Topic

recommend a camcorder?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
Gabriel Pramuk BPL Member
PostedApr 20, 2010 at 11:49 pm

I want to get a camera that would be good enough to make a high quality DVD of my upcoming NFCT paddle.

I didn't bother looking for a past post on this because that sort of technology gets outdated pretty quick.

I want! HD, 3CCD, flash memory. Ability to take still shots with it. Price is an issue so I suppose I can drop the 3ccd part if necessary. Waterproofness adds way too much money so I am just going to dry bag it for gnarly bits. If I happen to dump it in Lake Champlain I don't want to feel absolutely horrible about dumping $1000+

Sanyo VPC-SH1R High Definition Camcorder and 10 MP Camera is about the minimum I would want
and something like the
Canon VIXIA HF S100 Flash Memory camcorder might be in the upper price range.

Weight is of course a concern. I will have to carry an extra battery, extra cards, plugs, and a specific waterproof bag.

Ideas?

PostedApr 21, 2010 at 5:51 am

One thing you might consider is getting a still camera that takes videos, rather than a straight "video camera." Most of the new digital cameras have some kind of video capability. I've used a Canon G10 and a Panasonic GF1 for video, and they both do very well. Take a look around and let your wallet be your guide.

Jennifer W BPL Member
PostedApr 21, 2010 at 6:12 am

Not sure if this camera is 3ccd, but it comes with several different type of mounts and we've had it in canyons in Zion, mounted on helmets in the sand dunes in California, on x-country ski trips, through waterfalls, everywhere, and it takes really good video. Plus, it's only 6 ounces, including the battery and waterproof housing.

I'm actually getting rid of all my other camcorder equipment while it's still worth something, because this little camera is so good. We just hang it around our necks, so it can be passed around so everyone can get video and be in the shots. I have the original one and just got the HD version, wow, this camera is nice. If you want to see some you tube videos of some of our trips, using the original, non HD version, look up "Canyoneering Seven Teacups" in August 2009 or "Heaps Canyon Canyoneering May 2009."

I have absolutely no affiliation with this company, I just love this thing. The only limiting factor for you may be card size or battery life, not sure what you require.

Ben BPL Member
PostedApr 21, 2010 at 8:07 am

I have a HFS100 and it is absolutely brilliant. The quality of the images is great, the battery life is pretty good and its nice and small in your hand but still has a huge lens.

PostedApr 21, 2010 at 9:03 am

Have you looked into these? I have a VADO HD, it's about the size of touch-screen phone, weighs about 4-5oz and takes really awesome 720p HD vids! A good buddy of mine has a Flip HD, where I got the idea to get one in the first place, and he absolutely loves his!

Both work on flash memory, both are pretty light, both come with built-in, super easy software, and both are fairly inexpensive… fairly =D I got mine on sale, so look out for those!

Hope this helps!

Clint

PostedApr 21, 2010 at 10:20 am

Check out the Panasonic ZS3 or the newer model. It's a still camera, but does hi def flash video. It's rated highly by Consumer Reports and various internet digital camera sites. I bought one several months ago and am vary happy with it. I can't believe how nice the video is from this camera.

Gabriel Pramuk BPL Member
PostedApr 21, 2010 at 11:01 am

I am kinda stubborn.

I like the idea of the GoPro HD Hero for whitewater shots, head mounted… I appreciate the input all, thanks.

I should throw in that I want zoom options. The still cameras that do HD and the flips just don't have the kind of zoom that I would want. Even toy camcorders have 12-15x optical zoom with double that in digital zoom.

and isn't 720p inherently NOT HD? I thought it was 1080.

If my trip goes well and I get good footage, I wouldn't mind submitting to a local outdoorsy film festival. or the NFCT paddler film fest. I just don't see still camera video being projected in front of an audience.

-thanks

PostedApr 21, 2010 at 11:41 am

"I am kinda stubborn."

Your choice.

"I like the idea of the GoPro HD Hero for whitewater shots, head mounted… I appreciate the input all, thanks."

If you want headmounted, then you've definitely limited the kind of camera/videocam you can get. You're not going to kayak down rapids holding a videocam.

"I should throw in that I want zoom options. The still cameras that do HD and the flips just don't have the kind of zoom that I would want. Even toy camcorders have 12-15x optical zoom with double that in digital zoom."

Most of the smaller point and shoot cameras have both video and zoom. My older G10 does 640×480, and has a large zoom range. I would suggest staying away from digital zoom, however, as it will degrade the image quality.

"and isn't 720p inherently NOT HD? I thought it was 1080."

There are different HD standards, including 720p, 1080i, and 1080p. My GF1 does 720p, and produces very good quality video. I would *assume* that you'd have to go to a dedicated, and larger. videocam for 1080p.

"If my trip goes well and I get good footage, I wouldn't mind submitting to a local outdoorsy film festival. or the NFCT paddler film fest. I just don't see still camera video being projected in front of an audience."

Supposedly the last show of this season for House M.D. was shot with a Canon 5D Mark II, a still camera. Not that you'd want to hold that while paddling, of course. :-)

PostedApr 21, 2010 at 11:44 am

720p is considered HD, 1080p is full HD. DVDs are less than 720p.

If you want good enough HD footage for a film festival, controlling shake has become even more important in the HD era. Consider putting some of your coin toward a rock steady tripod. Otherwise shoot slightly wide and have Final Cut Pro stabilize it, though I found results of this mixed.

Mirco four thirds cameras can still suit you needs. The GF1 and G10 are very capable and light, though only doing 720p. 10x zoom can come from their 14-140mm kit lens. Body and lens should run under $800.

Edit: Lens alone was $800, woops. Cheapest way to go DSLR is combine the kit 14-42 and 45-200 with a g10 for ~$880.

PostedApr 21, 2010 at 3:34 pm

Gabriel
I think that I understand what you are after and no the GoPro and most still cameras will not do it.
Again most work by numbers. 720 and 1080 are a quantity not directly related to quality. Same as you can have a lousy 12mp still camera but a good one that only shoots 6mp.

The size/tytpe of sensor and the type of lens used make a big difference.
One that I would look at right now is the Panasonic HDC TM 700.
3x CMOS, 35-420mm (equivalent) optical stabiliser
AVHD (needs a quad processor to edit) or H264 (Mac friendly)
Manual focus/exposure. Mic in, headphone socket
Franco

Miner BPL Member
PostedApr 21, 2010 at 5:09 pm

Both Sony and Canon make some good HD camcorders (Survivor Man uses several different Sony models though I hate the proprietary flash memory format sony uses). I used a Canon HF S100 for my PCT thru-hike last year and was very happy with the results. Even the 8megapixel stills from photo mode turned out well.

No matter what camera you end up with, I recommend adding a circular polarizer filter. If you think you will be doing alot of filming in the sun, a lens hood also might be good. You also may consider adding a small lav mic for when recording yourself or others talking in noisy conditions as most camera mics will pick up everything, especially wind. A good cheap one is the Audio-Technica ATR3350 OMNI CONDENSER LAV MICROPHONE that will work fine with the Canon or most other camcorders mic plug.

PostedApr 21, 2010 at 6:35 pm

Excellent points about the "accessories" Sean.
Wind noise in particular can kill an otherwise good video and you still need some "ambient "sound.
Sony is moving away very quickly from Memory Stick to SD.
One of the reasons that I mentioned that Pana is the wider than most lens. 35mm is not very wide at all but many start at over 40 up to 50mm.
Wide converters inevitably produce a lot of flare. However a 0.7 will still work and it will take a 35mm lens down to about 24mm if required

Franco

BER — BPL Member
PostedApr 24, 2010 at 8:43 am

Gabriel, I don't know if this would fit your bill, but I posted this camcorder for sale in the gear swap forum a couple months ago. Still have. Still in great condition. Still cheap, comparatively. It is not HD, but does make good quality standard definition video.

JVC Everio 30GB Hard Disk Camcorder, 35x Optical Zoom.
Model GZ-MG330, original packaging and all original box contents.

Used only a couple times. Video turns out to NOT be my thing…

Accessories:
Extra JVC NB-VF823U Battery Pack
Lezura carrying case

PostedApr 24, 2010 at 12:45 pm

I see that now there is the HFS 200 which permits simultaneous motion and still photography.

It all makes my old, once state-of-the-art Canon Hi 8 videotape camcorder seem very obsolete.

Now I want NEW gear! (Why is nobody surprised?:)

Eric

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
Loading...