Topic

Which heart rate monitor

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Robert Blean BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2010 at 3:44 pm

I have a Polar HRM now, and it is getting time to replace the battery. Considering that I would like to have minimum heart rate, and how expensive it is to send it in for battery replacement, I am considering just buying a new HRM.

What I want is a simple one — large heart rate numbers, time, heart rate, and tells my minimum heart rate (so I can use if for easily telling resting heart rate).

I don't need anything fancy — no splits, time in zone, etc — actually, they are a drawback, because they complicate the HRM.

Polar has no watch that meets this description. Timex T5G941 looks pretty good — the only thing I wish it had is including seconds with its time. Unfortunately, it gets a significant number of bad reviews at Amazon, making me question its reliability (even though it averages 4 stars).

All suggestions welcome.

Thanks,
— MV

Robert Blean BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2010 at 5:03 pm

One of the Amazon reviews also complained about water getting in.

I was surprised, because one of the features claimed for this watch is water resistant to 30 meters.

— MV

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2010 at 5:19 pm

You might check into the Sportline heart rate watches.

I won't claim that they are the best in the world, but I have one that worked fine for 11 months. Then "the button" disappeared, the one that activates the heart rate function.

–B.G.–

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2010 at 7:35 pm

> one of the features claimed for this watch is water resistant to 30 meters

This fine bit of industry hype actually has almost no meaning at all. If you are very lucky the watch may be slightly splash-resistant. Maybe.

The clue lies with the word 'resistant': that is NOT the same as 'waterproof'. For further detail on this see my small rant on the subject at BGT:
http://www.backpackgeartest.org/reviews/Electronic%20Devices/Watches/Timex%20WS4%20Watch/Test%20Report%20by%20Roger%20Caffin

Cheers

Robert Blean BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2010 at 8:06 pm

Roger,

Thanks for the comment, and I agree. I have not looked into it as much as you have, but I had already noticed where it said not to go swimming with it.

That struck me as strange, but I (mentally) shrugged my shoulders and thought that it must at least be OK with things like rain, wet clothing, and heavy sweating.

Perhaps I was being too optimistic?

— MV

Robert Blean BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2010 at 8:43 pm

Just for everyone's amusement, I could not find anything on the Timex site about waterproof/resistance for the heart rate monitor in question (Timex T5G941).

The Amazon.com description said the following: … and is water resistant to 30 meters (100 feet)–enabling it to withstand splashes and accidental dunks into the water, but not suitable for swimming.

At least they are fairly open about it. I am not sure what to make of even Amazon's description when thinking of being out in the rain, though, especially if covered by a wet shirtsleeve.

— MV

PostedMar 14, 2010 at 6:41 am

Since my G-Shock is "water-resistant 200m", I did a little research on the term water-resistant.

There are actually standards for the term water-resistant. ISO 2281 Horology – Water-resistant watches, defines what the terms mean, and the fairly simple testing protocol.

So assuming the manufacturer adheres to ISO 2281, the term does have a meaning. If the summary of ISO 2281 in Wikipedia is correct, water-resistant (or water-resistant 30m) means —

"Suitable for everyday use. Splash/rain resistant. NOT suitable for swimming, snorkeling, water related work and fishing"

There is a separate, much more rigorous standard for diver's watches…

Robert Blean BPL Member
PostedMar 14, 2010 at 8:53 am

Roger,

The clue lies with the word ‘resistant’: that is NOT the same as ‘waterproof’.

Dangerous place, these forums — too easy to get off looking into something ….

I looked on Wikipedia in the Watch section, and one thing I found was Watches may be crafted to become water resistant. These watches are sometimes called diving watches…. The International Organization for Standardization … prohibits the term “waterproof” to be used with watches, …. I was surprised that this applies even to watches that are for diving.

So it looks as if there is no such thing as a “waterproof” watch standard, so use of “water resistant” is not a tip-off. I strongly agree with you that including “30 meters” or “50 meters” in what they call it is a deceptive practice, standard or no standard.

–MV

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Loading...