are you looking for something that will insulate you from the ground more?
if so, the thermarest women's prolite plus actually has a higher R value (4.6) than the regular thermarest prolite plus (3.8) or the neoair (2.5), and is cheaper than the standard size mens prolite plus and weighs the same. its 6 inches shorter than most full lenth pads, but if length bothers you, just stick your semi-empty pack under your feet.
if your looking for lightweight, may i suggest my setup.
i use my small neoair for everything above freezing, and if im below freezing, i have a full length z-lite that i pack with me. i've taken a 20degree bag to single digits relitively comfortably using this and propper dressing in the bag.
OR maybe you should just keep your BA pad and just use a second foam pad underneath it if your going