I just read a bunch of threads and, for a while, there seemed to be a concern about wind stability in the Contrail. It appears that, when the third strut is placed by the feet, the Contrail is essentially a cat-cut tarp in an A-frame set up. Yet I don't read concerns about wind stability for just plain tarps set up in an A-frame configuration. In fact, users tout that a tarp can withstand significantly adverse weather. Why is there a difference in performance?
Topic
TT Contrail
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
The third strut is an optional addition to the shelter. Yes it does work as you describe it , provably with a much lesser wind tunnel effect than most tarps.
Franco
dennis, i have often wondered the same thing.
Could be it depends on how you setup the Contrail. From experience there is a notable difference in tautness (and stability) if you guy out the pole at the head of the tent vs leaving the pole freestanding. And if you also stake down the two side loops midway from front to back vs leaving them free. If you use the extra 3 stakes to do the above it is a pretty tight configuration even without the addition of the center pole at the foot. Add that nice trick to the mix and the tent is pretty bomber.
I had a Contrail for 3 years. The tent is quite "stable" in wind in terms of no excessive flapping but it WILL flap some. To tie it down properly for real wind you need to:
1. use TWO hiking poles in an A shape for the front
2. stake out the front guyline & close the vestibule
3. stake out the side stake loops
4. and for wind AND snow use a 3 ft. stick, cord and stake to make the foot end of the roof into a peak.
5. retighten after 1 hour or after it gets wet.
Or do as I did, sell the Contrail and buy a TT Moment. 2 stakes (4 at most) and you're ready for quite high winds. That's it.
Eric
Eric,
While we're talking about this, could you give us your detailed observations (advantages, disadvantages, other) of moving to a Moment from the Contrail. (I have a Contrail and Sublite Tyvek, but no Moment yet.)
Eric,
Does the Moment have less flapping?
This comparison has been done on this and other forums but I'll doit here again.
TT CONTRAIL >
PROS
1. larger floor space
2. lighter by a few oz.
3. no poles to pack
CONS
1. fast to pitch but not as fast as the Moment
2. flaps some in high winds no matter how tight you pitch it or how many stakes you use
3. smaller, less protective vestibule than the Moment
TT MOMENT >
PROS
1. VERY fast pitch W/no fussing afterwards i.e. stays taut
2. nice vestibule for your pack AND cooking at the same time
3. TOTALLY wind stable (I know this from an all night gale at 11, 300 ft.)
4. better ventilation options than the Contrail
5. LOOKS COOL!
6. more useable headroom
7. I think chicks will dig it. ;)
8. zippered vestibule door, not Velcro, like the Contrail
CONS
1. heavier than Contrail
2. see # 1
Thanks Eric. Sometimes it's important to hear it from someone who has direct experience with both.
You couldn't have made it clearer to us. I've bought many items to find out for myself how they differ, when I don't really need so much as I have. Sound familiar, anyone?
Just to add along with Eric's post above:
I just got my Tarptent Moment in the mail less than a week ago. Within a few minutes of it arriving, I had it out of the box and setting it up in a snowstorm.
Even without reading the instructions, I was able to get it up and taught within 2 minutes on the first try. It seems very stable in the wind and did ok under moderate snowfall (but not for use with TONS of snowfall!).
Hope this helps!
Become a member to post in the forums.

