I searched through many of the past threads on this issue of down vs synthetic, but I am curious as to what most folks in the eastern us use? I live in western pa and spend most of my trips in WV and the ANF. Do you guys use down or synthetic sleeping bags? I currently own a 4 lb synthetic slumberjack bag that I would like to replace probably next fall, not sure what fill to get though.
Topic
Eastern US- synthetic sleeping bags?
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
I'm in the east and end up hiking a lot in the rain and I have gone to down for all of my bags, quilts, and insulating jackets. Things don't dry well in the humid east so you have to make sure and keep them dry. I use both a pack cover (2.6oz) and a Sea to Summit dry bag style pack liner (3.4oz) to keep my pack contents dry. I did a trip this past summer where it rained 7 inches in the 48 hours I was out in north Georgia and everything inside the pack stayed dry.
I think I've done more hiking in the rain than out of it and I use down. I put my bag in a dry sack and use a trash bag as a pack liner.
The only issue I have had with a down bag in the humid East has been some noticeable deflation of a Marmot Helium EQ after a week on the Long Trail… I believe that the shell fabric was simply not breathable enough to let moisture escape as my regular Pertex Quantum Helium has never had that problem.
For 3 season backpacking I always make sure to let the bag air out as much as possible in camp and to change into dry socks and shirt before getting in my bag. Again, no noticeable loft issues after 4 or 5 days in a Pertex Quantum shelled down bag.
For winter, I often sleep in damp clothing (always change my socks, but once I put on my Powerstretch baselayers and Schoeller Dryskin softshells, they stay on) and have not had any issues on my short 3-4 day trips using a WM Antelope (microfiber) in the Catskills and Adirondacks.
So, IMO, a down bag with a breathable shell is not an issue so long as you take some basic preventive measures to block moisture from entering (internal and external) and let the bag air dry whenever possible.
I am a recent convert to down gear and I have to say I am glad I made the change. The weight savings alone make up for any drawbacks it might have.
My feet sweat alot, even when they are cold. So I have been wearing bread bags under my sleeping socks. I also tend to breathe through my mouth when I sleep. I have a Golite Ultra 20 and it has waterproof fabric at the top so I don't have any problems there. I just have to make sure my shelter has alot of ventalion and I don't touch the sides of the shelter either.
The last night of my last weekend trip I got the quilt a little damp from touching against the inside of my tarp. As soon as the sun rose I placed the bag in the light on some mountain laurel and the loft was restored in a matter of no time.
Joseph
i too use down in PA (hershey area) and haven't really had any problems keeping it dry. i try my best to lay it out over my hammock ridgeline in the morning as long as it's not raining to let it dry out.
Yep, I use down too. I use a WM Caribou most of the time, and a WM Versalite in the winter. As others have said just make sure to keep it as dry as possible, and dry it out when the opportunity arises if it gets a little damp. I keep my stuff dry by lining my pack with a trash compactor bag, and using a pack cover on the outside of the pack. I also use a sil-nylon poncho in warmer weather for my rain gear, which is redundant (and likely unnecessary) to the pack cover.
Protection from external water is not difficult. Sea-to-Summit makes very light sil-nylon dry bags with roll-top closures. I use these as my standard sleeping bag stuff suck even in dry conditions and consider it one of my more indispensable pieces of gear. Additionally, many hikers will use either a pack cover or pack liner to keep rain out of their packs.
It helps to have some sun to deal with internal moisture accumulation. Even if you have a synthetic bag it's good to open it up and expose the lining to the sun about every four days. Another way to keep moisture accumulation to a minimum is to stuff your bag as soon as you get out of it. This forces the moist air out before it has a chance to cool and condense.
I primarily camp in the S. MD & N. VA areas.
In the spring (April-May), my Marmot 650 fill 15* down bag starts to feel damp as the moisture condenses out of the air at night – but it's still warmer than my Sierra Designs 20* XP bag. The XP doesn't feel damp, but it's noticeably colder (about as much as wearing a silk-weight base layer). In the spring, I'm mostly doing 3 day hikes. If I was going for 10 days I might have second thought about taking my down bag. I find using a tent rather than a tarp in the spring raises the dew point in the air enough that the moisture condenses on the inside of the fly rather than on the outside of my sleeping bag. Down bag works perfectly then, but a synthetic bag + tarp is lighter than a down bag + tent.
I've given up on trying to dry things on the trail in the spring. I've hung my poly t-shirts up for 3-4 hours on cloths lines – and they just stay damp… I've also noticed at night that I need to seal any spare cloths in a plastic bag or they absorb moisture and feel damp in the morning (yes everything is synthetic).
I've also noticed that if I let my bag loft for 30-45 minutes before going to bed, it will absorb enough moisture to feel a little damp ("clammy"). Leaving the bag stuffed until it's time to use it works better (both down & synthetic). A 650 fill down bag lofts in 1-3 minutes anyway – just shake it a little to fluff it up. I don't know if 800 fill down lofts faster or slower than 650 fill down.
All my bags are down and I haven't had any problem but the echo those above about keeping it dry inside my pack.
I lived in Erie, PA for 35 years and backpacked in the Allegheny Nat'l. Forest a lot. My last 3 season synthetic bag was a Caribou Mountaineering PrimaLoft bag which lost virtually ALL its loft in 3 summers. No more PrimaLoft for me – ever!
I'd recommend a NF Cat's Meow of any good 3 season bag with Climashield insulation.
BTW, Try the "MOST EXCELLENT" 85 mile Susquehannock Trail system loop for THE best PA backpacking ever. You can GOOGLE them & buy their excellent guide book and even better series of topo maps W/water, camp sites and side trails all marked.
And there's a tiny town & Post Office at about the 5:30 location on the trail to send you food to, care of "general delivery" so you don't have to haul all of it in the first 1/2 of the trail. You park your car at the 12 'o clock location/trailhead at the PA Forestry office parking lot. This trail is simply beautiful, esp. compared to the ANF. Try it in the 1st week of October for the beautiul fall colors.
I am from Pa and I always used synthetic. Just for the damp/wet weather. However, when I was on the AT I saw alot of Heliums. The ADK is also known for the wet weather. I probably was jus being too cautious. (or maybe cheap)
Become a member to post in the forums.

