I think that the rigid big toe joint causes Morton's Toe. I'm still straightening out all this info. Your full recovery is encouraging as I deal with my foot injury. Best wishes for continued recovery and many trails ahead.
Found out through MRI that I have what's called 2nd Metatarsal Phalangeal Joint Stress Syndrome – a torn/stretched ligament around the 2nd toe joint which may have caused the Morton's neuroma by leaking fluid from the joint and rubbing the bones against the nerve. Trying to get the inflammation down with ice and anti-inflammatory (Advil) and PT (ultrasound and other anti-inflammatory) for 3 weeks and then take it from there.
There's no way to tighten up a ligament without surgery, but before reverting to surgery I'd like to see how things feel once I take every non-surgical course of action to reduce the inflammation.
Switched to doc who heads the podiatry group in our med center and he's much better than the young very inexperienced doc I first saw, but I may still see a sports podiatry specialist. Found out from him that first doc should have never given me a cortisone shot for the neuroma – most podiatrists like to avoid this in active people and athletes because it can loosen the ligaments and dissolve the fat pad – sure enough within a few weeks after the cortisone shot I felt pain in the base of the 2nd toe from the stretched ligament right near the injection. The injury could have been there but not as bad and the cortisone shot made it worse. In any case I'll never go to a new doc in a field that benefits from a lot of experience again – they can practice on someone else.
Doc gave me Spenco Rx Arthritis Foot Beds (just a well-cushioned footbed with a good arch) with small metatarsal pads stuck on in the center forefoot behind the metatarsal bones, to help spread the bones from the nerve.
My left foot is uncomfortable but I'm still walking at least 1 hour per day and hopefully going for a short hike this afternoon. I'm being careful but stopping all walking would be the worst course of action.