So I did look at the respective sizing charts before I made the following online purchase
(1) XL Montbell U.L Down Parka
(1) XL Marmot Super Mica
My body specs are the following
Chest: approximately 43"
Torso: approximately 21"
Question, how snug without the drawstring should the insulation layer be against my body? While wearing a cotton tee-shirt, if I pull the excess material of the jacket to one side of my waist I have approximately 3" of excess before I would consider the fit snug. I presume I want a fairly snug fit with down jacket?
I have approximately 2" of excess material with the Super Mica. A quick cinch on the drawstring alleviates the slack and I have some wiggle room with when I layer. Overall I find the Marmot piece an overall more athletic fit.
The sleeves on both fit me perfectly so I am apprehensive to go a size down.
At this point I am leaning towards returning the down jacket and getting a size smaller (Large). What would the hive do/suggest?
Is my anal retentiveness showing yet?
Thanks!

