Topic

ethanol residue/burnishing

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 3 posts - 26 through 28 (of 28 total)
PostedMar 26, 2010 at 6:23 pm

more testing results:

I picked up some of the 'rubbing alcohol compound' suggested by Rene. It's ingredients were listed as 95% ethanol, and remaining ingredients were camphor, diethyl benzyl benzoate, diethyl phthalate. It is recommended as a 'topical antiseptic', which is appealing compared to the toxicity of methyl hydrate.
actual stove performance fell in between the Sunnyside denatured alchohol and methyl hydrate for both boil times and total burn times. HOWEVER, the burnishing experienced with Sunnyside was repeated, AND a significant amount of soot was produced at the end of the burn.
i am now debating whether to use this 'compound' because of its relative safety for skin exposure and simply remove the pot before the burn finishes, or opt for either the Sunnyside (fastest boil time, and no soot) or meths (clean burning, but slower boil and toxic).

PostedMar 26, 2010 at 9:49 pm

Hey Jason,

I have also been searching for a good source of ethanol in Canada. I stopped by a local Shoppers Drug Mart after work but I could not find the rubbing alcohol compound and did not have time to ask for help. Where did you get yours? I'm assuming it was next to the rubbing alcohol or should I have been looking in a different section?

Currently I have settled on using methyl hydrate but I am always on the look out for an option that is not toxic. In my search for an alternative I have tried Everclear and Fondue fuel. The Everclear burned surprisingly poorly. Lots of yellow flame and soot. I was expecting a faster boil time compared to methyl hydrate but for some strange reason under identical conditions on the bench in my garage it actually was slower to reach a boil. Part of me was relieve because the stuff isn't exactly cheap. As for the fondue fuel that I bought at Canadian Tire.. it just did not burn hot enough.

I plan on checking out the product mentioned above from Lee Valley Tools the next time I am in Calgary. I will let you know if it is of any value.

I sometimes wonder if I should even worry about the toxicity issue. In reality I take precautions never to get the fuel on my skin and if I do I rinse it off immediately. Most of my backcountry cooking is just boiling water and I do not stand over the stove and suck back the fumes… I have not done any testing but I doubt this would improve boil times. :) Paranoid?? I don't know.

Jeff

PostedMar 27, 2010 at 4:53 am

Hi Jeff,
I found the rubbing alcohol compound in the first aid section right next to the isopropyl alcohol. It's about $3.75 for 500ml. I'll be interested to hear about the Lee Valley stuff once you've tried it.

Viewing 3 posts - 26 through 28 (of 28 total)
Loading...