Anyone have experience with the REI balaclava? Is the Patagonia R1 truly the BPL favorite or did it just happen to get the most reviews? Any suggestions?
Topic
balaclavas
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Haven't tried either of the ones you mentioned.
I have the OR Wind Pro. This thing is great for me. Doesn't choke me or make me feel like I'm in a bag. WARM. NO WIND gets through. I can hike in it and sleep in it – roll it up as a beanie. Can pull it down and make a neck gaiter but it works best as designed.
My head is my thermostat – wanna cool down I take it off – wanna take the chill off – slip it on.
I have the OR Ninjaclava and love it. I bought it off someone at BPL who didn't care for it so much, so it's obviously a preference thing.
For me, it does a great job regulating temperature, fits comfortably, and covers nearly all of my face when I need it to. It's easily convertible into a warm beanie, so I don't need to bring anything else for headwear unless we're talking extremely low temperatures.
I haven't slept in it yet, but will probably be taking an overnight in two weeks, so we'll see at that point. I'm assuming it'll be comfortable.
.
+2 on the OR Ninjaclava- it regulates perfectly as I can cover everything but my eyes, pull it under the chin without feeling as if I am being strangled, or push it up as a hat.
I wear it all winter long, mostly under a helmet.
Nate- I've slept in it many times. I usually use it to cover my mouth and nose when it hovers around 0 outside my bag, and those areas get wet. I often carry a backup and switch them out in the morning, drying the damp one under my clothing during the day.
I use a Mountain Hardware Powerstretch balaclava. It weights 1.5z and has kept me warm down into the teens on backpacking trips. If it gets too warm, I pull it up off the face.
an absolutely awesome piece of gear. soooooo versatile. this gets worn in such a variety of ways that i never go hiking without it.
i haven't really heard anything negative about the outdoor research ones either. i'd buy either with confidence
I like the warm when wet and low smell of wool for my face. Wool power makes a thicker merino wool balaclava than others I have found. This is the one I use:
"I use a Mountain Hardware Powerstretch balaclava. It weights 1.5z and has kept me warm…"
+1 down into the mid 20's in my case, but still…
HA! Wool smells a LOT more than polyester when it's wet or damp. I use wool in one place only, on my feet – and there only as part of a mix of fibers.
Low smell of wool indeed.
If I wear poly for more than a day I can't even tolerate the smell of myself… I haven't found the same for wool.
Edit: For balaclava different story…
No experience with the ones mentioned but I did just get this Loki_Balaclava as a gift. It’s similar to a buff and it does the hat, balaclava, neck gaiter, ear warmer switch-a-roo. It weighs 2 oz as well.
Become a member to post in the forums.

