Topic

Contrail vs. Moment.. for my 6′ 5″ Ass

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedMar 3, 2010 at 11:09 am

So I'm looking at both of these pretty hard and like them both (in some cases for different reasons) but I think the deciding factor is going to be: "Which is a better fit for my 6 foot 5 inch tall frame".

In looking at the cutaway dimensions it looks like the Contrail will be a bit roomier given the consistent width down the length of the tent. I also like that the interior space ends with the vestibule rather than having a vestibule on the side.

A wildcard here might also be the Scarp which looks a bit roomier than the Moment but is really more robust of a shelter than I really need.

I tried mocking up some outlines on my floor but it's just not the same as actually being able to give them a try. I'm hoping some of you with similar height challenges can way in on how these tents feel to those us who are around 6 foot 5 .

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 11:45 am

I'm 6'6 when my fat belly isn't pulling me down to 6'5" and I have a Contrail. All-in-all, it's a great tent and fits fine. The wild card is if I'm on an uneven surface. My only complaint with the Contrail is the footbox is a little short. With feet upright and with or without a pad, my size 14's will brush the top of the tent when under my quilt which will transfer moisture if the fabric is wet.

Since you haven't thrown any money down yet, why not wait for the Six Moon Designs Vamp or Haven which are guaranteed to give you some extra breathing room? If you don't want one, you can buy one for me instead. Either is fine.

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 1:56 pm

Thanks for that, I remember hearing about the Vamp a while back but had forgotten about it.

Looking at the cutaway specs though it makes me wonder how much usable space will be available at the head of the tent given how it all comes to a point:

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 2:12 pm

Based on the length and profile, I'd say the head end looks good for storing gear and such while still allowing plenty of fore/aft room for head and feet.

Thomas Baker BPL Member
PostedMar 3, 2010 at 2:12 pm

While I am not quite as tall as you (6'4")I think I can identify with your dilemma. Initially I tried the more traditional shaped TT's like the Squall. They were fine for me except for one factor. With the highest point of the TT being at one end I found it very hard to sit and move at all without hitting my head on the roof. The amount of area where I could sit and do anything at all was very limited due to the highest point being at one end. I fixed this by getting a Rainbow. Now I can go from laying down to sitting and not have to slide forward as I do it and not hit my head on the roof. I find it much more comfortable and user friendly.

The purpose of telling you this is not to get you to switch to a Rainbow. But to point out that having the highest point more toward the center works better for average height guys like you and me. (It's not our fault everyone got lazy and stopped growing early :))Of the two you mentioned the Moment is closet to this design. I have heard plenty of good things about both but having the highest point toward the center is the factor that makes me think the Moment would be the better choice.

My $0.02, hopefully it helps.

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 2:58 pm

>>The purpose of telling you this is not to get you to switch >>to a Rainbow. But to point out that having the highest point >>more toward the center works better for average height guys >>like you and me. (It's not our fault everyone got lazy and >>stopped growing early :)

I'm 6'4" and not even close to being the tallest guy I know and it seems like threads like this pop up at least once a week. It seems to me that there is a pretty good market out there for tall hikers. I'm glad Six Moon Designs is doing something.

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 5:02 pm

I'm not a huge supporter of the manufacturer below, but in the interests of being fair about tall person tents:

http://www.lightheartgear.com/

About the Vamp and the Haven, the length should be fine in either. I wondered the same thing. Keep in mind it is considerably longer than other options, so even coming to a point won't matter too much. I also think the headroom when sitting up would be nice. Because both the Vamp and Haven use two trekking poles side-by-side, you'll have a little more seated breathing space. The Contrail merely uses one or two poles coming to the same apex in the front.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...