. I've done a lot of reading on older posts but I've figured that I should get some help before spending more money. I'm thinking of trying out the ULA Conduit or Osprey Ariel 55 but I just don't know anymore. She is around 5'1"-5'2" and 110-115lbs. Thank you for your help.

PostedApr 21, 2010 at 4:04 pm

I tried a couple of frameless packs, the GG Virga and the GoLite jam, and even with a base weight of only 10 or 11 lbs, I can't stand them. With my internal frame pack I am still at 10-11 lbs (17-18 with food, fuel and water).

If she is willing to try a pack with a frame, my son used a small Osprey EXOS 46 pack when he was 5'2". He and I now use a medium and MAN are they comfortable. You can probably pick one up around here for $110-$120, and sell it for the same if you don't like it.

PostedApr 22, 2010 at 10:39 am

My wife tried on at least twenty packs when she wanted to lighten up from her Lowe Sirocco. In her experience, the light and ultralight packs just did not work — the shoulder harnesses were too wide and dug into her neck, and they mostly didn't curve around the curvy bits at all. Only a few packs had a short-enough torso length and short-enough hip belt (my daughter finds this even more difficult — on every pack she has tried, the hip belt pads or wings meet in the middle before the hip belt is tight.) Most UL packs at the time were made for men.

My wife ended up with an Osprey Ariel 55, which comes in several torso lengths and has interchangeable hip belts and shoulder harnesses. The suspension system is the best she has tried — it fits, and it works. It appears to have been designed for women (fancy that!) None of our local outfitters carried the Ariel 55 — one said it was too small for backpacking, and tried to steer us to the Ariel 65. So we bought the pack when we were in Colorado, at a dealer that had the full line of Osprey products.

The only serious downside to the Ariel is the weight — it's almost 4 pounds empty (hers is 61.5 ounces.) Also, because of the design of the pack, it does stick up over her shoulders enough that she can't wear a wide-brimmed hat without it banging into the pack. Annoying.

In our experience, carrying comfort is more important that uber-light-weight, so the Ariel 55 is a huge win.

Good luck.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedApr 22, 2010 at 11:07 am

First, remember that height doesn't have much of anything to do with torso length or pack size. I'm 5'6" and I've seen guys 6'4" fit the same size pack I wear. Make sure you have a great torso length.

Realize that even if you know her exact torso length, and you know for a fact that it's been measured properly, 4 different packs from the same company in the same torso size can all fit completely differently.

You say the packs haven't worked at all. What hasn't worked about them? What aspect(s) of the fit?

When I fit uber-tiny women, I've found that the GoLite Pursuit tends to work well. They don't make a women's version any more, but just discontinued for spring, so you should still be able to find the pack. The Osprey Aura packs tend to fit smaller women well. The Gregory Jade series comes in an XS size that can fit tiny women well, too.

The Ariel packs have been best-sellers for us for years… Two interesting points about that. One, since bringing in the GoLite Quest I've found that ~35% of people find the Quest a more comfortable fit (unscientific number, all you scientists!). Second interesting point: for really small women the Ariel might not get short enough. Below roughly 16" I seem to start running into more fit problems.

She really needs to be able to try on several packs side-by-side; sounds like you've been doing mail-order on the packs. Is there a good shop within a couple hours of you? Seems like a long drive, but if she gets fitted properly it might save you both some headaches. If the only shop isn't all that well stocked, I'd order a small women's Pursuit, a small Aura, and an XS Jade 60 to start… if I'm interpreting your troubles right.

PostedApr 22, 2010 at 11:28 am

Thanks for sharing this nightmare with me everyone. Seems like we've all encountered this problem. I think, at least so far, the problem is with frameless packs. I will keep trying packs and see how well it works. I'm planning to try the GoLite ones first since they are the most affordable; I've ordered the Lite-speed but second-guessing myself because it seems a bit on the low capacity side. I'll probably try out the Quest or Pursuit and the Gregory Jade–the dimensions seem very good on paper. I'll leave the Ariel and Aura to last since they are pretty heavy.

What do you think about the SMD Traveler?

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedApr 22, 2010 at 12:38 pm

Just FWIW, the Jade 50 & Aura 50 both weigh 3 pounds. The Lite-speed will be way to small. The Pursuit (also 50L) weighs 2.5 pounds. I have no experience w/the Traveler, but it looks like a 1-size fits all adjustable frame? Presumably unisex harness/belt? I've heard of women using them, & they're a 0.5 pound lighter than the Pursuit, but guessing if you're having fit trouble gender-specific model will help…

PostedApr 23, 2010 at 1:04 pm

I'm going to agree with Brad, the Lightspeed women's version is a pretty small pack. Not sure why the men's version was so much larger in capacity (IIRC men's = ~3000ci, women's = ~2000ci.)

The Traveler is the panel load version of the Starlite, which I use and love dearly. The current version may allow a short enough torso length, but like many one-size-fits-all packs, it does this by lowering the shoulder harness. She ends up with half the pack towering over her head. (Yes, my lovely wife tried the Starlite.)

In my experience, which is actually my wife's and daughter's experience, a frameless ruck isn't necessarily a good choice for women. The weight needs to ride on her hips, so good transfer is paramount. YMMV.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...