Would you rather have a cuben tarp or a cuben tent?
Topic
Cuben Tarp vs. Tent
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
A cuben tarptent.
But seriously, you'll probably get equally divided answers. The tent users want a cuben tent, and the tarp users want a cuben tarp, which already exist. The real niche would probably be a cuben tarptent/tent shelter that employs a tried and true design, significant weight reduction, and at a price point that doesn't make the Federal Reserve shudder.
Travis has it dead on. You want to dominate the market…a cuben tarptent of some sort is the way to go.
Lawson,
If you're looking into production of something along these lines, I think I could work it into my schedule to test some prototypes! ;)
Cuben tarptent! The reality for me is I'd be very happy with a simple cuben flat tarp, a 7×9 rectangular cuben flat tarp with shallow catenary cuts between the tieouts on the length side. I think Joe Valeskos Zpacks Hexamid nailed it; balancing the best of both worlds and the price point and weight is about as good as it gets right now for a fully featured tarp tent shelter. There isn't really anything out there to compete directly with the Hexamid, not that I can think of, anyone? Correct me if I'm wrong. I guess the Refuge X is sorta comparable. The new MLD Cuben Solo Pro tarp paired with the MLD Serenity tarp is very close to the low weight of the fully featured Hexamid but it's modular vs. an all inclusive package.
Lawson, if you could come up with a tested shelter that balances that fine line of price, weight and smart design that attracts both ends of the shelter spectrum then i think people would knock at your door. But I'm a handy man, not a business man so what do I know. :)
I think the biggest innovation with the biggest reward if you can hang on to/patent the technique/process will be a cuben based pad: especially if down filled.
I suspect the key will be a clever if complex "jig" to clamp and hold ALL or most the seams for glueing. one step or 2 step process. glue all the seams on one side…step one…etc.
Notice we've not heard a thing from Huzefa for almost a year. I suspect there's a lot of seams to glue and it's not like you can afford to screw up even one short stretch.
Not only would this have the potential of a relatively quantum leap in air mattresses but it would also allow for re-creation or revitalization of the basic "Stephenson" design for the combination of a top bag/layer with an insulated bottom. Those things are so comfy and warm! And if the weight weren't a penalty they could easily "migrate" to hammocks.
Oh well it's fun to dream.
And PS: You might be bucking some strong head-winds on a tarptent. Joe Valesko has a pretty good looking product. Ron Bell is making stuff with Cuben. There are rumors about GG. I'm guessing that tarp/tent ground shelters might become a crowded/competitive market and plus the responses are skewed on this forum by a dominance of ground dwellers.
I haven't seen but one tarp designed for hammocks; the one at MLD by Ron Bell and it's VERY expensive.
Take dead aim. Do something well and the world will beat a path to your door.
I think a cuben tent is what the market is really missing right now. Cuben tarps are currently available and most needs are being met.
I think what would really be a huge hit is a successor to the Refuge X that addresses it's shortcomings. Take the Refuge X but use bonding/tape instead of stitches, use colored cuben, give it a bathtub floor and somehow increase the interior room a bit and you'll have a hit if the price is sub $500. Basic A frame trekking pole supported shelters like Refuge X don't have much interior room because they are only high in one point. You can use trekking poles for your design, but it would be nice to add a little something else too (ie. SMD Lunar Duo) to give the interior volume a boost. I think you could create quite a nice 2 person single wall cuben tent with pretty much zero compromises for 18-24oz.
I have just recieved my Cuben Zpacks Hexamid and I am very impressed with its design and the Cuben material, I have not used it yet.
I would like to see one of Rogers Caffin's tent designs made with Cuben.
Tony
>Take dead aim. Do something well and the world will beat a path to your door.
Well said, and the basic moral of that statement can be applied to many more things in life.
I agree with everyone else that the cuben tarp is already being supplied, so you're only adding to people's options at best. IMO, go for a cuben tarp tent. I love joe's hexamid, but I know im not the most delicate on my gear…I've worn holes in the netting on my double wall tents, and I'm pretty sure I would do the same on a hexamid. If his tent incorporated some form of a built in silnylon bathtub floor, I would be all over it…hint hint :)
Konrad,
My hexamid is tarp-only, but have you tried using your groundsheet under the netting? Since the guylines are fixed-length, you could easily attach the groundsheet to the stakes with negligible weight gain by using sheetbend knots.
Hey John, oops I should have been more clear…I love the idea of joe's hex, but I don't own one, for the fears I've listed in my previous post. I think I read from him that the ground sheet should always be above the netting, that way if water runs under the tarp, you can adjust the groundsheet accordingly, whereas if the groundsheet were underneath the netting, you cant' move it, and instead would just have a pool of water underneath.
What I would want in a new cuben tarptent is what we see Henry Shires is already doing…simply having netting attached to a low bathtub floor. That way no netting touches the ground. The weight penalty is minor and worth it in my opinion.
My vs. post turned into a dream gear post haha…I agree with everyone's statements..I think there are some holes in the market that need to be filled..
On a side note: I am not sure if I agree with a silnylon floor..First there is no such thing as an adhesive or tape that will bond properly to both and sewing cuben is out of the question. So its either a floor made of cuben or urethane coated nylon????
So the question is do you use cuben and a ground sheet or a 70d ripstop urethane coated nylon by itself??? Weight probably even with the cuben and ground sheet costing 1000% more..
> First there is no such thing as an adhesive or tape that will bond properly to both
Except that I use siloxane transfer tape on my 1.1 oz silnylon groundsheets to proof the saeams and I sew the bathtub edges to the netting …
Cheers
With regards to the original question, I agree with just about everyone here: Tarpent. As already mentioned, there are several very good Cuben tarps, but very few Cuben tents (of any sort).
With tarps, you can't do too much with regards to the design. You can vary the size and shape a bit, but some folks are already doing that (MLD has a pretty wide assortment of tarps). That would make it hard for you to carve out a different niche.
If you make a Cuben (single or double walled) tent then you have to decide on a design. With a little research and cooperation, this will greatly improve your chances of success. To put it simply, you can make something that people want to buy and that no one else is making or planning to make. If I were you, I would do the following:
1) Talk to folks that make craft tents and tarps and ask them if they plan on making a Cuben tent anytime soon. This will prevent you from making essentially the same thing as someone else.
2) Given that, throw out some design ideas and see what people think. Personally, I would like a tent similar to a Contrail or X-Rocket. You wouldn't want to follow either of these designs exactly (unless you got the permission and cooperation of the makers) but variations on these themes are well within bounds (in my opinion). In other words, you could make tents similar to these, without feeling like a thief. For example, I know someone made a home made tarptent that functioned like an X-Rocket without ever having seen the design.
I think there are a couple of key things to keep in mind:
1) The people who make this stuff are really nice, cooperative folks.
2) The demand is there for a Cuben tent. The Refuge X sold out quickly. The only reason we don't see a lot more Cuben tents being sold is because there aren't that many being offered. Those that are offered sell very well.
Become a member to post in the forums.

