Topic

Help me decide: GGear Virga vs SMD Swift ’10

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 9:06 am

I'm trying to decide between these two packs b/c the GGear is half the price. But I have little experience with either company. Help me out if you can

thanks
Vadim

PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 9:43 am

Just for the simple fact that the SMD Swift does not have load lifter straps I would go with the Granite Gear Virga.

Joseph

Eugene Smith BPL Member
PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 9:56 am

Vadim, interesting question. I'm seriously considering the Swift as well in the future. The thing I don't like about my Virga already is the lack of a 'real' hipbelt. The collar on the Virga is enormous and anything that actually filled up the volume of the Virga would easily exceed the weight limits of the pack. The nice thing about the Virga is the cushioned shoulder straps which are downright comfy under 20lb. load. Without having any experience with the SMD Swift I would imagine the Swift would be a better all around pack. My 2 cents is spend the additional $20 and buy the SMD Swift pack if it is coming down to deciding between the Virga or the Swift.

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 3:37 pm

Vadim, I used a GG Virga and really liked it. I swapped out for a lighter pack with less volume. Eugene is right about the collar being long. I suspect it is so you can still roll it even when the collar is full. In no way could someone fill the entire thing. I did cut the collar down and sewed the draw cord back in…but it was fine as it was. The shoulder straps are probably the best I've used…they are padded nicely. Yes the waist strap is marginal at transferring loads, but I don't use belts anyway so this was not an issue. When scrambling over rocks it does a nice job of holding the pack onto you. The only other thing was the lower compression straps run across the pockets which makes them rather useless. I hear the new versions have this solved (straps run inside the pockets). One other thing is this pack only has 2 side pockets, it does not have a 3rd back pocket. But the center straps are great for tie/holding gear.

All in all I really recommend the Virga. I think it is the best lightweight pack that is widely available (i.e. REI, backcountrygear.com, etc). It replaced the Golite Jam on my recommended list after the Jam gained so much weight.

Jamie

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 4:24 pm

To me, the thing that distinguishes one frameless pack from another is that pair of shoulder straps! Unless you know that certain ones don't work for yu — it's pretty hard to tell just from looking (or even asking).

You've got the Swift already. Why not order the GG Virga as well so you can try both out "live and loaded"? The return postage for either should be pretty minimal — and IMO well worth it.

PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 5:25 pm

I didnt know that the GG virga was selling for so cheap on ebay on friday so i ended up placing an order of a swift. it's going to ship out first thing monday. i sent them an email to see if they would cover me for the return shipping but they have not responded yet b/c of the weekend.

PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 5:29 pm

people seem to say that one should never go above 20lbs in the GG virga but w/ the new swift they're saying it can carry up to 30 w/ ease if one had to

PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 6:52 pm

"people seem to say that one should never go above 20lbs in the GG virga"

That's not what the test of the pack by BPL indicated.

D S BPL Member
PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 6:56 pm

I have used the Virga my past four thru hikes and love it. The shoulder straps make the pack; they are pound for pound the very best to be found. The volume is perfect if you travel "light" not necessarily "UL" the extention comes in handy on resupplies but is admittedly a bit excessive. It carries like a champ up to about 25 lbs, like a cotton ball around 15 lbs or less.

I keep spending money (as others will attest to) trying to find a lighter pack made as well that carries as well and keep going back to the Virga. I know this pack very well indeed and know you would love it…if your torso/size is a good match.

tried MLD, GossamerGear, GoLite, SMD, and heavier packs but love the Virga. Next on my list is a Zpack…

good luck,

Dave

by the way, the SMD stuff is well-made too as is all the others I've tried…it just boils down to the fact that a size regular Virga fits me as if it were a custom made pack.

PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 7:46 pm

David

thank you thats very interesting.

what is your torso size by the way? im in right in the middle of the M/L category so i always need a large. For example, I need a large in golite and SMD.

how is the waistbelt on the pack?

D S BPL Member
PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 8:14 pm

SMD—a large

GoLite a large in the Gust and Breeze and medium in all others

D

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...