Topic

Light shoes with stiff shank?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 12:55 pm

I've had surgery on one foot to repair the big toe joint. It doesn't bend upward like it used to. I've found that I need a pretty good (3/4) shank in order to hike comfortably for any real distance. Unfortunately it seems like the only shoes I can find with a stiff shank are boots and they are really HEAVY!

I would love to find some light weight, breathable, trail runners with a more solid shank. I don't care about ankle support. Any ideas of brands or models I should check out?

PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 2:18 pm

I have to have a good shank to avoid repeating foot issues of mine. I have found some Merrel low cuts offer this in a hybrid of sorts – part trail runner, part low cut hiker. They are not the lightest but neither are they heavy like boots.

John S. BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 4:29 pm

Try on alot of shoes. Maybe an "approach" shoe will work better than pure trail runners. They would have more substantial soles?

Ross Bleakney BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 4:44 pm

I used to buy "HiTec" brand shoes. They are pretty cheap. They used to be very soft (which I prefer) but got a lot stiffer as time went by. I'm pretty sure the Big 5 stores still carry them. Just be careful about pinching spots.

PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 7:13 am

I thought that the midsole was very stiff on these shoes from new balance.

http://www.newbalance.com/performance/outdoor/products/MO1320/

I really liked the specs of the shoe, but I had to return them back to onlineshoes.com since they were way too narrow. I wear 14 4E normally (in new balance) but this shoes last is way different. If trying this shoe you will probably need to add a 1/2 size in length and go up a width to find a size that fits.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 8:17 am

You might try the La Sportiva Wildcat. It's one of the stiffest trail runners I've found, and super comfortable; it does have a natural flex at the forefoot, but the rest of it is really supportive.

PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 11:37 am

These things have pretty beefy soles. I got the Eclipse XCR Gore-tex version on sierratradingpost but I saw they make a non Gore-tex as well.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 3:53 pm

William, get well soon. Was that Morton's Toe you were suffering from? I have a similar issue (Morton's Toe + Morton's Neuroma) after bashing my feet in the military finally caught up with me years later (flattened and widened feet), made worse by not making sure my footwear had a wide enough forefoot and toe box. I also need torsionally rigid shoes and now I know why I've always felt uncomfortable with soft soles.

For those who have never had this, Morton's Toe, big toe joint that isn't flexible enough, causes you to place too much stress on the base of the toe and causes too hard a strike on the outside of the forefoot at the metatarsal heads under the small toes.

William you might want to also look into the type of material your orthotic is made from – plastic or carbon fiber or some combination of materials.

Brad, how's the La Sportiva Wildcat for wide forefoot/generous toe box? I'll add it to the list I've been putting together.

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 4:25 pm

"Brad, how's the La Sportiva Wildcat for wide forefoot/generous toe box?"

I'm not Brad, but I can answer that question. The forefoot & toe box are extremely roomy. My feet are shaped like duck's feet, and the Wildcat fits wonderfully. I tried a LOT of shoes and did a lot of research, and it took a long time to find a shoe with a generous toe box like this that didn't also have a heel that was too big & sloppy.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 4:35 pm

Christopher I think you commented on them in my other wide forefoot shoe thread. I remember your duck feet. Thanks for the very helpful info, going to try them out soon.

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 5:00 pm

No problem. For what it's worth, the La Sportiva Lynx and the soon-to-be-released La Sportiva Raptor are based on the same last & toe box design as the Wildcat.

Also, while I would consider the Wildcat moderately stiff, I don't consider it extremely so. The old Montrail Vitesse is stiffer, for example.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 5:37 pm

How do the La Sportiva Lynx and Raptor compare with the Wildcat in terms of weight, stiffness, etc.? What's the difference between them?

Looking for torsionally rigid but not solid-steel stiff, so should be fine.

I am wondering how the new Montrail AT Plus will be – the company told me it will be stiffer than the new Sabino Trail.

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 6:00 pm

The Raptor hasn't come out yet, so I'm not sure. The Lynx has more synthetic leather around the sides, and this same material is used to connect the lace eyelets to the sole of the shoe. On the wildcat webbing is used to do this (imagine what the Inov-8 shoes look like with the webbing on the outside, but with that same webbing underneath a layer of mesh on the Wildcat). So I'd say the Lynx is slightly less breathable, and feels a bit heavier. It might be more abrasion resistant than the Wildcat, but I haven't yet been able to use them enough to say. I haven't had any durability problems with the Wildcat, so it might not matter anyway. I think the Lynx is close to the same stiffness as the Wildcat, and if anything just a tiny bit stiffer. I got my pair of Lynx on steepandcheap for $40, so you might be able to find some good deals.

PostedFeb 19, 2010 at 6:57 am

"William, get well soon. Was that Morton's Toe you were suffering from?"

No, I had something called Hallux Rigidus, which is basically a rigid big toe joint caused by cartilage degeneration and bone spurs. I had surgery on it about a year ago and 3 months later was hiking in Montana. Before that I hadn't hiked in 4 years.

Thanks to everyone for the advice. This forum rocks! I'm going shoe shopping this weekend.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedFeb 28, 2010 at 1:26 pm

I think that the rigid big toe joint causes Morton's Toe. I'm still straightening out all this info. Your full recovery is encouraging as I deal with my foot injury. Best wishes for continued recovery and many trails ahead.

Found out through MRI that I have what's called 2nd Metatarsal Phalangeal Joint Stress Syndrome – a torn/stretched ligament around the 2nd toe joint which may have caused the Morton's neuroma by leaking fluid from the joint and rubbing the bones against the nerve. Trying to get the inflammation down with ice and anti-inflammatory (Advil) and PT (ultrasound and other anti-inflammatory) for 3 weeks and then take it from there.

There's no way to tighten up a ligament without surgery, but before reverting to surgery I'd like to see how things feel once I take every non-surgical course of action to reduce the inflammation.

Switched to doc who heads the podiatry group in our med center and he's much better than the young very inexperienced doc I first saw, but I may still see a sports podiatry specialist. Found out from him that first doc should have never given me a cortisone shot for the neuroma – most podiatrists like to avoid this in active people and athletes because it can loosen the ligaments and dissolve the fat pad – sure enough within a few weeks after the cortisone shot I felt pain in the base of the 2nd toe from the stretched ligament right near the injection. The injury could have been there but not as bad and the cortisone shot made it worse. In any case I'll never go to a new doc in a field that benefits from a lot of experience again – they can practice on someone else.

Doc gave me Spenco Rx Arthritis Foot Beds (just a well-cushioned footbed with a good arch) with small metatarsal pads stuck on in the center forefoot behind the metatarsal bones, to help spread the bones from the nerve.

My left foot is uncomfortable but I'm still walking at least 1 hour per day and hopefully going for a short hike this afternoon. I'm being careful but stopping all walking would be the worst course of action.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
Loading...