I've been eying Montbell's UL SS bags for awhile now, and as there seem to be some sales out there at the moment I might finally pull the trigger. I'm trying to decide between the #1 and #2. I'd mostly be using it for car camping/climbing trips in areas with night temps in the 20s and 30s, but it would nice to not be limited for backpacking in the future. I guess I was wondering if the #1 would be manageable if it was a bit warmer, say 35, and how the #2 would go if it got colder than 25. I'd say I'm a cold sleeper, but that could just be cause I've only used my current bag which is old and synthetic. Cheers!
Topic
recommendation on montbell bag
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
For 20's and 30's — I would get the No. 2. My reasoning is that I like to match the bag warmth to the expected nighttime lows. My clothing (insulation, shell layers) then serve as "insurance" for any unexpected lows.
But if you buy a bag that will mostly be heavier than what you really need — then methinks you end up spending more and carrying more than you need.
My own experience is that MontBell's warmth ratings are spot on (I have two of their bags). Reading numerous user postings over the years, my recollection is that most users feel the same — but a few find the rating a bit overrated.
However, subjectivity aside, there have been occasional reports that MontBell bags are underfilled — i.e. quality control issue. So when you get yours, make sure that the weight is close to spec and also feel it to make sure the down appears properly spread out and all.
I don't want to exaggerate the quality control problem. Truth be told, if I remember correctly, the few complaints surfaced about 1-2 years ago — and I haven't come across any recently.
I have three Montbell UL SS bags (#2, #3, & #5). The temp ratings are spot on. Buy one, you won't regret it.
Shucks, campsaver sold out of #2 bags already. It sounds like the #1 might be more bag than I'll need. At what temps do you reckon the #1 would be uncomfortably warm to sleep in? And does anyone know of anywhere else the #2 might be going at a discount?
I have the #1 ulss, and I use it all the time, well not when its' super warm mid summer, but I just quilt it, or sleep on top of it, as I use silk jammies. I think this would work fine for you, and then have a real light summer one for the warmest time. Kinda depends how much use you will be using the bag the most for. Lots of spring/fall times, go warmer. Mostly mid summer, maybe not. Love the bag, good luck.
Become a member to post in the forums.

