Topic

what should i choose for a summer bag?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
PostedMar 15, 2010 at 4:05 am

Ok, iv got a FF Lark coming in the mail.
But now im looking to get a 30 degree Farenheit sleeping bag for warmer nights.

I had narrowed it down to the following 3:
-Feathered Friends Osprey.
-Western Mountaineering Summerlight
-Nunatak Sub Alpinist (with sufficient overfill to make it a legit 30 deg bag)

Now im stuck…which one of the 3 to i choose?!
Other suggestions are welcome.

Im based in Australia, so i can get the FF shipped for free with my Lark for which the shipping has been paid…Hermits Hut is doing international shipping for free for Western MOuntaineering, only Nunatak (also the priciest) will cost me near $40 for shipping.

Im open to other suggestions (fabrics/customizations for the Feathered Friends and Nunatak).
but i do want a top end quality bag, preferably cottage industry made and made in the States.

Cheers guys!!

Pedro Arvy BPL Member
PostedMar 15, 2010 at 6:28 am

Without doubt the FF bags don't seem to have the fill of the other two.

I'd go the WM but check you like the width in Paddy's.

Ted E BPL Member
PostedMar 15, 2010 at 6:31 am

its temp rating a little higher than what your asking for, but i bet they could add some down and you could add a silk liner to get the rating down to 30 degrees. both bags are under 16 oz

PostedMar 15, 2010 at 1:28 pm

hey Pedro, yeah i was in Paddy Pallin's Ringwood store, checkin out the WM's Summerlight and i tried one out, it fits fine…probably even slightly large cos im only a 165cm guy..i cant believe their sellin them for near $700 here, its stupid.
I thought the loft of FF down was 800+ or 850, please, if anyone can correct or reassure me on this it would be great!
And i like FF, cos of their Epic shell, just incase the weather turns, and the tent aint good.

PHD designs? they claim they use 900 loft down….is this marketing BS? cos i havnt heard of anyone else using 900+ loft (Roger Caffin please help me out. I know you dont beat round the bush with marketing bs)

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedMar 16, 2010 at 8:47 am

Siggy, the fill power of the down doesn't have anything to do with how well the sleeping bag baffles are filled. Higher fill power just means you can use less down to get the same amount of warmth as you would w/lower fill power (ie, perhaps 9 oz of 850+ gets you as much warmth as 12 oz of 600 fill).

Some companies are known for under-filling their bags a bit. You can look at bags hanging in a shop and just straight see that some bags loft better than others. That's the reference that was made re: the FF bag. FF makes great stuff; when I had the Osprey next to a Summerlite, though, the Summerlite was clearly better filled. More stuff in it, though the same quality of down in each.

The Nunatak would be nice, too… Or just get an Osprey over-filled (seems I recall people recommending the same w/Nunatak?).

PostedMar 16, 2010 at 9:56 am

Brad,

I noticed people are always saying the WM bags are warmer than stated on the label, do you think this is a result of overfilling? so then would a WM bag would be heavier than stated in the specs?
cos i guess if the WM bags were as light as stated, and as overly lofty as stated by people, then their fillpower would be greater than that of FF, wouldnt it?
would u know what the standard fillpower of FF is? would anyone know if there are options available from FF in regards to fillpower and how much it would be?

PostedMar 16, 2010 at 5:44 pm

i just find it strange, that for some reason, as time and technology passes…higher and higher loft grades are discovered…..though the geese are exactly the same as they were 15 years ago when 750+ was the top pick.

I might order myself one of those beanies.
Would anyone know how hardwearing/water resistant that extremelight fabric WM uses in their bags is? Cos now, im pretty much thinking either the FF or WM (cos i dont have to pay for shipping), and cos i hear Nunatak take a LOOONG time to catch up with their orders.
I'd take a FF Osprey with Epic, or that Summerlight with extremelight microfibre.
Ur thoughts please?

Travis L BPL Member
PostedMar 16, 2010 at 7:36 pm

Siggy,
This is just a guess, but 15 years ago when 750 fill was the "top pick," there was nowhere near the demand for ultralight equipment as there is today. There were less people who needed it, and even less willing to pay for it. It probably wasn't practical for companies to incorporate into their products. Now, there's a market for the more expensive 850-900 fill down.

But, that's purely a guess!

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 4:26 am

yeah, this is a good point….bags have always been expensively priced for the higher end gear.
Yeh, ive kind of chosen….but still open to a last minute change.

FF Osprey/Merlin, with an epic shell…not as light as WM's summerlight…but i would rather have a stronger shell, cos that extremelite fabric prob isnt tough enough against abrasion..

Still open to suggestions though. totally.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 5:49 am

Hi Siggy, just curious why you are worried about abrasion on your sleeping bag shell? The WM extremelite is plenty tough. As tough as Pertex Quantum I'd imagine, and I have at least 150 nights on the shell of my Marmot Hydrogen(2004 PQ shell), which looks pretty much brand new. And I don't use tents; these nights are either under a tarp or under the stars. In fact, last night was the first time the Hydrogen has been used in an enclosed floored bug shelter. So I wouldn't worry too much about abrasion.

Condensation resistance on the other hand …

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 1:04 pm

yeah, ur right. i really just meant general wear and tear.
Its just that i was in Paddy's lookin at the WM Highlight, and i was quite taken back by how thin the extremelite fabric is, it almost made me feel unsecure!
but your right, i mean WM wouldnt just go out and take the risk with weak fabrics, it must be strong stuff.
How is the condensation handling though? Cos i hear Epic is quite good. I'd be using the bag in damp conditions hovering just above 30 quite a lot.

Thanks Scott.

Gabe P BPL Member
PostedMar 17, 2010 at 1:35 pm

Have you considered WM's line of bags with Microlight XP? The weight different between the Microlight XP fabric and the Extremelight fabric isn't that significant — depending on the temperature rating and features you're looking for. Most people on BPL seem to prefer the Extremelight fabric, though, which makes me think it must work extremely well. I have two WM bags, both with Microlight XP. I'm happy with them. They're durable, very water resistant and they breath well.

PostedMar 17, 2010 at 10:24 pm

wow, yeah this is true.

Oh, does anyone know if the FF bags have reverse differential cut hoods like the WM bags?
But i hear the WM Summerlight is narrower than the FF Osprey.
Damn the time difference between Australia and the Pacific North West! looks like im going to have to delay the order til tomorrow morning…
Anyone have experience taking the 900+ loft option for the FF bags? i have heard rumours bout it, but no one lists the prices.

Oh…i just looked at the BPL review of bags….Im curious if anyone has used the Volandre range of bags, The PHD bags or the Terra Nova 900+ fill bags..care to share your thoughts?

Pedro Arvy BPL Member
PostedMar 18, 2010 at 5:51 am

"And i like FF, cos of their Epic shell, just incase the weather turns, and the tent aint good."

Unless you are under a small tarp without a bivy this is DEFINITELY not an issue.

I ordered a FF bag a few years ago and even though the cut and fill were specified it just didn't have the loft of my friends WM Ultralight which should have been identical.

"Would anyone know how hardwearing/water resistant that extremelight fabric WM uses in their bags is?"

I know three people with WM bags and the fabric is not an issue. Yes it is thin but it is remarkably strong and tough.

Definitely go the WM, you are an ultra lighter now – act like one.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedMar 18, 2010 at 6:03 am

Have you considered any Montbell bags? Their UL Spiral Down Hugger #3 is rated to 30 degrees F, weighs 19 ounces, and is only $228 US dollars. There's a review here on BPL.

PostedMar 18, 2010 at 6:14 am

hi siggy

used the summerlite in south australia and tasi with great success. there has been a recent review of these temp rated bags – definitely worth looking at

got mine from the hermits hut web store cheap compared to the ridiculous prices we get charged in Australia and at the time got shipping for free

good luck

nick

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedMar 18, 2010 at 4:52 pm

Sorry, been out a couple days. I don't think WM bags are overfilled, I think they're properly filled. I think other companies tend to under-fill their bags. WM bag weights match their specs; I own three, and they're all on-spec. Weight is not purely a factor of fill-power; it's also related to materials and construction, for example. My recollection is that both WM and FF use 850 FP down.

Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
Loading...