Topic

BA, TT and Hilleberg tents

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Cory Cole BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2010 at 1:47 pm

Hi ya'll. I apologize in advance for the lengthy post but i'm looking for a little help with decision making and want you guys to know where I'm at.

I'm new to the BPL site, but have spent the past few months researching 2 man tents (for me and my wife – both under 5'7") for backpacking/fly fishing trips into the Wind River Mtns. Can't say enough about this site and its members – extremely insightful.

Here's what we're looking for in our tent:
-the lighter the better
-hold up to strong wind/weather – durable in mountainous terrain
-roomy for extra fly fishing gear and the occassional dog
-2 doors if possible

I have been looking at the following tents and would welcome any info you might have.

BA flycreek UL2
BA seedhouse SL2
MSR CR2
TT Double Rainbow
TT Squall 2
Hilleberg Rajd – haven't seen many comments on this tent –

As you can see, I'm still on the fence with the single/double wall. Love the weight of the single wall tents but have concerns about condensation and durability —- and so i seek your advice and stories of success with these tents at higher elevations and mountainous terrain.

I've read some of the reviews/threads and I look forward to more of your input on these (and other) tents. Thanks!

Cory

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2010 at 1:56 pm

Welcome. Remember, much of this is going to be subjective. As they say, YMMV (your mileage may vary). With that… of the tents you mentioned:

First round of elimination…

I would eliminate the Squall 2. The DR throws off winds from most all directions whereas the Squall — although it will perform very well when you have the foot end pointed to the wind — well, you need to have the foot end pointed to the winds (particularly strong winds) or you risk getting very suboptimal performance. And we know that winds can (and do) change directions… The Squall 2 is a great tarptent, but you've got the DR on your list…

I would also eliminate the Rajd. The tarptent Double Rainbow looks to perform better in strong winds and seems to perform better in condensation management — given its 360-degree mesh netting and top vents. It has legions of enthusiastic fans for good reasons.

Between the BA Fly Creek 2 and Seedhouse 2 SL, I would just eliminate the Seedhouse. The latter is also a great tent, but the newer FC is a lot lighter — and pegging the two corners at the foot end is no big deal.

Finally, for strong winds, I would be leery of the MSR CR2 because of the carbon fiber tent poles. You did mention strong winds, and having a pole snap on you is just not worth the small handful of ounces of weight savings.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2010 at 2:02 pm

Now for the second round:

If you mostly camp in temperate areas with low to moderate humidity, I would pick the Double Rainbow and call it good. Note that the improved and wider 2010 Double Rainbow should be coming anytime now.

If you want the maximum three-season flexibility including camping in humid places as well as cold/windy places, then you should get a double wall tent.

If you two like to snuggle and don't mind tight but adequate space, then get the BA Fly Creek UL2. But if you want the convenience of two doors/exits/vestibules — then also take a look at the slightly heavier BA Copper Spur UL2.

But if you want extra room for fly fishing gear and the occasional dog, you may want to look for a bigger tent — such as the Copper Spur UL3 (there are other brands too of course).

Boozer BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2010 at 2:29 pm

Quick Round 3 – Both BA's will really put a squeeze on you when you add the dog. Also if you would like to have 2 vestibules then the small limited vestibule of both the BA's are going to fall very short.

The TT DR is going to offer tons of really usable space. With both of you under 5'7" you'd have room for gear or dog at your feet. So far I'm picking it from the line up you already have – but

Have you looked at the new Nemo Meta 2P? I have no personal experience as few would since it is new, but it seems to have alot of what you are looking for and still sub 3 lbs rather than the 3 lb 5 oz minimum of the Copper Spur 2.

PostedMar 21, 2010 at 2:32 pm

None of these tents except maybe the Double Rainbow is going to have a significant amount of extra space for gear and a (presumably large) dog. If you're okay with a single wall tent, then I would add the Six Moon Designs Lunar Duo to your list. It's about the same weight as the Double Rainbow, but it gives you quite a bit more space. The floor is bigger and the side walls are pretty much vertical so you get a lot of headroom (unlike the DR whose walls slopes in significantly). The DR is probably better in high winds, though I suspect most tents are going to be adequate.

PostedMar 21, 2010 at 2:35 pm

Finally, for strong winds, I would be leery of the MSR CR2 because of the carbon fiber tent poles. You did mention strong winds, and having a pole snap on you is just not worth the small handful of ounces of weight savings.

As someone who has used the CR2, I can say that the carbon fibre poles seem very strong. I can't imagine one of these poles snapping just due to high winds. You'd almost certainly need a large snow load to cause that sort of trauma. Even if a pole did snap, there is a repair sleeve than can be used as a temporary fix. Supposedly most carbon fibre pole breaking results from the poles being stepped on and cracked, which then leads to a break. The CR2 uses Easton FX carbon poles, not the weaker Fibraplex ones. MSR stands behind these poles and will replace any broken ones for the lifetime of the tent.

The CR2 sounds a bit small for your needs and it only has one door, but I wouldn't avoid it because it has awesome and light poles.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2010 at 2:46 pm

Cory:

Note that Dan is an actual owner of the CR2 while I am not. It's why I chose the word "leery" rather than anything "definite".

My "leeriness" of carbon fiber poles stems not from the MSR brand, but from Fiberplex brand carbon fiber poles. I had 3 mishaps with them — twice when setting up my tent leisurely in my own back yard and the third time when winds were gusting in the field. I am normally very careful with my gear — and having read about the carbon poles, I was extra, extra careful to set up slow and easy, and to make sure that each section was set/connected fully.

I wrote a negative report on these poles and someone offered to buy mine within minutes. The weight saving was just too powerful a siren call. Anyway, I sold mine to him (but only after warning him again) — and he broke them too.

So, maybe you shouldn't write them off per se, but be careful.

Second CAVEAT: Be realistic about whether or not you will be hiking in highly humid or cold/windy places. No double wall tent can beat the area / weight attributes of a single wall tarptent — but there are good reasons for using double wall tents: condensation (when not enough of a breeze) and also draft (when too much breeze). Anyway, more food for thought.

Cory Cole BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2010 at 3:55 pm

Thanks guys, for the quick responses and the input. Does anyone have the specs for the 2010 TT double rainbow that Benjamin mentioned? I wonder how they compare to the new NEMO Meta 2p.

Benjamin – you're eliminations were freakishly similar to my own. I have the double rainbow as my top choice as well, but was concerned about its susceptibility to high winds that I've experienced in the Wind River Range and was hoping for some feedback on its performance.

You mentioned climate in my area – The majority of my hiking is in areas of low to high humidity, but with frequent nights of cold and strong winds – so not sure which way to lean – get one of each (single/double wall) – MORE GEAR!

I too, considered the 3 man tents, but figured for as few times as we bring the (medium-sized) dog with us its not worth the extra weight.

Jonathon – looks like you've successfully added another one "to the list." Looks real good actually.

Dan – i know I've looked at the the Six Moon Designs Lunar Duo, but not sure why i eliminated it – i'll have to revisit it.

Thanks again.

Cory Cole BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2010 at 4:14 pm

Dan/Benjamin;

Thought i'd make a separate post to address the MSR CR2 comments. I've read a lot of negative reviews/posts (width, pole strength, $$$, vestibule access, etc) on this site regarding that tent, and unfortunately only a few positive ones which somehow managed to keep me interested (I think i've read a few of your posts Dan).

Having said that, I found a new one for $350 this weekend, but the salesman told me he wouldn't recommend it – just had bad experiences with it – so I held off on it. I was more worried about the width than pole strength but hadn't seen one in person yet – width seemed okay for my wife and me.

Thanks for your sharing your comments with this tent though………

PostedMar 21, 2010 at 4:32 pm

Cory
The weight of the 2010 DR should be pretty close to the previous version. I guess that Henry will know when the first production run arrives.
As for the changes, you can see them here :
http://www.tarptent.com/doublerainbow2010.html
So because the floor can go higher when pulled up (for extra rain/wind protection) it also means that it is a bit wider when relaxed.
As stated on that page , two 25" wide mats fit side by side.
Franco
franco@tarptent.com

PostedMar 21, 2010 at 7:46 pm

I've read a lot of negative reviews/posts (width, pole strength, $$$, vestibule access, etc)

I think the width of the CR2 has received an usual amount of criticism not because it's unusably narrow, but because of the discrepancy between it's width and MSRs spec of 50". It is narrow but it's not ridiculous. BPL measured their CR2 at 40" wide in the middle and 46" at the corners. Mine measured about 42-43" wide in the middle and 46" at the corners. What's going on here in that the cross strut pulls the tent up in the middle so the floor effectively narrows by a few inches. If the tent was a bit looser (or the cross strut more flexy) the tent would be 46" wide the whole way. If you added a spot to stake it down in the center then you could have it wider. IMO, a width around 40-46" is totally fine for two. Especially when you consider how the vertical side walls give you a lot of headroom (unlike other tents like the DR and BA FC2). I was happy with using it with my wife and I would share it with a buddy if needed. She never commented that it felt small. However you're not going to have much room in the tent for extra gear or a dog. My wife and I managed to fit our small (20lbs) dog at her feet because the tent fairly long (about 7 ft of usable length). To picture what the CR2 is like inside, imagine two standard width sleeping pads taking up the full width of the tent, and then you'll have about a foot of extra space at either the head or feet depending on how tall you are. I sold my CR2 this winter just because I wanted to try a tent that is even lighter, so now I have a 15.2oz SMD Refuge X. We'll see how that goes but I'm optimistic.

The rear vestibule access is a poor design with just the vertical zip, but if you really need to store big stuff in here you can do it by slipping it in from the outside of the tent. This isn't ideal for sure, but it's not a huge deal IMO because the main vestibule is pretty large and it'll likely be all you need.

If you want a spacious double-wall tent that is really light, take a look at the new Six Moon Designs Haven. Ron says that a cuben version is in the works. The SMD site seems to be down right now so I can't get the specs, but the Haven will set up with trekking poles and it's larger and lighter than the CR2. I think it's about 2.5lbs trailweight and it'll be about 2lbs in cuben.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Loading...