Topic

Standalone Bivy for Alpine Walking

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedMar 1, 2010 at 10:47 pm

I’ve just whittled my entire gear closet down to five boxes… three tents, four backpacks, two sleeping bags, three walking shoes, and one box of clothes. You can imagine the anguish I went through getting rid of the other stuff! It’s hard to let go! (I will be putting up items for sale soon)

RIght now I just need a few things to complete the set… a knee length cagoule (I might use Roger’s article to make my own, since I can’t find one commercially anywhere… the only one I found, by Northwerks Cagoules no longer has an operating website), a GPS unit (will ask about that, too), and a waterproof bivy for when I want to go light and fast without an overhead shelter and when I need to be able to camp in very limited space. I’m thinking of doing night hikes in the mountains and don’t want to deal with setting up a shelter in the dark when I’m tired. Just throw the bivy down and sleep. These trips with the bivy would be no longer than 3 days.

So far I’ve narrowed the selection down to the ID South Col Bivy, the MLD Alpine Bivy, and possibly either the Big Agnes Three Wire Bivy or the Nemo GoGo LE. I’d like 3D eVent if I use eVent because of its greater durability. I’m considering the Three Wire and the GoGo because of the very heavy rains here in Japan, but I realize that these set ups are probably heavier than a light bivy with tarp combination.

I’ve only used pertex bivies in combination with tarps (I have a BMW Vapr Bivy), so know very little about using standalone waterproof bivies. Would anyone be able to recommend something recent that would suit my purpose? I’ve been steered toward the South Col eVent Biivy… is that the best thing right now? Or is MLD a better choice?

One thing that I’ve not liked about my BMW Vapr Bivy is that I move around a lot when I sleep and the silnylon floor always manages to shift around high enough that the condensation soaks me and my sleeping bag. So I might prefer a 100% eVent bivy instead.

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 4:37 am

I really like the combination of the eVent Unishelter with a Silwing tarp. There are endless combinations you could choose from, but I've really liked a tarp over my bivy. It makes getting in and out less of a chore in the rain.
Don

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 5:19 am

No, Northwerks is gone?! I always wanted one of their Cagoules, and they had such a good name!

As for the bivy, I've never tried it, but I think some use an umbrella with a basic WPB bivy. You'd have to find a way to anchor the umbrella, but it would make for very good style!

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 7:16 am

I've used various 'standalone' bivvys over the years, but the one i use now is the ID All eVent bivvy. I've never really had any condensation using it. I'm convinced the non-breathable floors of most bivvys are responsible for most of the condensation found in bivvys.
I never used a tarp before, but entering and exiting in rain was always a problem. Sometimes i got wet. Now i use a 5' x 8' ID tarp set up over the head/torso, depending on the terrain. It makes things much more comfortable for a an extra 200g or so. I don't bother setting it up if there is no chance of rain.

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 7:58 am

Miguel, I am with Mike on this. The all eVENT ID Overbag is fantastic. It is easy to get into despite no zippers. This has to do with it's size – it can fit a fully lofted winter bag and thick mattress – and the size of the head opening. Quality is superb and durability solid.

"I'm convinced the non-breathable floors of most bivvys are responsible for most of the condensation found in bivvys."

This has been my experience as well.

I have used both the Unishelter and the 3 Wire Bivy (do a search on these forums and you will see some pics I posted of them side by side) and while great products, there is a greater level of claustrophobia in these shelters. However, they do completely seal out the elements. On the down side, they are heavier, more complex, require you to carry separate poles, back larger, and don't breath as well (given the PU floors).

With respect to the eVENT South Col, there is no advantage to this bivy over the Micro Bivy in eVENT or the eVENT Overbag. It simply costs more and weighs more.

PostedMar 3, 2010 at 10:22 am

Thanks everyone for some great advice. I think I've narrowed it down to the ID Overbag, the Penquin, and the Nemo GoGo Le. One problem I have is claustrophobia so it is difficult for me to sleep with something that covers my head, especially my nose. I begin to feel like I'm suffocating. So I'm not sure the Overbag would work for me. I agree that an all-eVent bag would be best, considering my experience with waterproof, non-breathing floors. I've read some good reviews of the Penquin and I like the center zip and the stiffened opening at the face. I'm just not sure about the Sympatex Reflexion material, though. I really like how Nemo thinks things through very thoroughly. I like the area over the head and the small vestibule. Just seems a bit heavy and I don't know how well the Osmo fabric works. I think, if I start using a standalone bivy, that I would probably bring my ID 5×8 tarp, or something smaller, or, even, if I ever get the design worked out, my idea for a special hiking umbrella.

Let me digest all this and see what I come up with.

Thanks, guys!

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...