Topic

Why does my redbull stove suck?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
PostedMar 26, 2010 at 10:56 pm

Made a red bull sideburner (smaller version of pepsi can stove) stove per the instructions on zen stoves. Takes forever to prime and my Heineken pot snuffs it right out even though the flames are shooting strong after priming.

1) Is it that the Heineken can sits over the edge of the top and very close to the jets that snuffs it out?

2) I could be lighting it wrong. Should I be using a primer pan?

3) I think my fuel may be junk. A bad batch of SLX, maybe. I plan on hitting the liquor store for some grain alcohol tomorrow. Should the jets be flickering a good bit or just giving a nice, steady stream of flame?

I'm trying to find a smaller stove setup that's a little more efficient with my Heine pot. Any experiences with the gram weenie pro used in conjunction with a Heine pot?

PostedMar 26, 2010 at 11:00 pm

My Heini pot sat right on my beer can stove and almost put it out every time. i made a little stand for it out of aluminum and it works perfect. boils 24oz in 6 minutes. The flames on my stove do not flicker.

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 26, 2010 at 11:12 pm

What is the vertical distance from the side jet holes to the bottom of the cook pot?

If it is much less than one inch, it's probably wrong.

Bad batch of SLX? Doubtful.

–B.G.–

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedMar 27, 2010 at 4:22 am

Jonathan, I've used a MYOG V8 can stove and Heiney pot on multiple occassions. Here is a pic of my setup.

V8 Can Stove

Mine works extremely well. The only time I've had trouble with the pot snuffing out the flame is when used in cold weather (15 degrees in picture). Even then I just need to let it heat up a bit longer. If priming is an issue you might want to add a priming pan below.

Your other option is to consider drilling the holes a bit larger. This may help.

Nothing beats my Caldera cone, but for a MYOG item it does extremely well.

Jamie

PostedMar 27, 2010 at 8:32 am

Jamie? How far are the side jets from the top of your stove? I did mine per the instructions on zenstoves.

Since I already did all the work to get this darn thing together, would it be ok to just put an extra set of holes around the can below the first set of holes, similar to a supercat setup?

Greg Lewis BPL Member
PostedMar 27, 2010 at 10:22 am

Jonathon,

I tried my Super Gram Weenie on my Heinekin pot. The results were not that impressive. The first attempt put out the stove, even after what I thought was a good bloom. The second attempt I primed a little more and it worked. The problem is that it barely (2 cups) came to a boil after about 14 minutes.

After many of these same attempts when I switched to alky, I decided that a tealight was the best method for a Heiny pot. I also had decent luck with pop can stoves when I put the jets towards the middle of the can, so they shot basically straight up to the pot.

I gave up on heiny pots after determining that the extra fuel I had to carry due to the inefficient design of the can (tall and narrow) made up for any weight savings from using it.

If your hart is set on this pot, maybe a cone is the way to go.

gl

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedMar 27, 2010 at 1:57 pm

My holes are 5/8" from the top. I think I followed the directions without changes. I've made a number of these guys and they all work pretty good. I think my holes were actually done using a push pin. I use denatured alcohol that I buy from REI. I have found that if I want to preheat it quicker I drip some alcohol on the outside. I have also found that in cold weather it can "jet" but unless I let it get hot it will go out when the heiny pot is put on it. But again this is in sub freezing weather. I've found it to be fairly fuel efficient (1/2 oz per 1.5 cups of water).

Jamie

george carr BPL Member
PostedMar 27, 2010 at 5:59 pm

We have just recently gone back to the 1.75" height in the GWP, and it works just fine with a heiney pot. If the bottom of the heiney pot is too close to the jets it will snuff the stove. That's what it sounds like is happening with your redbull stove. If you build it about a 1/4" taller and keep the jets the same distance from the bottom you'll most likely see better results.
GWP+ heiney pot
The original GW and SGW are better suited for mugs and small diamter cookpots. That's why I don't market them for the HP.

PostedMar 27, 2010 at 11:54 pm

George, I was checking out your site last night. I still see the specs listed with a 1.5 inch height. Is that just something that hasn't been changed yet, I guess?

Also, I see that you suggest boiling a cup of water (EDIT:, you said 16 ounces, which I took for one cup, but 8 ounces is one cup, 16 ounces is one pound. Silly me) with the stove. I'm looking at usually boiling about 2 cups at a time. my supercat does this just fine on one oz. of fuel. Would it take two ounces to get it done with the GWP? (EDIT: So yeah, ignore that question)

And to all interested readers, I bought some Everclear and tested it out with the supercat and redbull stove (I was using SLX). The jets are just too close to the bottom of the Heine pot with the redbull, but it kicks ass on a regular pot, so I'll definitely be keeping it around. Also, I used a priming pan and the thing blossoms up in like 10 seconds, really quick. It seems to be more efficient and can boil the same amount of water on less fuel. Maybe on a longer hike where I need to stretch fuel and don't mind carrying a larger pot.

The supercat did something strange with the everclear. It didn't flame far up the sides of the can for the first few minutes. It seemed to prime a little slower, but it was, in effect, more efficient. This seems like the winner for now. It can boil 2 cups of cold tap water in about 5 minutes on one oz. of fuel or less, so I think it will be good for the trail.

george carr BPL Member
PostedMar 28, 2010 at 10:35 am

Jonathan,

Thanks for keeping me honest :)! I try to stay on top of changing specs, but that one slipped past me. The website reflects the changes to the GWP and GWP package deals.

Sounds like your stove's a winner. Jet height is just more critical with a heiney pot if your stove doesn't use a potstand.

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
Loading...