Topic

Windshirts and insulation

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2010 at 8:19 am

I've wondered about wind shirts and coordinating them with a good insulation layer. Many folk use a light insulated jacket like the MontBell Thermawrap or the down equivalent, Patagonia down sweater, etc. These are wonderful garments, but they have their own shell built in, duplicating the windshirt.

I wonder if the hikers who use these thinner insulated jackets are also packing a wind shirt. I appreciate your feedback.

Living in my soggy Pacific NW climate, fleece has been a staple for years. I find that if you stick with "plain" 200w fleece garments you end up with light, very comfortable, quick drying insulation that mates perfectly with a wind shell, can be worn next to the skin, and is excellent for sleeping in. I have a Patagonia Synchilla crew-neck pullover that is 10.4 ounces and I'll wager it provides the same amount of real loft that the Thermawrap does. Polartec Power Stretch works much the same way, with a little less loft, but better wind resistance. Plain 200w fleece tops run 16oz and up, but offer all the features above with yet more loft and are relatively inexpensive.

So what do you think– and use?

PostedMar 12, 2010 at 8:35 am

i have a down sweater. i have not had to use it while hiking as i live and hike in NM. the sweater does a good job of blocking wind and i would rather just take my rain jacket to use for both. plus the down needs to be kept dry. as you said, i have hiked with my R1 and rain shell, which works extremely well. just my thoughts.

PostedMar 12, 2010 at 8:41 am

golite ether/marmot driclimb

i have the golite ether windshirt and love it great very lightweight windshirt as to layers i normally wear the ether over my marmot driclimb wind jacket which is also an awesome lightweight garment this combo is a very warm combo when on the move the marmot doesn t breathe great however i think the new versions have pit zippers in them to make them more efficient
either way i like mine a lot it has been a winning setup for my uses
kevin

PostedMar 12, 2010 at 8:43 am

I also hike in a damp climate, and haven't found anything that works better for myself than the baselayer/100 weight fleece/windshirt combo for 95% of the time.
I carry synthetic and down insulation, but usually only for rest breaks and camp wear.

PostedMar 12, 2010 at 8:48 am

I carry a light puffy for camp and a windshirt for traveling. I camp and hike in N.E. which is a very moist environment as well. The versatility of a windshell (curently using a houdini)for moving in all but drenching rain and snow is great. I would never use a puffy or 200 weight fleece while moving even in fridgid mid winter weather or I would be soaked from persperation. Then when in camp my windshell can dry(as best it can) for the next days travels and I put on my insulation and if necessary a hardshell to stay dry. So in my experieince the wind shell is for moving and insulation is for camp/rest breaks.

PostedMar 12, 2010 at 10:01 am

My insulation is an old grey 90% wool Woolrich cashmere dress sweater that was at the end of its useful life. Nice and fuzzy at its age which creates "loft. It's exactly 12 oz..not really UL. Paired with a Marmot windshirt it provides a surprising amount of warmth at a total of 15.5 oz. Not bad. The price is right, versatile. I am seriously happy with this setup for 3 seasons.

This pairs well with an ID rain cape.

James Naphas BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2010 at 8:48 pm

Yes, I carry both. I generally carry an old marmot chinook windshirt (very breathable, not too water-resistant, 3.7 oz in a large) and a light puffy layer. They tend to serve different purposes in the dry southern Sierras. I usually throw the windshirt on when I stop for a break to prevent the flash chill from sweat evaporation, use it sometimes when the bugs are fierce but temps are warm, wear it starting out hiking on a chill morning, as an outer layer if it's misting or almost raining, and probably a few other times where a WPB is going to create a wet microclimate next to my skin. The puffy is for camp insulation and extending the temperature range of my sleeping bag.

In the summer I'll sometimes substitute a poncho for a WPB shell. In this case the windshirt can be worn as a light water-resistant layer under the poncho if the wind and rain is howling.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...