Topic

MLD Grace Solo and Oware Cattarp 1.5

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
Jeff M. BPL Member
PostedMar 20, 2010 at 2:01 am

I'm interested in these two tarps in silnylon. From what I can tell they look very similar. Are there any significant differences between the two that I'm missing. Experiences with either one?

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedMar 20, 2010 at 5:36 am

Both tarps are similar and made by the very reputable shops. Either one will serve you well. The biggest difference is probably the wait time. The MLD tarp will likely take 6 weeks while I think the oware may be in stock and able to ship out quickly. I'm a big fan of MLD so don't discount them if you have the time.

The other small difference is Oware comes in 50' of line while the MLD tarp comes with LineLocs. I must say I absolutely love the LineLocs for adjusting tension. With both tarps you will need to buy 8 stakes.

Jamie

Eugene Smith BPL Member
PostedMar 20, 2010 at 6:34 am

Hey Jeffrey,

I own both a MLD Grace Solo Spinntex EXP and an Oware Cattarp 2.0 and will second what Jamie said, they are very similar in design. However, there are some craftsmanship details that Ron incorporates into the sewing process that I think are worth the extra time and money. I listed a few comparison points for the 2 tarps below:

MLD Grace Solo Plus

1. Pre-taped tieout reinforcements then sewn thru (no need to seam seal the tieouts, just the ridgeline)
2. Sewn on Linelocs @ tieouts (super convenient and fast)
3. x3 interior ridgeline mini clips (bivy, light, gear)
4. x2 ridgline tieout grommets+loop (trekking pole tips)
5. Mcnetts Seam Sealer for ridgeline included
6. 1 yr warranty for materials + manuf. defects

Oware Cattarp 1.5

1. Trapezoidal taper like the Grace Solo (taut pitch)
2. 8 tieouts (no sewn Linelocs, but a Mini LineLoc set is easy to acquire and add on if that is a preference)
3. Shorter ridgeline length compared to the Grace Solo (8.8ft vs. 9.3ft)
4. Lighter weight (8.7oz vs. 9.3 oz. for the Grace)
5. Seam sealer not included ($6 from Oware website)

Personally, both tarps are very well made, use quality materials and will serve the same purpose. I wouldn't hesitate to buy the likely In-Stock Oware Cattarp 1.5 and get on the trail sooner and try some things out, whereas the 6-8 week wait on the Grace Solo might keep you twiddling your thumbs as the weather warms up.

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
Loading...