Topic

What Bag for Wind Rivers??

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Ben Wortman BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 7:24 am

I have a trip planned to the wind rivers this summer, and I am trying to decide what bag I need to bring. I will be there the end of July/beginning of August. I have both a WM Badger (15)and Megalite (30). I am going to try to fit everything for a 6 night trip into a golite jam 2 pack, so pack space is definately an issue. (This will be my first real trip trying to go semi-ultralite). Do you think I can get away with the megalite, or should i bring the badger? I will be spending at least a few night up in titcomb basin, and the remaining below tree line or close to it.

Thanks

Fred Eoff BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 7:39 am

My one experience with the Winds was a bit later in early September. Fabulously sunny and warm during the day. And I froze my butt off at night! If you can handle the extra volume and weight I would opt for the warmer option personally.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 8:05 am

Definitely the 15* bag. While you may encounter a balmy week, you're more likely to have plenty of frosty nights or snowstorms. Last summer it snowed a foot in Titcomb Basin on Aug. 8 and again on Aug. 15. The temp at the Elkhart Park visitor center (9300 feet) on the morning of Aug. 9 was 20*. If my dog hadn't gotten sick, forcing a premature exit, I'd have been up at 11,000 feet when the second storm hit!

Actually, a good 20* bag (like my Western Mountaineering Ultralite) would be fine, but I doubt that you want to buy a third sleeping bag. While your Badger may be warmer than you need, it's better than shivering on cold nights!

If you have a non-insulated air pad like the NeoAir, I'd take a piece of 3/8" CCF pad to boost the insulation!

Have a great trip! IMHO, the Winds are one of the most beautiful places on this earth! Lord willing (gotta add that caveat at my age), I may be there at about the same time!

John Vance BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 8:09 am

I have spent months in the Winds at all times of the year and you should be fine going with the Megalite unless you are an really cold sleeper. Most of my time in the Winds is after Labor Day and before Memorial day.

For the past 16 years I have spent a week or two in the fall starting on Labor Day weekend and I have used summer bags (25-32F ratings) with no problem – despite some occasional dips into the low 20's.

Having taken a Megalite on a number of these trips you should be good. If it gets really cold you can augment with your clothes.

Last year was cooler than normal and I used a Golite Ultra 20 which has about the same loft as the Megalite but is a bit more breezy, and slept just fine.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 8:24 am

I guess it all depends on whether YOU are comfortable in a 30* bag at 15-20*, which are temps you can expect up there. I wouldn't be, but I am a cold sleeper! If you get a chance to test the Megalite in 20* temps, you may want to do so before deciding.

John Vance BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 10:04 am

If you are in an area where you can get out and test the rating of your bags that would be a huge advantage. Just remember that even though you may be warm sleeping in the Megalite on the deck at 20f doesn't necessarily mean that you will be warm in the mountains. Factor in energy expenditure, hydration, fatigue, caloric intake, altitude, wind, and shelter type just to name a few, and you may find yourself shivering in above freezing temps in a winter bag. One of the coldest weeks I spent sleeping at night was in near freezing temps in a WM Versalite Superlite fully clothed and wearing a down vest. A stomach bug combined with a leaking mattress left me shivering all night and longing for the warmth of the morning sun. It was still a great trip, just looong nights

I spend many winter nights testing the limits of light and ultralight gear in conditions that they weren't designed for. Much of this testing takes place in the backyard or close to home just in case I need to bail out. So far I haven't needed to but I have spent many uncomfortable nights this way. I have been honing my snow tarping skills this past winter and will move into tarping in blowing rain shortly. Unfortunately despite my success it is the biting bugs that keep me from fully embracing tarps. I have moved to quilts and shorter pads, but it is still an exped downmat 7 short…no lightweight but worth all 20ozs and down from the 32oz of the regular length!

The bottom line is that you will have to decide for yourself and if that decision can be based on some testing, all the better. I can tell you that the Winds are so breathtaking that a cold night won't be so bad. I relish the below freezing nights as the bugs can be pretty bad during the time you are going and a good freeze keeps the little buggers down.

PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 10:19 am

Conditions can be quite variable. I was there mid-August last year. First day on the trail – 7pm start – was beautiful and we got 4 miles in and woke up to a blizzard. That first full day we hiked in snow and hail storms all day, max temp was 39. 4 days later we were roasting mid-day and wearing headnets close to the lakes. It was cold at night….unless you are a really warm sleeper, 15 degree bag is fine. I would have been cold in anything rated over 20.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...