Topic

Switching to trailrunners – maybe

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
Ben Wortman BPL Member
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 6:39 am

I am in the process of tweeking my gear list for a summer trip to the wind river range. This is going to be my first UL expedition. I have most of my gear figured out at this point, other than footwear. I have a pair of Lowa Tibets that I am used to wearing on backpacking trips to the rockies, but since my pack will be about 20 lbs lighter than normal, I might want to switch to trail runners.

Does anyone have any reservations about using trail runners in steep/rocky terrain? Should I just stick with my Lowas? I can't decide if the benefit of a lighter shoe would outweigh the lack of support on steep bushwacks.

Any thoughts? Thanks

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 6:55 am

Most people end up sticking with trailrunners once they switch. I'd bet you would like them. Boots are usually considered a bit too much.

I am an odd case, I kept spraining my ankles with low-top trailrunners. I have always had this problem since I was a kid. I now wear light mid-heights.

The extra height doesn't keep me from rolling my ankle, but it does limit the amount of roll so I no longer sprain.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 6:55 am

Just curious Ben, do you have an history of lower-leg/foot injuries? What type of footwear do you use in a typical day, and what are you doing? What is your opinion of your lower-leg/foot strength and stability? Do you participate in any activities that tend to strengthen these areas (yoga, martial arts, rock-climbing, ballet(!) etc)?

IMO trailrunners are preferable on steep/rocky ground as long as snow isn't present. I wouldn't want to kick steps in light shoes, but otherwise I think they perform better. You have to be much more careful about foot placement, but on steep terrain this is an issue with any footwear. Lighter shoes allow me to articulate my foot to the surface, where a stiff boot will not allow this. I also find stiff boots somewhat dangerous on steep slabs; since I can't flex my ankles as easily, it's much harder to keep the entire sole in contact with the surface of an angled slab. With shoes, I can easily keep the entire shoe sole in contact with the surface, rather than lifting my heels. If you spent time on slickrock with boots, you'll know what I mean.

Anyway that's my 2 cents. Pick up a pair of trailrunners and try them out. Even if you can't use them for backpacking, you still have a good pair of shoes for day-hiking or playing in the creek!

Ben Wortman BPL Member
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 7:07 am

I do have week ankles from many sprained ankles while playing basketball. That being said, I have never sprained an angle while hiking or running.

For those of you that have tried both hiking boots and trailrunners, at the end of the day, could you tell a difference in foot fatigue? Were your feet less tired with trail runners, or more sore due to the lack of support underfoot?

thanks

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 8:11 am

Personally I find the lessening of fatigue to be quite noticeable with trailrunners. Especially towards the end of a long day on the trail, I'm still light on my feet in trailrunners, making me less likely to misplace a step and incur an injury. In boots, I would be plodding along, and the combination of fatigue and the weight of big boots would make me more likely to misstep. The time when I prefer boots is on snowshoes, although for many other reasons than just support.

Jeffs Eleven BPL Member
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 8:15 am

If you switch, strengthen your ankles before the trip, or you may twist your ankle. If you normally have taller boots on, your ankles haven't done much work, and will be weaker.

Also, beware that many of the really light TR shoes may not be stiff enough to protect your foot from sharp rocks that are usually associated with steep trails.

For me, the lack of a shank (I guess, not too versed on shoe construction- midsole, maybe?) left me wanting something more underfoot. I want Salomon XT wings rather than my Comp 4s- too soft.

Maybe merrels for would be a good intermediate for your switch from boot. I like some of them, but they are too narrow for me. Also, maybe an approach shoe.

Anyway, the venting is AMAZING, walking with 'cool'(not just non-sweaty, but COOL) feet is something to behold.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 8:54 am

I made the switch to trail runners a a few years ago and have not looked back. I can move quicker and easier over all sorts of terrain.

Best decision I made along with going UL. I think that they happened about the same time.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 9:14 am

I too am making the switch. I did 40 mi of the PCT in TNF Hedghogs a couple weeks ago and they worked well. Because of all the rain the trails were heavily eroded and a lot of rock is exposed in areas. I noticed that my feet got sore, most likely due to the lighter soles.

I just bought a pair of inov8 Flyrocs and am looking forward to trying them out. Maybe this weekend.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 9:28 am

My experience with boots vs. trail runners is identical to Scott's. I have a pair of boots which are very comfortable and GoreTex-lined, but they're a last resort. I'd rather be in trail runners with wet feet. My boots don't hurt or fatigue my feet, but I definitely feel more fatigue in my thighs and hips when wearing them. I'm much more clumsy on steep or soft terrain when wearing hiking boots.

One thing which helps me avoid sprained ankles is that I view falling as a way to save my ankle. Maybe learning to break falls well will help you have more confidence to instinctively fall when your ankle senses rolling? There are martial arts videos on youtube which instruct in good falling techniques. Trekking poles might help prevent sprains some, but they also hinder good falling technique.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 9:32 am

Looking back, switching from hiking boots to trail runners wasn't really much of a switch at all. As a child (under 18), sneakers were just what I wore when I was walking through the woods, scrambling up mountains, or whatever. Also, even as an adult, I wear sneakers (trail runners) in everyday life. I have different pair, but I wear sneakers running, walking, biking, at work, in the garden, etc.

The real "switch" happened when I started "hiking" in college and apparently that meant you needed to wear boots. Although I liked the pair of boots that I used for many years, the two things I never liked about them were (1) the amount of time it took for them to dry and (2) the "ankle support" made me sloppy on the downhills and I'd often roll my ankles. If anything, it seems that boots weaken your ankles, because they don't allow you to develop those muscles fully.

When I finally just realized that I could just wear my sneakers hiking/backpacking, that was all it took and I've never looked back to the boots. Yes, I still use boots for winter hiking, but for 3-season hiking I use trail runners. Right now, I wear New Balance 812 AT trail runners. I buy factory seconds and get them really, really cheap!

Monty Montana BPL Member
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 10:06 am

Ben, my experience was similar to the one Thomas describes: hiking in sneakers in the early years, then succumbing to peer pressure and "the cool factor" to wear heavy mountaineering boots, then a long journey back to "sensible shoes".

My last boot was the Lowa Tanark, which won the BP Editor's Choice a few years back and was the lightest on the market, yet my feet were still sore and sweaty at the end of the day. Then one day I noticed these things at STP called trail runners and on a whim decided to give 'em a go. Wow, what a difference! I wore those LaSportivas well past their useful life. By then I was a member here at BPL and heard about Inov8s and ordered their mid-height version (370 & 390) and the Montrail Namche, both highly popular amongst the lightpacking crowd. After many miles my vote goes to Inov8.

Earlier this Winter I began trying out the Teva X-1 Control 2 and like them…they have a sole plate under the tread which protects from sharp stones. Yesterday some Inov8 315s arrived and I'm anxious to put 'em through their paces. What's interesting about these two shoes is that they're lowcut…by wearing "sneakers" my feet have strengthened and so I'm more confident about gettihng away from higher shoes. BTW, both of these shoes are on sale at Sierra Trading Post.

Jeffs Eleven BPL Member
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 11:01 am

Innov8 users: is there sufficient underfoot protection?

The few I've held seemed like it would be death on rough trail, so I never tried them.

Are they good just because of the infinitesimal (gotta get that one in again) weight, or is it really a good shoe?

(marginal threadjack)

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 12:22 pm

very comfortable. best thing is they let your foot do what its designed to do so you are more aware of what the foot is hitting on the ground.

I find the durability to be great. mine are over a year old and a little duct tape on the heel and I expect to get a few more months out of them.

for the record i have the Roclite 315s and highly recommend them.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 5:25 pm

"Innov8 users: is there sufficient underfoot protection?"

My 370's have been fine so far in some fairly rough country, with loads up to 31#.

They're very good for limiting ankle roll, thereby preventing a roll from turning into a sprain.

Monty Montana BPL Member
PostedMar 18, 2010 at 9:44 pm

The sole is flexible, yet firm. So you won't feel sharp rocks poking through or have to be be concerned about bruising your feet.

Nate Davis BPL Member
PostedMar 19, 2010 at 3:45 am

The switch:

I made the switch last September and won't be going back. I will warn you, though, my ankles were weak and they did roll on those first few hikes. After about three hikes of just three or four miles a piece, the issue ceased. I would absolutely suggest building several training hikes into your schedule before you take the trail runners on an actual trip.

Inov-8:

Just bought my first pair of Roclite 315's about two weeks ago. They're only twenty miles old or so, but so far, I love them. I hike and run on technical terrain, and the protection seems adequate. I can feel sharp edges on rocks more than I could before, but not in a dangerous way.

They do take a bit of getting used to, but I think I could have bought these as my first pair and still have been just fine. They're super comfortable, very light, and I feel much more stable than I did in my last pair of shoes. I think this is due to the fact that I can actually feel the ground beneath me.

I may be tempted to try out other models, but I plan to stick with Inov-8 from here on out.

Oh, and I'd recommend buying them from revelsports.com if you can. Their customer service was EXCELLENT. My first pair of these shoes tore apart due to a fluke manufacturing defect within nine miles of having them. I took a picture, sent it to Revel Sports, and had a new pair at my doorstep in four days. They didn't even ask me to return the old ones. Can't get better than that!

As I would have expected, this new pair is doing great. Inov-8 has a great reputation and I really do believe my issue was a fluke.

BRIAN BOLIN BPL Member
PostedMar 19, 2010 at 6:19 am

The blue/silver models are on clearance on Invo8s US website. I got mine yesterday and I only paid $54 and that includes shipping.

Very light shoe. Definitely need to strengthen my feet, they will get sore if not. I also noticed that with putting shoe on…make sure your socks are on without any crease in them and where the toe stiching is that it is nice and smooth. You WILL feel any flaw in your sock if just thrown on.

Ben Wortman BPL Member
PostedMar 19, 2010 at 7:01 am

How do the sizes run on the Inov8's? I usually wear 11.5's or 12's. It is tough to pull the trigger on shoes from the web since I have never tried them on. I also don't have any retailers near me that carry them (Nebraska is not a Hiking Mecca)

Thanks

CW BPL Member
PostedMar 19, 2010 at 7:09 am

Do you wear a normal width shoe or a wide?

Ben Wortman BPL Member
PostedMar 19, 2010 at 7:15 am

I use a normal width, but sometimes find they are a bit narrow.

John Vance BPL Member
PostedMar 19, 2010 at 7:52 am

If you are going to be staying on the trails you should be OK. If a significant amount of time is off trail I would hesitate due to lack of ankle protection. This is different from stability as I have had problems with lowtop shoes/boots and ankles being banged up by rocks.

I have found a great alternative to trail runners in the Timberland Cadion XCR's. In my size 11.5 a pair weighs 34oz including superfeet insoles. This is actually lighter than some trail runners with so much more support and are even non rigid crampon compatible.

Earlier versions had som QC issues but I have mine for 3 years and some 900 miles with no issues. They can be hot, but in the Winds you be fine unless you have particularly sweaty feet.

Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
Loading...