Hi Craig,
I mostly followed Ed Speer’s instructions for making the basic tarp. The main differences are that I used nylon webbing instead of grosgrain ribbon for all tieouts, and used one middle tieout instead of two. I also added many tieouts, mostly patterned after tarp pitches shown on Oware’s pages and Ray Jardine’s tarp. Adding Ray’s pullouts makes for a great A-frame setup, and a tieout in the dead center of the tarp can be used for a more taught and lower diamond setup with a ridgeline or guyline.
Zaleski is easier than Shawnee, from what I’ve heard (haven’t been to Shawnee yet). Trails are well-maintained and marked with water spigots near campsites. (Call to find out if water is available though.) The only trailhead parking lot will be _underwater_ if there’s more than a few hours of heavy rain. There are other parking options for the determined, but they involve walking or risk to the vehicle from theft/vandalism. Campsites are usually fairly packed if it’s nice backpacking weather on a weekend.
Backpack Ohio has a useful forum and eTrails guides/maps.