Topic

Six Moon Designs Pack Sizing

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Kari Post BPL Member
PostedApr 18, 2010 at 6:56 am

I'm going to buy the SMD Traveler and I'm deciding which components to get with it. I'm having the hardest time deciding what size hip belt to get.
http://www.sixmoondesigns.com/shop/shopexd.asp?id=59

The pack I use now is an Osprey Talon 44 size S/M (although I have a 19 inch torso so its just barely long enough). I like to wear my packs so they hug my iliac crest instead of sit on top of it like some people do, so I measured the waist belt from the base of one clip to the tip of the other clip from how I wore it on an overnight trip this weekend and I got 31.5 inches. The padded section measures about 24 inches with the remaining 5.5 inches being the adjusted webbing. I find this pack VERY comfortable and it fits me well. Temps for my hike this weekend were in the 50s to low/mid 60s, with some showers. I wore lightweight hiking pants, two very light and thin synthetic shirts, and a too bulky rain parka when it got cooler. I'm still at my "winter weight" though and will likely drop another ten pounds or so on my backpacking trips this summer.

SMD offers the option between three sizes of hip belts, the smallest being 26" and sized to fit 26-34" and the medium being 30" and sized to fit 30-38". The small seems to be the closest to the hip belt on the Osprey, which works really well for me, but with only a couple extra inches of webbing, I wonder if it would be too small when using while wearing winter layers, including a down jacket. For the medium I would have an extra 6+ inches of webbing (which I guess is only 3-4 inches on each side). Which do you think would be best?

I am guessing I will go with the regular 18" shoulder straps. I am getting the aluminum stays. I'm 95% sure think I want the belt with the hip pockets. Does anyone know how much weight this adds to the pack specs? Also, with the stays, what do you feel the max load capacity would be? SMD recommends a pack weight of 35lbs or so (with a 17lb base weight) but I've read on here that with the aluminum stays you can load it beyond that, although no one ever specified how much. I don't think I will do that, but I lead backpacking trips with students and you never know what extras you'll need to bring along when you have a bunch of kids in your hands.

Thanks guys!

Mary D BPL Member
PostedApr 18, 2010 at 3:29 pm

First of all, the Six Moon Designs website has an email address, a telephone number and a Skype contact listed. Either Ron or Brandon Moak will be more than happy to answer any questions you may have about your pack. Please email or call them with your questions–I've always received a prompt and clear answer!

I'll weigh in here because I have a Six Moon Designs Comet (smaller version of the Starlite, unfortunately discontinued–even the Comet's volume is bigger than I need) that I've had for almost 5 years and with which I'm extremely happy. It is basically identical to the Starlite except for smaller capacity and an internal, rather than external, pad pocket. I understand that the Traveler is basically a Starlite with the panel loading feature. I'd be tempted, too, if it didn't have far more capacity than I want or need.

When I got my Comet, SMD's packs came in one size only. It works just fine for me, although I'm definitely at the small end for torso length (15") and have that adjusted to the smallest possible. I ended up trimming some of the adjustable straps, of course making sure there was plenty of room for winter clothing and/or weight gain underneath.

From my past reading of the SMD website, the 35 lbs. recommendation is the maximum recommended load WITH the "optional" stays. Unless your total pack weight is normally 25 lbs. or less, IMHO you're going to want those stays. You can easily take them out for shorter trips (they slide in and out very easily), but you'll definitely want them for trips in which you need to carry more food and/or lots of water. The load lifters (one of the reasons I chose an SMD pack, my shoulders are extremely pressure-sensitive) don't work very well without the stays. I have carried up to 37 lbs. in my Comet. My shoulders, back and hips were just fine, although my knees and feet were screaming! I will never do that again–if any other relative wants his/her ashes deposited in a location that's several days' backpack from the trailhead, they can find someone else to do it! But I came out of the experience with high praise for the pack, which did its job superlatively and felt very comfortable! From my (obviously subjective) experience, it would be comfortable up to 40 lbs. (with the stays) if your legs and feet can manage the weight.

Heath Pitts BPL Member
PostedApr 18, 2010 at 4:05 pm

My SMD traveler weighs 30.7 oz with the stays and hip belt pockets. The traveler is a great pack and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it to anyone. I used the stays the first two trips that I made with it. My next trip should have total weight of around 22 lbs so I am going to try it using only a foam nightlight pad in the pad pocket.

Kari Post BPL Member
PostedApr 18, 2010 at 5:54 pm

Mary, I did send SMD an email, but thought I'd get some other opinions on here as well. I'll probably use the stays most, if not all, of the time, as I really like having a frame to distribute and hold the weight of the pack. Thank you both, Mary and Heath, for your insight.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedApr 18, 2010 at 6:06 pm

You're very welcome, and best of luck with your new pack!

Bob Bankhead BPL Member
PostedApr 18, 2010 at 8:23 pm

We have two Travelers. You're going to love this pack………if you like panel loaders.

If in doubt regarding lengths, order it with more than one hipbelt and/or shoulder strap set, and send back the one(s) that doesn't work. Better to have both lengths in hand simultaneously rather than ship one back, get the other, and then discover your first guess was the better one.

Fortunately, we live only a few miles from Ron so were able to have him custom fit my wife with hers – it was actually the prototype Ron had just received. We placed an immediate order for the first production run.. I liked hers so much I ordered one for myself later that year. Did the JHT with it last summer. With the stays, it easily carried 35 pounds. I suspect it could handle more than that. However, with any pack, gear bulk is more an issue than gear weight. Full is full, no matter how much weight-carrying capacity is left. That's why a pack should always be the LAST gear item you buy.

WB

Kari Post BPL Member
PostedApr 19, 2010 at 6:10 am

Great point Bob. I used my Talon 44 for my overnight this weekend, and although it wasn't heavy at all (about 15 lbs before consumables with me carrying all of the shared gear between me and my hiking buddy including stove, fuel, pots, maps, tent, etc), it was FULL. I think its fair to say that that my base weight would be roughly 18 lbs for an extended trip (adding a few clothing articles), and I just ran out of room for extra stuff. I think the extra volume of the SMD Traveler would be perfect for most of my needs.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...