Topic

Plantar Warts

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 10:09 am

"I have a plantar wart on my heel. I have tried the at home treatments but it is too deep in my tissue to get it our by "freezing it"

Been there done that. My experience: Freezing required multiple visits and was consequently becoming very expensive.

So I went with the self-help approach using a sheet of drugstore adhesive-backed 40% salicylic acid – 'Mediplast' by Curad in my case, at a cost of $1.60 x 2 = $3.20

Every 4 or 5 days, after a shower (you want soft moist skin) I used a surgical scalpel with replaceable blades($10) to pare away the dead tissue. I then cut out a 6mm circle of Mediplast, stuck it to my heal, and covered it with tape to help hold it in place. I did this for ~3 months. I checked along the way by letting things dry out and then applying vinegar to the area. A wart will turn white. Once I got no response to the vinegar I gave it another 2 weeks of treatment to be sure. No problems since. No scar. No problems or pain during the treatment.

Plantar warts grow 'into' the tissue because they cannot grow 'out' – you're standing on it. When they grow in far enough they hurt. As soon as you remove a little from the 'outside' the pain subsides. So almost immediately you will be able to walk pain-free. Eventually you erode away the whole thing.

Just commit to the time and do it. If you miss a week or two, no big deal – just be as consistent as possible. Eventually it will be gone.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 11:12 am

I like it. I'm all for keeping health care costs down. Home lesion removal may be a little more painful or take a little longer to heal. As long as you’re willing to put up with that, and you’re not a diabetic, AIDS, etc. I think it's a good idea. Doctors, PA's, NP's and such are usually very willing to do these procedures because insurance reimburses them much better than office visits, but why should they have all the fun.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 11:43 am

"Home lesion removal may be a little more painful" –

Not in my case. I did get a little "reminder" on being to aggressive in the beginning, but once the tape was in place everything was fine.

"Doctors, PA's, NP's and such are usually very willing to do these procedures" –

Yes, at $125/visit, I'm sure they don't mind. I quickly had a $500 foot, with no end in site. (Cryo.)

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 1:18 pm

thanks for the help. i wonder if the tagament will really work. i guess its worth a shot since i do get heartburn as well.

also, i had another thought: could the way i am forced to walk and hike b/c of the plantar wart be good for me? I have to walk and hike with most of my weight on the front of the foot b/c the wart is on the heel. is that good or bad?

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 2:27 pm

"…could the way i am forced to walk and hike b/c of the plantar wart be good for me?…"

IMHO – Not good! "Use is outside the design specification."

OTOH, if you were running, it Might be better.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 3:30 pm

I had one removed by a doctor – he cut and scraped it out. I couldn't walk comfortably for a couple of weeks and had to look at a hole in my foot, but it got the job done. The first shot of anesthetic the doc put directly into the wart was EXTREMELY painful, but the pain didn't last long.

These things can get a good way into your foot. Best to get the whole thing cleaned out by a doctor so you know it's all gone the first time.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 4:28 pm

If your willing to put up with the pain it's a good idea to communicate to your doctor that you would prefer an aggressive treatment rather than the possibility of multiple treatments.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 4:48 pm

I had a wart on my finger that responded to duct tape. Just put a fresh piece on every day for 3 or 4 months. Yes, it looked funny.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 4:59 pm

At the age of about 12 I got a couple of warts on the top of my hand. Having noticed that muriatic acid (hydrochloric acid) dissolve some metals (possibly my dad used that for rust) I applied that to my warts. They disappeared in a very short time (turned black and fell off, maybe in a couple of weeks)
Not recommended and could be a fluke but did the job for me.
Franco

Mark Hurd BPL Member
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 5:13 pm

The wart viruses live in the the very margins of our bodies. The immune system doesn't seem to mount much of a response. I tell my patients it's kind of like rats in the attic. You kind of know they are there, but unless something makes a whole lot of racket up there you don't pay much attention.

The freezing, and the wart plasters, the immune modulator drugs doctors use, and probably even the duct tape all act as local irritants. They get the attention of your own immune system which comes in and goes "OMG! we've got rats!" and starts to take care of the problem. Of course there is some mechanical destruction and removal of the tissue harboring the virus, but it is primarily the inflammation that gets the job done.

As for cimetidine, well, all the studies I've seen say that it works about 30% of the time in adults and 50% of the time in children. It turns out that placebos work about 30% of the time in adults and about 50% of the time in children.

-Mark

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 5:36 pm

–RANT

Don't go to the doctor for something that can be done at home. That's why my insurance premiums have gone up so much. If you have a cold and don't have AIDS then DEAL WITH IT! If you brake a toe or finger, good news it's gonna heal and there's not a darn thing your doctor is going to do but charge you for x-rays. If it hurts when you do this, STOP DOING THIS! ARG!

–END RANT

Just like to point out that this post is not directed at anyone in particular, but is directed to what might be called in the Army as "sick call Rangers."

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 6:59 pm

Ummmm….a broken finger can be splinted. And it should be, unless ya want a slightly crooked finger that will predict when rain is coming for the next 40 years.

My husband broke a toe and then re-broke it multiple times over a couple months. Finally he went in to the Dr, they showed me how to tape his foot up and it healed. That ONE appointment stopped the pain and re-breaking.

Sometimes knowing HOW to stop the pain and HEAL it is more important than just stopping.

Mark Hurd BPL Member
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 7:27 pm

Gary,
You may be surprised, but as a doctor, I agree with you (well in the general spirit of what you said anyway;-) Lots of folks come to the doctor for pretty minor problems. "I have a cold" being my pet peeve. It is a waste of their time, my time, and a drain on the health care "system." Agreed. I would also agree that a simple fracture of a toe most of the time can be taped to the toe next to it and do fine.

I would generally disagree that a broken finger can be treated the same way. People use their fingers in many more ways than their toes and most folks depend on their hands to make a living. Certain kinds of fractures (spiral) can leave you with a useless finger ( except for telling the weather:-). Other kinds of injuries can leave you unable to flex or extend limiting your ability to type or use a hammer, etc. So for significant finger and hand injuries where you think you may have broken something I think it is well worth going to see your provider.

-Mark

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
Loading...