Topic

MLD Supermid or Oware 10 x 10

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
Paul Ettestad BPL Member
PostedApr 5, 2010 at 11:40 am

Will be hiking this summer above treeline in the Rockies with 2 other guys, all 3 of us around 6'2". I'm thinking of getting either the MLD SuperMid or the Oware 10'x10' pyramid. I like the quality of the Supermid, the side tieouts and the venting, but wondering if it will be cramped with 3 large guys and gear. I don't like being squished. Anyone have experience with the SuperMid and how many people it can hold comfortably with that center pole in the middle?

Ben Wortman BPL Member
PostedApr 5, 2010 at 7:53 pm

I have a DIY Mid that has roughly the same specs as the Oware 10×10. It will fit 3 guys inside just fine with room for gear also.

PostedApr 5, 2010 at 9:41 pm

I have an Oware 9 x 9 mid. I think for three tall guys the 10 x 10 would be a better option. I'm sure 9 x 9 would work to sleep three but the extra foot would make a big difference when you add gear to the mix. Also I believe the Oware mids are a touch taller.

Some other thoughts:

1) I ordered a MLD mid prior to buying my Oware mid. At that time shipping times for MLD were stated to be 8 weeks. Called Ron around 8 weeks and found out it was going to take a couple of weeks longer. At around the 11 week mark talked to him again and found out it still was not being sewn and that they were out of silnylon at the time and that it would likely tack on a couple of weeks to get the material in. When I originally ordered it part of the reason was because the MLD mid had a vent. I then realized that the shelter had been changed so that it was not going to have a vent but I was not contacted about this. I guess I would have found out when it arrived. Now I see they are made with vents again. Yikes. I do not want this to sound like a rant so enough about my experience with MLD. Just felt that I was not kept in the loop about what was going on. To his credit Ron was quick to refund my money and sent a few mini-biners along with my check. Would I still order from MLD? Maybe because their products look great and most people seem to rave about the customer service, but I would go into it with the mindset that I had to be very patient.

2) To Vent or not to Vent… that is a question that stressed me before I ordered. David from Oware assured me that the vent was not worth while as most condensation can be dealt with by pitching the shelter with an edge raised for air flow and that the steep walls generally means that most condensation will just run down the wall. My experience has been consistent with this in the dry Canadian Rockies. When I spoke to Ron at one point he told me much the same so I am not sure why the vent has appeared again. Maybe somebody else has had a different experience.

3) Side tieouts – My mid does not have side tieouts. In high winds there is definitely some material flapping but nothing I have been terribly concerned about. I am pretty sure this is an option that you can have Oware add. If you are at all handy with sewing you might choose to order one without and add guy attachment points later if you believe they are necessary. Would be a very simple modification.

4) Ordering from Oware was great. Spoke to David on the phone. He had mids in stock. Was at my house in under two weeks (pretty good for ordering from Canada)

Hope this helped. I'm sure you would make either work.Mid

PostedApr 5, 2010 at 10:30 pm

I have a 2009 MLD supermid in cuben that I love. That being said i think trying to squeeze three people inside would be a bit of a stretch. Last season myself, 6'3" 225, and my buddy, 6'4" 235, shared the Mid on several occasions and had plenty of room inside with our gear. I'm sure we could have squeezed in one more if the situation called for it but it would probably end up looking a lot like a bad game of Twister.

PostedApr 6, 2010 at 8:34 am

Oware for sure. I got bug netting around the perimeter on mine. Super slick!

Paul Ettestad BPL Member
PostedApr 6, 2010 at 10:22 am

Thanks guys for the very helpful insights. The bug netting was going to be my next question. Those of you without bug netting around the perimeter, have you been able to deal with a mosquito problem by pitching the mid with the sides right next to the ground? Does this cause a ventilation problem? Does the perimeter bug netting actually work? I would rather have the perimeter netting if it works than carry a whole interior bug net.

Thanks again for the advise.

Paul

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedApr 6, 2010 at 10:29 am

I have added my own 4-6 inches of bug net to the bottom of two of my shelters. I've never seen a mosquito inside either shelter, but I don't know if that proves anything. It does not seem to cause a ventilation problem. In fact, I fixed mine up this way so that I can either raise the shelter up for 4-6 inches of ventilation, or I can lower it down before a storm to seal it better.

Depending on what the door-end of your shelter looks like, you might add more net there. Mine was a simple triangle shape, so some net and some velcro made the job easy.

If you do this, make sure that you use good netting material. Some stuff has holes that are too large.
–B.G.–

Rog Tallbloke BPL Member
PostedApr 6, 2010 at 10:29 am

Perimeter bug netting – does it work?

I hope so. Kath and I just spent several hours doing a perimeter bug netting/Tyvek floor job on our Golite Hut 1. See MYOG forum thread.

. . BPL Member
PostedApr 6, 2010 at 11:41 am

+1 on the Oware 10 x 10

Both companies make great gear, but the extra 20 square feet and five inches of head room would make a big difference for 3.

26oz./3 = 8.66oz./person (call it 9.5 after seam sealing) – not bad.

I cannot comment on the bug netting, as my 10 x 10 does not have it, but I would look into getting a couple of big sheets of Eric’s Plastazote 1/8″ Foam Pads (click for link). I would get 2 @ 1/8″ X 50″ X 74″ – 4.4oz (124 grams) and one @ 1/8″ X 25″ X 74″ – 2.2 oz (62 grams) to cover most of the floor as insulated groundsheets. This would help cut down on condensation contribution from the ground mass or moisture elements, provide some ground insulation for your sleeping, and keep your gear clean. Fine multi-purpose gear. The netting should then tuck in underneath the edges of the pads to seal out insects.

This is the link above if you prefer to cut & paste:
http://www.suluk46.com/products%20%20-%20P4%20PF%20Sheet.html

PostedApr 6, 2010 at 3:59 pm

My Oware Mid does have the bug netting. It definitely works to keep out the flying insects. I would guess that having the mid pitched tight to the ground would be effective most of the time but it sure does limit ventilation. Also would limit the ability to pitch the mid off the ground which can make it feel that much more spacious. If you are going primarily to buggy places I would say get the bug netting. If you are mostly using it in the shoulder seasons or into winter I would say don't bother.

Jeff

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
Loading...