"I chuckle when I think that there are "internet UL experts" buying this that can easily lose about 64oz off their gut :)"
It's funny how often that kind of comment comes up.
Topic
Become a member to post in the forums.
"I chuckle when I think that there are "internet UL experts" buying this that can easily lose about 64oz off their gut :)"
It's funny how often that kind of comment comes up.
"It's funny how often that kind of comment comes up."
Indeed! BUT, it's a valid comment.
Physician, heal thyself.
-or, more precisely for our purposes-
Ultralight Backpacker, lighten thyself.
A couple responses.
1. I posted the weight of the tarp alone (rather than the whole package) because I want to hightlight just how lightweight it is. If I posted the weight of the whole package it would, at a glance, seem too heavy.
2. Although we have contracted Oware to sew tarps and other items for us in the past, this new line of Stealth NANOs were not produced by Oware.
"I loosely drew out the tarp in Google Sketchup and came up with 63.5 sq ft of coverage."
Chris,
I did the same thing an got about 64 sq ft for the bpl nano ul and 72 sq ft for the spinntwinn. Any idea what that number would be for the grace duo? MLD doesn't disclose front and rear overhang measurements like GG does.
I'd have to draw it up. It's 8.8 at the head by 7.5 at the rear. Main ridge line is 9 and the sides are 8.5. I believe that would make the overhangs 3" at the head and foot (assuming I understand what overhang is referring to).
Ok, I drew it up and come up with ~73 sq ft.
Chris, have I been under a rock or what- I just noticed that you are now "Staff". Congratulations, we're all proud of you!
Well, someone needs to clean up after Sam.
Nice David. Chuckling over here.
I don't think an official announcement has been made, so unofficially, I'm managing the Wilderness Trekking School this year.
You know – I noticed that a few days ago but figured I had simply missed an announcement somewhere. In any event, congrats.
He will be cleaning up after me – – once he's living at my house while he's out here this summer ; )
I'm trying to understand the dimensions myself and can't make sense of it. I'm comparing the GG SpinnTwinn with the BMW Stealth NANO.
1. According to published specs by BPL and GG, the Stealth NANO is either 36% larger square feet or 49% larger square meters. That alone means that either GG or BMW has an error with their sq ft vs sq meters math.
2. Whether it's 36% larger or 49% larger, I can't see how that reckons with the dimensions of the 2 tarps. Again, according to published specs, the Stealth NANO is 8% shorter than the SpinnTwinn, 7% narrower at the head end, and 18% narrower at the foot end. Given that it's shorter in all dimensions, how can it be larger than the SpinnTwinn?
I'm trying to understand just how big and weatherproof the Stealth NANO tarp is. Is it large enough to keep out rain and snow with 2 people in it without bivy sacks? That's what I'm used to –for reference, I've found Ray Jardine's tarp design wonderful for 2 people.
–http://www.rayjardine.com/ray-way/Tarp-Kit/index.htm
I have the version of it sold by GoLite as the "Cave 2"….
–http://www.frontcountry.com/site/pl_golite_cave_2.html
Unfortunately it weighs 20 oz.
On the upside, the front and rear beaks are great for keeping out windblown rain, and the lifters in the middle of the two sides are great for increasing headroom as well as stability in wind. The beaks and side lifters make this tarp harder to pitch than a Henry Shires TarpTent or even a Stealth NANO / SpinnTwinn, but with 2 people it's not bad.
So, can anybody tell me how the Stealth NANO size compares to the SpinnTwinn and Ray-Way tarps?
Thanks,
David Longwalker
P.S. — Here's the spreadsheet I made to compare dimensions…

David,
I think you are comparing apples and oranges. GG lists 47 sq ft of protected area when pitched for the spinntwinn.
BPL is listing 64 sq ft of fabric in the nano ul
David, I'm not sure where GG is getting their 47 sq ft number. The surface area of their tarp is more like 80 sq ft (rough estimate). I can draw it up to get a closer number if you need it. I don't know the dimensions on the RayWay tarp off hand but I suspect it's a lot larger than necessary to cover 2 people.
Scott, thanks for pointing out the fabric sq ft vs protected sq ft. I missed that difference.
So, that begs the question: What is the protected area of a Stealth NANO?
Also, Chris: I just checked the specs on the Ray-Way tarp site —
http://www.rayjardine.com/ray-way/Tarp-Kit/index.htm
–and they claim their tarp provides a protected area of 106" long by 92" wide when pitched at a 30 degree slope. If I did the math right, that works out to:
269 cm long
233 cm wide
6.27 sq m protected area
I have used the Ray-Way tarp for years with 2 people under it and I've never felt its protected area is excessive. It provides a margin between your sleeping bags and the sleet/snow/rain coming down outside. Without that margin, you'd need to carry bivy sacks, which my tarpmates and I have never done.
To illustrate, here are two pictures of my Cave 2 tarp in a rain and snowstorm in the Washington Cascades last Labor Day. I don't see a lot of extraneous space…


BUT: I'm very excited by the idea of a 5-oz tarp to replace my 20-oz tarp. I just wonder how big it is?
definitely not as roomy as that :)
Based on the dimensions and having a slightly larger Grace Duo, it will likely shelter a couple that sleeps close fine. That includes pitching it to the ground to prevent blowing rain. You'd need to take advantage of the surrounding environment to block the head/foot. If you're two male friends, you probably wouldn't like the accommodations.
What are the recommended pitch heights for the front and rear of the NANO Tarp ? LIKE: The GG SpinnTwinn recommends front 45" and rear 32".. I thought I had read something about it but not sure.
Just Curious
Bumped for question and possible answer….
I don't have the exact answer but I don't follow suggested heights. I set my front pole to the height I want and adjust the rear accordingly for a tight ridge line. Seems to work well thus far.
I think it would be extremely generous to call that tarp a 2 person tarp based on the size and picture provided.
It's plenty big for a couple. Two burly guys, not so much. It's actually wider than my Grace Duo at the head and plenty wide at the foot.
Sammiejoe at zpacks is real competitive on prices and weight went it comes to cuben shelters.
http://www.zpacks.com/shelter.shtml
It looks like the Nano has a lot of thought behind the manufacturing.
I have not camped in my GG SpinnTwinn, which has similar dimensions to the Grace Duo, with my wife yet but it is a palace for one (even when pitched low to the ground) so I would anticipate plenty of space for a couple. On Alan Dixon's website (http://www.adventurealan.com/4-7_index.htm), he indicates that he and his teenage son used the GG SpinnTwinn comfortably on a couple of his trips. Even if the NANO tarp is slightly has slightly smaller dimensions, I would imagine two people who are relatively close could camp comfortably (in the event of blowing rain you would probably want a bivy though IMHO).
My projected shelter weight will be(17.7 oz) with my MLD Serenity Bug Net and my new Stealth NANO Tarp.
10.2 oz– MLD Bug Net
5.5 oz– BPL Tarp (Added weight for guy lines)
2 oz—-Ti Lazr Stakes
17.7 oz total-SWEET!!!!!!!
This is going to a killer set up with plenty of storm coverage and most importantly(for me)sanctuary from the bugs!
I could go lighter with a bivy– but bivys make me fill claustrophobic. Everybody has different comfort levels. I can not weight for BPL to ship them out.
Come on BPL I have a hike in two weeks. Lets put these SUL bad boy tarps to work ASAP!!!!!
-Jay
Become a member to post in the forums.