Topic

chemical water treatment advice?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
PostedApr 15, 2010 at 9:42 pm

I want to switch from a pumping water, and was looking for advice or tips to treating water with chemical.

It seams that alot of people here use AQUAMIRA, are there other alternatives I should investigate?

I have also head of people using a bandana as a simple prefilter. Is something like this common practice?

PostedApr 16, 2010 at 11:18 am

Thanks, lots of good info.

I thought I would share some info that I have gathered, please correct me if any info is incorrect. Note that this are general guidelines.

Contaminates to be treated

1. Viruses
Low risk (depending on location and water source)
-purification, 30 mins.
-filtration, no effect

2. Bacteria
High risk
-purification, 30 mins.
-filtration, removed

3. Protozoa (Giardia, Crypto, Cysts)
Moderate risk
-purification, up to 4+ hours
-filtration, removed

Treatment options

1. Chlorine dioxide
Often times would be safe
-disadvantages- long wait times with hard to kill protoza

2. Filter
Safe if there is no threat of viruses
-disadvantages- weight penalty and realibilit

3. Electronic Purifier (MIOX, SteriPEN)
MSR MIOX – Same as Chlorine dioxide? (treatment time)
-disadvantages- ~ 50 days of water/charge, treatment time,
SteriPEN – Instant (90 second) treatment???
-disadvantages- ~12 days of water/charge

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 11:35 am

There are other treatment methods also. Iodine crystals work fine, as long as increased iodine in your system is not a problem. About one person out of a hundred seems to have a big problem with iodine. It's cheap.

Chlorine liberated from household bleach can be effective. It's cheap.

Boiling the water can be effective. It's cheap, as long as you have a plentiful source of fuel. If you are cooking with alcohol or Esbit or butane, this may not be good. A woodburner stove with lots of wood can boil water until the cows come home, and boiling kills virtually everything quicker than by chemical treatment. But if you are up high above timberline, then wood may not be available.

Filtering is by far the quickest method. So, you have to decide your priorities: time, fuel, weight, or cost.

The smart backpacker probably uses two methods variably during a trip. If one method fails, then the second method will still maintain some reasonable degree of safety. This is because different methods tend to work more on different water problems.

The really smart backpacker will study the raw water sources to be able to select the cleanest one to begin with.

I was trekking in Nepal, and the Sherpa mountain guides told us not to touch the water of one sacred river. As it turned out, it was not that any water was sacred. The river was downstream from quite a number of Sherpa villages, so it was probably teeming with all manner of viral and bacteria organisms. Just touching the water would have risk from illnesses, which the Sherpa people equated to bad luck from the gods. I wouldn't touch it.

–B.G.–

Mary D BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 12:55 pm

Being one of those who ran into big problems with iodine, I want to second the warnings against it. My reaction to it was an overall rash with deep-seated lesions (lichen planus) which left permanent scars. I wouldn't wish such a thing on my worst enemy! To this day (25 years later) I cannot eat seafood or iodized salt or anything containing iodine without suffering another reaction. Since nearly everyone uses iodized salt, I can't go to a restaurant or someone else's home for dinner unless I request that my food be prepared without salt or stick with a raw vegetable salad with oil and vinegar (no homemade dressings, either). And I have to read labels carefully–nearly every food fortified with vitamins and minerals has iodine in it!

There is a reason that the CDC warns against the use of iodine to purify water only in emergencies. It's also contraindicated for pregnant women, which should tell you something. In addition, iodine is not effective against cryptosporidium, which is becoming an increasing problem.

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 1:12 pm

For most of us, however, iodine is very safe and effective. It must be used in proper concentration. Unfortunately, some people do not pay close attention and wind up using double-dose for a long time, and that may get a reaction also.

–B.G.–

PostedApr 16, 2010 at 1:58 pm

Iodine is the worst tasting of all the treatments.
Plain old Clorox treats as well, tastes better, is also cheap, but doesn't stay in your system the way iodine does.

I have done much boiling of water and in most cases that can be fine, but do you want to sit in the sun, on a hot summer day, gathering fuel to boil water for the afternoon leg of your trip. I've done it, but….

Me, I like Aquamira because of the taste, shelf stability and reliability.
Combine Aquamira with an ultralight filter and you have something to use use if one or the other fails(or fall back to boiling)

PostedApr 16, 2010 at 2:05 pm

I've tried a LOT of chemical treatments – Aqua Mira is the one I use more than any.

I do NOT follow the instructions, I usually use much LESS than recommended.

PostedApr 16, 2010 at 2:09 pm

Bleach (chlorox) is not a reliable treatment for bacteria or protozoa. It is OK for virus if you're combining it with a filter for the bacteria and protozoa.

Chlorine dioxide tablets or iodine take up to 4 hours to eliminate giardia. I'm not sure iodine works well for cryptosporidium.

Boiling works well for virus, bacteria and protozoa. This seems like the most reasonable method for winter.

Giardia and cryptosporidium have been found in municipal drinking water in Massachusetts and elsewhere in New England. All it takes is one of those infected people upstream of you. Nobody tests backcountry drinking water around here.

Karl Gottshalk BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 2:21 pm

But as I understand it, the steripen will disable all of the above in 90 seconds. Am I correct?

Karl

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 2:25 pm

> But as I understand it, the steripen will disable all of the above in 90 seconds. Am I correct?

You are correct. It is definitely my favoured method of treatment. We have reviewed the
SteriPEN Adventurer
and will publish a review of the SteriPEN ADventurer Opti soon. They are so easy to use.

Cheers

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 2:30 pm

"Chlorine dioxide tablets or iodine take up to 4 hours to eliminate giardia."

I'm not sure that it is fair to lump those two methods together.

Some of the methods will take as long as 4 hours, but that is mostly with near-freezing water in winter. For summertime water, it is a matter of minutes for iodine crystals.

One of the reasons that so many people complain about the taste of iodine is that they are simply using too high of a concentration, like what you get from iodine pills. Iodine crystals allow you to vary the solution to meet the temperature. However, some people can't distinguish pills from crystals. I found that iodine treated water can be left to work for a period, and then dosed with Gatorade powder, and then the taste is gone.

For most of us, iodine is not a problem unless you try to cook a potato with treated water. You get a purple potato.

–B.G.–

PostedApr 16, 2010 at 2:40 pm

Researched the steriPEN a little bit. Sounds like some people have had reliability issues with them. Hopefully in another year or so that will be resolved, and they will come out with a UV led model, to improve the battery life.

. . BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 2:45 pm

I actually prefer the taste of iodine to chlorine, and it seems less harsh on my system. I've never had a problem with Iodine and it was even the standard method of treatment during long summers of guiding largish groups in the Rockies. The taste is relatively easy to mask w/ citric acid, etc.

PostedApr 16, 2010 at 3:14 pm

I think most of the reliability problems with the Steripen derive from its power draw. If you have fresh batteries or the day is warm, it works fine. If the battery is fresh, it works fine even when cold. If the battery is partially discharged and it's a cold day, it will sometimes fail. I experienced all three of these situations in summer and fall with mine.

In fall, when it failed (it just told me that it was out of juice when I dipped it in the water), I put in my coat pocket for around 10 minutes, and then tried it again and it worked fine.

McDowell Crook BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2010 at 6:24 pm

I used Polar Pur for six months while on the Appalachian Trail in 1999 and it didn't bother me at all. The taste was very subtle and if I got tired of it I would just add gatorade occasionally. I took every opportunity to drink clean, untreated water so my system wouldn't be barraged with iodine, but I think it's safe to say that I drank some of it almost every day. A lot of people did the same thing. Your mileage may vary.

PostedApr 16, 2010 at 6:42 pm

I went from Katadyn Hiker Water Filter TO Aquamira Water Purification Tablets and Drops TO the new SteriPEN Adventurer Opti Water Purifier.

The drops were quite a bit lighter than the filter. The tablets made the process easier. But I did enjoy mixing the drops. Weird, I know.

The SteriPEN has good reviews. The new Opti looks like it took care of some of BPL review concerns. I never used the other one. I plan to begin using the SteriPEN starting next weekend on through Autumn.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
Loading...