What is the difference or advantage of the hoser series vs Big Zip? Any advantages compared to camelbak?
Topic
Platy bottles
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
In situations that require carrying extra water, I like the platys because once they're empty they roll-up and disappear in your pack.
The main difference between the hoser and the big zip is the way each one fills up. With the hoser, you have to pour your water into the platy through the narrow (think 2 liter soda bottle size) mouth opening. This makes it kind of a pain to fill and dry. With the big zip, you have a much wider opening to fill, clean, and dry your bottle out. I haven't look much into the weight difference between the 2, but im sure theres a weight penalty to the big zip. Also big zip is better suited if you plan on converting your platy's into a gravity filter setup. The difference between the camelbak and the platy is durability. I use to use camelbaks but have since converted to Platys. Camelbaks are more in line with being used by the military, or those who really abuse their gear. I once saw a camelbak bladder survive a stress test of being run over by a ford f-150 . Excellent durability, but overbuilt for my own personal usage. So for me, platys are more advantageous than camelbaks due to their weight and simplicity.
I'm the proud owner of both a 2L Hoser and a 2L Big Zip (along with every possible size Camelbak bladder). There is a weight difference between the two. On my scale:
– 2L Hoser = 98 grams (3.46 ounces)
– 2L Big Zip = 157 grams (5.54 ounces)
That weight includes the bag, tube, and Camelbak bite valve (which I prefer).
The Hoser definitely is more challenging to fill (especially by yourself) but it's never been a problem.
I switched from a Camelbak to the 2L Hoser. I was considering the big zip, but it all came down to weight. Hoser wins.
Become a member to post in the forums.

