Topic

Help me size my already purchased Insulation layer and Rain Jacket

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
PostedApr 6, 2010 at 4:04 pm

So I did look at the respective sizing charts before I made the following online purchase

(1) XL Montbell U.L Down Parka
(1) XL Marmot Super Mica

My body specs are the following
Chest: approximately 43"
Torso: approximately 21"

Question, how snug without the drawstring should the insulation layer be against my body? While wearing a cotton tee-shirt, if I pull the excess material of the jacket to one side of my waist I have approximately 3" of excess before I would consider the fit snug. I presume I want a fairly snug fit with down jacket?

I have approximately 2" of excess material with the Super Mica. A quick cinch on the drawstring alleviates the slack and I have some wiggle room with when I layer. Overall I find the Marmot piece an overall more athletic fit.

The sleeves on both fit me perfectly so I am apprehensive to go a size down.

At this point I am leaning towards returning the down jacket and getting a size smaller (Large). What would the hive do/suggest?

Is my anal retentiveness showing yet?

Thanks!

Richard Nisley BPL Member
PostedApr 6, 2010 at 7:43 pm

Nathan,

You could call it anal retentiveness or you could call it exchanging knowledge for comfort. I prefer the latter.

Most UL backpackers ignore optimal layer sizing as a strategy to maximize their garment insulation efficiency… this is a big mistake IMHO. Appropriately sized garment layers will provide incremental insulation approximately equivalent to increasing the garments loft by the gap size between garments. This more than offsets the weight increase from a potential size increase.

Thermal insulation and moisture vapor resistance under no wind and in windy conditions both increase with the thickness of the air gap between layers when the air gap is small. The rate of increase gradually decreases as the air gap becomes thicker. The rate of increase is much less than the theoretically ideal still air calculations due to forced convection, caused by movement, in clothing systems.

The base layers need to fit tight. Each insulation or shell layer should be selected to achieve a progressively larger girth. You should select layers so there is a 0.39" air gap for maximum insulation without significant wind. This equates to a maximum girth difference of 2.95 inches. A .24" gap is best in very windy conditions. This equates to a girth difference of 1.97" between layers.

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
Loading...