Topic

ul inner, flash hooded, microlight alpine, skaha+

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 7:54 pm

Hey there folks,
I'm trying to replace my ex-light jacket after it being misplaced/robbed.
What is the most recent word on the street when it comes to a hooded lightweight insulated top, am I missing one?
The listed stats of each are.

Montbell U.L. Inner Parka
Listed 800 fill down
2.5 oz fill/ 9 oz total weight

Western Mountaineering Hooded Flash
Listed 850 fill down
3 oz fill/ 9 oz total weight

Skaha+ Jacket
800+ listed fill down
4.5 oz fill/ 10 oz total weight

Rab Microlight Alpine
750 fill eu rated (which I have heard corresponds to 850 fill traditional, tell me if I am wrong)
6 oz total fill/ 12 oz total weight

The price on all of them is steep with the inner parka being the most affordable, the flash and microlight comparable and the skaha+ being pretty extraordinary.

Whats the feedback from everyone in terms of warmth, actual weight/feedback.
I'm most interested in a side by side of the hooded flash and the microlight.

Any other contenders you have are welcome and any feedback on these pieces is appreciated.
Thanks,
Sean

James Naphas BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 11:42 pm

The montbell is spot on regarding weight. It's probably warm on its own down to the mid-forties, maybe freezing with a shell over the top. Nice as a layer for three-seasons in the Sierras. I haven't had any of the others on, though from reading reviews the skaha is probably warm down to 15 or 20 degrees.

You can usually pick the down inner parka up with one of the backcountry.com 20% off deals. I think one is running now.

PostedApr 16, 2010 at 11:53 pm

I didn't realize the RAB had 6 oz. of fill. That's quite a bit, and I think it might give the Nunatak a run based on warmth, though obviously there would be a number of other variables. If anyone has this jacket, hopefully they can give some good feedback on the relative performance.

PostedApr 17, 2010 at 12:36 am

So I think the weight on the rab might be a bit off. The hoodless jacket of the version is listed at 11 oz, but it has over an ounce less down. That leads me to believe the jacket might actually be a bit heavier.

Richard Nisley BPL Member
PostedApr 17, 2010 at 9:24 am

Sean,

Your 6.5 oz fill amount for this jacket appears to be incorrect. Where did you get this figure?

At least for the last year, the fill amount for this jacket was 4.4 oz of 750 fill EU and 11.3 oz for size L. EU Lorch fill ratings are only 4% more conservative than US fill rating. See the date of the BPL review for this jacket.

They recently changed their specs for this jacket but I don't know if any of the newly specified jackets are the inventory pipeline. The new size L specs list the fill amount as 5.8 oz size with a nearly commensurate weight increase to 12 oz.

On average there is about 7.5% less fill in a size medium jacket than a size large jacket. So their size L spec, for the past year, of 4.4 oz = 4.07 oz for size M. The fill for a size M is what many vendors use for comparison. Historically this was the same warmth jacket as the Montbell Light Down with 4 oz of 800 fill.

. . BPL Member
PostedApr 19, 2010 at 1:23 am

Richard,

If it is convenient, could you post the iclo values of the jackets mentioned in the originating post? I could not find the info for most of them searching through past posts.

Sean,

The WM Hooded Flash (Bill & Paul's Sporthaus) and MB Down Inner Parka (Montbell USA and Prolite Gear) have decent sale prices online right now – check Gear Swap for some of the details. I'd consider trying them on for best fit also, as this significantly effects each garment's overall efficiency for you.

PostedApr 19, 2010 at 2:00 am

I picked up the flash jacket today in a M. When it gets here I'm hoping it fits perfectly.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...