Topic

Choosing a Lighter Tent

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 9 posts - 26 through 34 (of 34 total)
PostedMar 5, 2010 at 2:27 am

Sergiy
A lot of three season tents are indeed very ordinary * but the Scarp is not one of them…
These single hoop tent design works very well with side winds (door/broad side) because that is where the wind splitting pole is (providing that you have used the optional guylines there) however the non diamond shaped versions can suffer a bit with the end in the wind because the they tend to have little support there. The inverted V struts (PitchLoc) used by TT on the Scarps is a lot stronger than most. Note that it also has a center strut. Essentially tent flies that have little or no flat areas do better in the wind.
Another advantage is the differential panel cut. Each half has three panels not one that is stretched to fit. That allows the tent to remain taut and shed wind better that way. The "UK" (2010 version) has those panels with a slight catenary cut making them even more streamlined than the one I have.
Scarp 1 2010

Now do not do this but there is no trick involved…(and don't try it with another tent either)
I did that just to see if it could be done.
Scarp PitchLock
This is in theory and based on my limited understanding of tent design. I still use the Contrail so no real world test with the Scarp for me.
Also just my opinion, if guyed out correctly (IE when it looks like the above shot, not the one with that lunatic..) I don't think that the extra poles will make any difference. For snow loading , yes.

Franco
* sorry about that…

PostedMar 22, 2010 at 2:00 pm

About a week ago I had sent an e-mail to the address given at tarptent.com. Next day or later, having no reply, I thought may be my mail was rejected by some kind of a spam filter, so I dublicated it through a PM, also unsuccessfully.
Is there any other way to contact him, except for phone (my English is not good enough for speaking)?
Or, may be he is somewhere on a trail now, I should wait more? :)

Meanwhile, may be someone can explain me, how TT Scarp is freestanding with the additional crosspoles? I mean, usually freestanding tents are supported by poles. But from some photos it seems like the tips of Scarp's crosspoles do not touch the ground.

PostedMar 22, 2010 at 2:29 pm

Sergiy
At the bottom of the TT front page there is a CONTACT link.
Henry was at the Seattle factory recently so it is possible that he has not caught up with the mail. (there is only one Henry Shires there…)
http://www.tarptent.com/
You can see that the Scarp 1 with crossing poles is indeed freestanding (including vestibules…) from this pic.

Scarp 1 free

The poles keep the PitchLoc corners in tension.
Franco
franco@tarptent.com

PostedMar 22, 2010 at 2:42 pm

"Henry was at the Seattle factory recently so it is possible that he has not caught up with the mail."
OK, no problem, I just wasn't sure what's going on.

"The poles keep the PitchLoc corners in tension."
ok, I see now.. the tent actually stands on the inverted-V things, and the poles just keep them in place through tension.

Thank you, Franco.

PostedMar 22, 2010 at 3:42 pm

Hi Sergiy,

I just emailed Henry (about an hour ago) and he got back to me within minutes. So he is definitely around and receiving email.

Derek

PostedMar 22, 2010 at 4:24 pm

mb crescent 2

i use the mont bell crescent 2 for me and my 5 yr old son
it has its trade offs but is a great lightweight 2 person tent at 3 lbs even its a joy to carry
its not freestanding and the vestibule is small however interior room is great and this tent has alot of venting options so it works well in alot of different conditions
i can fit both of our packs and our bags /pads in it without a problem i think these are in your price range
too so you might check them out
kevin

PostedMar 22, 2010 at 8:16 pm

I have a 2010 Scarp1, and though I'm hardly a tent expert, it is IMO a wonderfully designed tent. Even for a newbie, it's easy to set up and it's roomier than it seems like it ought to be.

PostedMar 23, 2010 at 1:05 am

+1 on the ShangriLa 3 plus inner net.
Shelter weight 680g for one person.
Inner weight 790g for the other person.
If you use hiking poles, all you have to do is split the stakes- 50g each.
If you buy from the UK, it could fit your budget.
Plenty of room, great for snow, and fits three.
Good luck.
cheers,
fred

PostedMar 23, 2010 at 2:06 am

Derek,
Thanks, I have just received a reply too.

And thanks everybody for other suggestions.

Viewing 9 posts - 26 through 34 (of 34 total)
Loading...