I'm looking for a UL but highly breathable rain jacket. The Marmot Mica looks great and weighs just 7oz. But how well does it breath? Like Goretex? Like eVENT? Somewhere in between? Or worse than Goretex?
Topic
Marmot Mica – How Breathable Is It?
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Yeah, its funny how the ad says 5.5 gallons of vapor in 24 hours per square meter of fabric. Well unfortunately we don't sweat evenly over a square meter. And also, how much can pass through in 2 hours? I bet a moderate exertion will still overwhelm it.
I guess this is all still the same ol' problem we've been facing… just a new ad campaign for it.
FWIW I use and love Marmot gear- just kinda hosin' it…
Yeah, I can push out an awful lot of moisture too — with a pot of boiling water! :)
eVENT is effective over a fairly wide temp rate (cold to cool) — but Goretex requires a wide difference in temp and humidity between the inside and the out in order to perform. I suspect the same with Marmot. Yeah, 20,000 when in the most ideal condition — but how quickly and deeply does performance drop when less than ideal?
Actual users, don't be shy…
Ben,
You keep circling the bowl and in the center is the ID eVent…time to jump in :-)
I'm not sure there is another fabric on the market currently that is waterproof with the breathability as eVent…probably why so many propriety brands compare their product to eVent.
Yeah, I know, I know…
But I want max breathabilty and lightest weight — but not the ugly Driducks! :)
It's a tough choice between shaving a few ounces if the Mica is truly very breathable — versus living with a few more ounces with the ID eVENT — a known factor…
What about the Super Mica?
I understand the Super Mica is made with the same wp/b laminate. It's more jacket than I need though.
C'mon… any actual Mica or Super Mica users out there?
Ben–I have a Mica that's seen tons of use for over a year. It's OK, not great, but it suits my needs. Excellent around town in the humid southeast. Hiking uphill, I get wet no matter the conditions though. There are no pit zips. My old Precip is actually breathes better since I can vent it. But since it resides in my pack most of the time, I carry the Mica due to weight and volume. My windshirt (Houdini) is what I wear for most light rain so the Mica doesn't come out much. I actually wear it for warmth more often than rain. So, it depends on your use. As a light shell that sees occasional use, it's great, but that's about it. If you have great breathability expectations, look elsewhere. Also, the rear hood adjustment is pretty mediocre–the velcro thing in the back on my model is a pain to adjust & impossible with gloves on, but once adjusted you can usually leave it alone, esp if wearing a ball cap. Drawcords near the face and visor are good though. It's surprisingly durable for the weight too. Hope this helps. Rain jacket decisions are tough–they all stink in my opinion.
hey ben, i acually just got one a few weeks ago. XL in black, weighs in a 7.8 on my scale.
well im pretty bumed so far. there has been a lot of precip this winter here in ncal but since the day i recieved it there hasn't been a drop of rain so i haven't been able to test it thoroughly.. I suppose i could just through it on anyway and go for a run in the sun..
The only thing i wish it had is pitzips. personally i would go for the Super Mica. it has pitzips and the pockets are chest high so they don't get in the way of a hipbelt. I would have got it but I got my Mica for $55 on ebay so you can't beat that.. Super is $199..
I used the Mica for a while, but then I sold it and got the Essence for the lighter weight (6.8 oz for size large) and better venting via the pit vents. These are not pit zips, since there is no zipper and they stay open at all times. However, there is a flap over them to prevent water from getting in. In my opinion, both are great jackets. Obviously, I find the Essence slightly better because of superior venting.
I will admit, however, that 90% of the time I am using my Rainshield jacket (like Driducks). At 5.5 oz and great breathability, I can deal with the poor durability.
I have been wanting to get an eVent jacket as well. I'm just waiting for a major manufacturer to make one that is 7 oz or under before I pull the trigger. Actually, it amazes me that nobody has released one at that weight yet. An eVent jacket that is 7 oz or under would be in a class of its own.
-Sid
Ben,
I have two Marmot jackets; an Oracle and an Essence. They both have under arm vents, the Oracle has huge zip pits, and the the Essence vents with a flap. The Oracle is hotter than the Essence. The Oracle uses thicker ply construction. Since I don't have an eVent jacket, I cannot comment on it versus the Essesnce.
I would say the Essence is better than my GoreTex jackets for breathability. The Essence weighs 6.7 oz in a large. I would suspect it is the same as the Mica. The Essence has only one pocket, at the chest.
I bought the Essence over the Mica because it was a little lighter. The Mica has more pockets and velco cuffs.
The Essence is discontinued, but can be bought on eBay. You have to be careful because earlier Essence models are made out of Precip material, versus the MemBrain Strata used in the Mica and new Essence.
I hate Dri Ducks, because the zippers are so finicky, one little crease and they are about impossible to zip up. When it rains, I want water protection I can count on.
Hope this helps.
Ben, I have both the Rab Drillium and a Marmot Essence. It's kinda of hard to judge my perception of breathability, since a lot of that depends on what baselayer im wearing under it and what im doing etc. Tell you what though. forecast here in Boston looks like its gonna rain/snow on fri and next monday. (seriously, snow in late march, this sh*t needs to stop) Ill take em both out for a jog with the same baselayer underneath and let you know how i feel. As i recall though, I liked my eVent more.
Thank you all — and esp. to Konrad. :)
For the record, the Essence is still on the Marmot site and available for purchase.
Ben,
I used to hike with the Rainshield 7 oz rain jacket but I was able to get the ID eVent Thru Hiker for $100 off thru eBay and did the JMT last year with it and it was so unbelievably great that I have no regrets about the extra weight. It is 13 oz (XL) but I was able to leave behind a 3 oz windbreaker I used to take (Montbell) that I wore when the Rainshield was too muggy and it wasn't raining. Now I can wear the Thru Hiker for either occasion, so I consider it only a 3 oz gain in weight.
I have no regrets. No looking back when one experiences the comfort and breathability of an eVent jacket.
OK, I'm going to stick with eVENT. I'll try the lighter option (ID rain jacket) and if it fits, I'll call it good. If not, then return and exchange for the ID Thru Hiker. Thanks, everyone!
"OK, I'm going to stick with eVENT. I'll try the lighter option (ID rain jacket) and if it fits, I'll call it good"
I don't think you'll regret it, Ben. It's a great jacket, simple, effective, and light. That said, I think it would be overkill for the Sierra, if that's where you intend to use it. I only carry mine up here in the Cascades.
Way to go Tom! Just when Ben had made a decision, you had to go and throw 'overkill' in. Now we will have to wait 3 more months and suffer through 18 new threads finding Ben the right jacket!;)
Something tells me Tom has been lurking for hours… There's a special place in hell for people like him! :)
"Now we will have to wait 3 more months and suffer through 18 new threads finding Ben the right jacket!;)"
Nah, I waited until I knew was going for it. ;}
"Something tells me Tom has been lurking for hours"
Who knows what evil lurks in the minds of men? Heh heh…
It rained 4 straight days in the Sierras last year (not all day, but about 2 hours each day). I really appreciated using it during that rain, plus is it so breathable, I used it every night as an evening jacket.
Actually, I don't see the event jacket as an overkill necessarily. My thinking is that because I hike within California a lot that I want maximum breathability! We don't get a lot of rain or mind-numbing coldness — but what we get is a lot of 'tweens where it's too cold for just a base layer — but not nearly cold enough to tolerate a piece of nylon that breathes suboptimally…
I would still be using this jacket if it were offered in a color other then green or yellow. I know, I know …
Ben, what's wrong with your Peak shell?
Become a member to post in the forums.

