Topic

TT Hogback vs. Golite 2010 Shangri-La 5+

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
PostedMar 19, 2010 at 1:23 am

I´m in the process of buying a tent for family backpacking trips for two adults and two children, five and eight years old.
So far my finalists are TT Hogback and the new Shangri-La 5+ with nest.
I would appreciate feedback on interior functionality, set up, wind stability, manufacturing quality etc. Thanks!

PostedMar 19, 2010 at 3:43 am

haven't used it in the field but the hog has fantastic interior space, all the space is useable due to the shape (as opposed to a mid where the wall slope restricts space) the build quality is top notch and it can be put up in two minutes flat-useful with young kids

Richard Lyon BPL Member
PostedMar 19, 2010 at 7:44 am

Very few backpacking tents fit a family comfortably. Particularly is that so with UL gear. A two-man tent accommodates two adults (i) who are used to camping and tight quarters and (ii) are willing to put up with a close fit to save weight. Children rarely are so tolerant. They usually like to move around. I agree with the prior post about the Hogback, based only on my experience with its smaller sibling the Scarp 2, but I doubt it'll work for four. You might consider a Stephensons Warmlite 5R or Kifaru tipi if the budget allows; otherwise I'd try to rig something with a Betamid or similar shelter. Think about what life will be like in a thunderstorm when you evaluate capacity.

PostedMar 19, 2010 at 8:45 am

We just bought a Rainshadow 2 for our two adults and 5 and 9 year olds. I'm the tallest in the group at 5'10", and we can all actuall fit in that tent fitting widthwise which frees up more space. It's a cozy fit for us, but it works and I'm planning on moving the kids into their own two person tent in a couple years leaving my wife and I with the larger space of the rainshadow.

My experience with our kids in the tent is that they are exhausted after dinner and head to bed early, and want to sleep late. Both of this means they are first into the tent and last out of the tent and therefore space is not really an issue.

PostedMar 19, 2010 at 9:41 am

Take a look at Cabela's online catalog for large dome tents. They've got a good selection.

PostedMar 19, 2010 at 3:59 pm

Stephenson's has updated the web site !
Had a look at the 5R .I would at least suggest the RT and windows , but that is over $900…
I would also take notice of the size, 90"x 184".

The Golite Shangri La 5 has more floor area inside the nest than the Hogback (71" vs 51") although some it is not usable.
Much larger vestibule but one entry/exit point. Larger footprint too.
On the Cabela site the 3/4 person Eureka and Cabela tents are all 8lbs plus.
Franco
franco@tarptent.com

PostedMar 20, 2010 at 1:02 am

Thanks for comments and insights in how you backpack with your families.

Weight and pack volume (and price) is important issues for me being the one carrying the tent :) even though the distances on our hikes naturally are limited.

What i like with the Hogback is the interior volume, low weight, two entries and high quality. What makes me hesitate is the gap between the fly and ground and wind stability. In the area where we backpack in northern Scandinavia on open tundra, high wind and wind-driven rain is common.
So Franco, knowing about your insights in Henry Shires plans I wonder if you have any info about making the same changes on the Hogback as on the Scarp 1+2?

Otto

PostedMar 20, 2010 at 1:28 am

Hi
Henry designed the Hogback for his family outings. That is himself, his wife, his 5 year old kid and Tioga ( this one has four legs and a tail).
Not meant to be used as a 4 season tent or the like but will work for all seasons here in Melbourne…
Never discussed the point, and Henry might just comment, but I cannot see doing a Scarp type change since air flow here is more important than blocking spindrift or high winds.
BTW, it does have a 5" bathtab floor.
Franco

PostedMar 20, 2010 at 2:18 am

No need for winter usage, but still comparing with the Shangri-La, you have possibility lowering the fly on wind side maintaining good ventilation, get better protection from wind-driven rain and draft.
Otto

PostedMar 20, 2010 at 12:47 pm

Here are some comparisons between the Hogback and Shangri-La 5 interiors. The green fabric is the Shangri-La "Nest"; the tan fabric is the Hogback interior. The blue pads are standard long pads (72" x 20"). Note that although the Shangri-La is marketed as sleeping 5, it isn't possible to fit 5 full length pads without overlapping them. Also, note the red line contour. It shows the 8" above ground elevation. In my view, for sloping walls anything below that line isn't usable except for small bits of gear as your head and/or feet will run into the wall. Also note that due to the Shangri_La single door configuration–the diagonal side on the diagram, at least one of the sleepers will have to step over 2 others to get out.

HogbackvsShangrila5

PostedMar 20, 2010 at 1:52 pm

Many thanks Henry extremly informative graphics.
It shows how well designed and functional the interior space are on the Hogback specifically looking at the benefits with a smaller foot print.

Yeah, hard decision. I need to sleep on this one it´s late in the evening over here.
Otto

Eric M BPL Member
PostedMar 20, 2010 at 10:21 pm

Not sure if this will help or not but here are a few pics of my SL5 I snapped for another forum.

Photobucket
Photobucket
Photobucket

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Loading...