Topic

Sierra winter bag recommendations

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
PostedMar 8, 2010 at 7:44 pm

Following two recent threads about those of us who sleep cold (with low blood pressure to boot), I'd like to solicit opinions on a winter bag for Sierra use.

I'm really only looking at Western Mountaineering bags, and the decision is more or less between the Antelope and Lynx (the Kodiak is too wide).

I have a GG 1/8" thinlight which I will mate with a Torsolite and Ridgerest for pads and stock GG sit pad for my feet, down booties, a light and heavy down jacket (which I'd rather not resort to for sleeping), R1 tops and bottoms, R2 vest, and I always wear thin merino base layers. I'll probably get a balaclava as well, but already have good fleece hats, and I do use the hoods on bags. My current bag is a Summerlite.

Generally, my core temp is fine. It's my extremities, and my feet in particular that get really cold; cold enough that it wakes me up and keeps me from getting a solid night sleep, and in conditions many others find quite ammenble. Arms where they press against the bag and legs to a lesser extent, but the winder girth of the bags I named should obviate the arms as a source of concern.

I'd really rather save weight and go with the Antelope (and lower cost), but camping in the snow in winter in the Sierra is not where I want to make a mistake. I was considering the Versalite, but I'm fearful that I'll still be cold, so it's more or less down to the Antelope or Lynx.

I have good heat-maintenance habits regarding hydration, calories, dryness, etc.

So, thoughts on which to choose? I haven't snow camped in years, and although many years ago I was able to camp successfully down to -25, I'm much older now, and with trips coming up soon, I need to sort this out. Thoughts from winter Sierra veterans much appreciated!

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 8, 2010 at 9:56 pm

You need to define the temperature range that you are shooting for. Some people sleep out in the dead of winter, and others do ski tours in March. Two completely different things.

I was leading a beginner snowcamping trip one time, and some people were there with +15 F bags. I sensed that it was going to get a little cold that night, so I warned them that if they weren't sure if their bags were going to be warm enough, that they should dig a snow cave instead of sleeping in a cold tent. Well, nobody listened, so I dug my own snow cave. After dinner and after dark, everybody crawled into their tents, and I crawled into my cave and into my -20 F bag. I read a book and fell asleep with my torso out of the bag. By midnight, I woke up, and I hadn't gotten cold due to the relative warmth of the cave, even though I had been only half covered. A good snow cave will be about +32 F, so it doesn't take the world's greatest bag to keep you warm. The people in tents got very cold that night, because it had gotten to about +5 F.
–B.G.–

PostedMar 9, 2010 at 6:16 am

Great comments Bob; I was hoping you'd chime in!

That's part of the problem: I don't know exactly all the conditions I'll be in. I can say that it'll most likely include sleeping in a four season/mountaineering tent below tree line through the middle of winter. I know that I have at least one trip coming up in which I will share a tent with someone else. But it's also likely that many of my trips will have me in a solo tent. It's also possible that at some point I may start sleeping above tree line.

In a perfect world, I'd have one bag that would take up where my Summerlite stops working (roughly 32f) and be good for the rest of the winter, but I fear that's unrealistic.

Where I'll be in three weeks, this week's night time lows for the coming week range from 2f to 15f.

In the long term? Really hard to say, but probably colder than that.

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 9, 2010 at 12:30 pm

There are many good brands of sleeping bags, and then there are some really awful brands. For each brand, there are models appropriate for your needs. Some brands try to stretch the temperature rating unrealistically, and other brands have a reasonable reputation.

I've had my best service from these: REI, Feathered Friends, Western Mountaineering, and Mountain Hardware. I've taken good care of them, so some of these are 30 years old and still going strong (or is that the odor that is strong?). I've had to keep them clean and wash properly only when necessary.
–B.G.–

PostedMar 9, 2010 at 10:22 pm

You say you have a summerlite – what temp does that take you to comfortably? If you find that bag keeps you warm to the rated temp, then another WM bag will probably keep you warm to its rated temp with the same sleepwear and the appropriate pad. so, if the Summerlite keeps you warm on the Thinlight and the torsolite down to 32, then with the addition of a full-length ridgerest – or a 3/4 length ridgerest and a sitpad under the feet/knees – the antelope will probably get you to zero as rated. For most Sierra snow camping that will be warm enough. BUT. If you want to be able to go out at any time, any weather, and be confident that you'll be warm no matter what, and have that little extra margin for times when you get dog-tired and don't eat enough dinner, then you'll be glad you got the Lynx.
I don't go out in the dead of winter anymore, but I do go ski touring in Sierra in the spring. A couple years ago I tried taking my summer bag (marmot Hydrogen) and wearing my clothes to bed. It doesn't get that cold in late april, even at 11,000 feet – mostly the low 20's. I was warm enough, but just. I didn't have any margin for error, and I didn't like it. I've gone back to my 5 degree bag for those trips. If I had a 15 degree bag that would be fine, but I don't have one so I use what I've got. Get the Lynx, you'll be glad you did.

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 10, 2010 at 12:21 am

In general, you don't dig under anything.

The best place is often on the side of a hill. Not a steep hill that might avalanche, but a short hill. Not at the top or the bottom, but mid-way on the hill. You tunnel in horizontally, and as you shovel the snow out, you just toss it behind you, which sends it down the hill and away from your tunnel. If you have plenty of snow depth to work with, you can shovel directly into the snow for 6-8 feet. If you do not have plenty of snow, like if you dig in a few feet and hit a boulder, then you have to turn 90 degrees and tunnel sideways. Once the tunnel is almost the size you need, you try to dig a foot channel that is lower than the sleeping bench. The foot channel might be 1-2 feet lower than where you expect to place your pad and sleeping bag. If you choose to burn a stove, then use it at the tunnel entrance where it is fully ventilated. You don't want to have stove exhaust deep within a cave and still expect to breathe. When night comes, you can semi-close the tunnel entrance with your pack, but you never close it completely. Also, you always take your shovel inside at night. You might need it to dig out in the morning. If it snows during the night, you need the shovel to increase the size of the air hole at the entrance.

When you get the whole thing dug out, you want to leave the ceiling and sidewalls as smooth as possible. If there are any little projecting points of snow, then they might melt from body heat, and you will have little droplets of meltwater falling onto your sleeping bag. The heat output of one human body is roughly equivalent to a 75-watt light bulb, so if you can simply harness that heat so that it does good things, you can stay comfortable. Any snow that melts on the ceiling will slowly migrate over to the sidewalls and downward. Then it might re-freeze on the walls.

Once inside and comfortable, you find that a very small flashlight is all you need. Any light inside the cave will bounce around the shiny white stuff.

Incidentally, choosing a shovel can be hard. There are big metal grain scoops, but they are unweildy inside a confined area. They are OK if you are working purely on the surface (like digging out your car from a snow drift). Snow claws aren't much good for this, either (too small). A Life-Link shovel is better, since the handle can be shortened or lengthened. I used to have a curved (spoon-shaped) aluminum shovel with a wooden handle, and it was the best, but I haven't seen anything like it in stores for many years. In an emergency, you can use poor tools like a X-C ski or an ice axe, but they aren't good. If you have no tools at all, then it is best to dig out a "tree hollow." That is found at the base of a tree where the wind has been blowing.

I hope this is not indelicate, but if you need to take a leak during the middle of the night, you don't really need to go outside the cave. It just disappears into the snow.

–B.G.–

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...