Topic

Montrail Mountain Masochist

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 9:54 pm

I am looking for tips from anyone who has worn these shoes for 200+ miles. I am interested in using these shoes in the desert section of the PCT and maybe switching to Hardrocks or Continental Divides for the Sierras. The mesh seems like it would breathe very well. However, for every review I can find online I cant seems to find someone who definitively says these shoes can take a beating and wont wear out. Lots of people saying they wear them for 100 mile ultra-runs but that aint exactly backpacking 500 miles in them. Does anyone know if this shoe is a good desert shoe and durable?

PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 11:00 am

The fact that Montrail tossed out every shoe and boot but the Mountain Masochist for a new design probably means something. I am sure its a great shoe. I have read alot of good reviews. The Montrail Streak might be another shoe to look at.

I have been backpacking in areas the same time as trail runs going on. From what I have seen those guys and gals tear shoes up pretty good. Along with there ankles and shins. So from I would have seen if a shoe can handle a 100 mile trail run the same shoe would probably last me 2 or 300 miles for me while backpacking. But then again I am pretty easy on my footwear.

My Montrail Mountain Mists are about 5 years old and have at least a couple hundred miles on them. They have just now developed holes on each side of the shoes next to the midsole at the point where they flex. I still wear them around town.

My first pair of Montrail Namches were about a year and a half old and had a couple hundred miles on them before I exchanged them for a new pair from Backcountry.com. Some of the outer mesh started to come off but they probably could have gone another 100 miles. They just stunk so bad I couldn't stand them anymore. :)

I have a pair of Montrail 09' Hardrock Mids on there way right now. There was alot of bashing being done on the shoes but I will see for myself.

Alot of people complain about Montrails durability but I have always been happy with them. Now I had a pair of TNF mid heights that didn't last but 30 or 40 miles. On one of the shoes the upper completely seperated from the midsole at the front. Junk!

Joseph

Lucas Boyer BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 1:48 pm

Brandon, I've got a pair of Masochists w/ about 300 to 400 miles on them. Not many people have this shoe on here. There are some delaminations on the sole, but no damage. I had them for a 225 mile hike I did recently. I would say they will hold up well. Unfortunately, they have a very rectangular shape to the toe box and rub my pinkie toes wrong. I did not experience this until my feet swelled sufficiently and then it was downhill. They are also pretty minimalist in the footbed. If you are not used to spending a lot of time on your feet, running, etc. I think you will find them a bit uncomfortable. I picked up a pair of Cascadia 4's recently and have really liked them so far. The longest hike I've had them on is a 6 miler, so I need to log some big miles before I will make a judgement.

PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 3:46 pm

Joseph: Thanks for the info. I am pretty easy on my shoes as well. I have never owned a pair of Montrails and I feel like I may have missed the boat on all the good pre-Columbia shoes, or maybe people are just exaggerating the change and pontificating.I originally considered the 09 Hardrocks, but as you say they have gottena fair amount of bad online reviews.

Lucas: I have a pair of Cascadia 3 and 4. I LOVE them. I was thinking of moving to the MMs as a more minimal shoe in comparison. Part of me thinks 'dont mess with a good thing' and simply buy more Cascadias. I guess I will try a pair and if they fail I can return them and try the new Cascadia 5! Observation of my own: not many people on here run Cascadias either, dont know why though.

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 4:59 pm

My current shoe is the masochist. I've been using them for about the last 6 months. It think I have used them on four trips of 25-45 miles each. These shoes are so comfortable I use them around town. I have tried 3 pairs of salomons and one pair on innov8's (310's). I liked the salomons well enough but I wanted something lighter. Would you believe the innov8's rubbed my pinkie toe while the masochist do not. The masochist are real light and breath exceptionally well. I have had no durability issues at all. After several hundred miles these shoes look practically brand new.

Jamie

Jeremy Pendrey BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 8:57 pm

I've used the Masochists for more than 300 miles without any durability issues. I hiked the 165 mile Tahoe Rim Trail in them last summer. I have had some issues with the fit over long distances, which caused some blisters, but I have difficult feet to fit so that's not a problem with the shoe. I have blister issues with lots of shoes, and actually didn't have any blister issues with the Masochists until after 60-70 miles, which is better than I do with most shoes on a trip. Overall, they are definitely durable, and if they fit well, will be a good light stability shoe for you.

Lucas Boyer BPL Member
PostedFeb 19, 2010 at 8:45 am

Brandon, if you are using Cascadias with success. I'd say stick w/ the winning formula. However, I understand the curiosity. While, I'd say yes the Cascadia's are heavier. It's not a noticeable difference to me. I will also say the Cascadia's get it right because they are built from a running shoe last by a company that builds good running specific shoes. Montrail does not make a true running shoe and I feel that works to their detriment. Are they light? Yes. Are they durable? Yes. Would I buy again if fit was ideal? Yes. I hiked the Masochist in Colorado w/ lots of varied trail and the biggest day being about 20 miles. I had no issues w/ fit of the shoe. However, on my long hike with 30 mi. days stacked on top of each other and a very homogenous trail surface, my pinkie toes took a beating. I'd say some of it was just the lack of varied motion, rather than the fit of the shoe. Once burnt, twice shy though. Of note too. The "trail shield" in the Masochist doesn't appear to be as protective as the Cascadia's Ballistic Shield. As always, YMMV!

PostedFeb 19, 2010 at 10:23 pm

Just ordered the Masochists from Runningwarehouse.com. They have free return shipping if I hate them so I'll see how they feel around the house. If they feel nice and I keep 'em I'll let you all know my impressions after a few runs/hikes. Shoes really are one of our most important pieces of gear and hopefully I fall in love with these. Really hope I didnt waste $82!

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...