I think I'm going to suck it up and buy something on the order of a Versalite, which is rated to 10f and weighs 2 lbs
If I wasn't going to make my own 5 degree quilt, the Versalite is the bag I would buy. I'm not the most experienced winter camper, but I don't think you can go wrong with WM.
I'm also going to do the math on pad weights and see if it also just doesn't make sense to get something like an Exped down mat and leave the others at home, as much for simplicity as warmth.
I kicked around going with a Downmat instead of CCF pads, but for the time being have decided to stick with CCFs.
The only plus for me that a Downmat had over CCFS was comfort.
Now, that's a big plus, but not one I could justify spending the dollars on yet.
Also, I believe I recall someone telling me with the downmat, I should bring at least a torso-length CCF in case the downmat springs a leak I can't patch. I'd need that CCF for sitting on frozen ground while cooking/eating etc anyways.
There aren't really any weight saving for a full size Exped, which weights 31.9oz for an R-Value of 5.9. Plus add in the weight of your CCF sit/emergency pad.
I'm using 3 CCF pads weigh a total of 20.53oz with a total R-Value of 5.869 from my head to just below my hips, and 3.469 from there to my feet. They are a 72" Ridgrest trimmed to mummy shape(9.28oz), a short Ridgerest cut to 40" and trimmed to fit(5.57oz), and a 38"x60" 3/16" thick pad from Oware that doubles as my ground sheet.(5.68oz). And one of the others is used when sitting down.
Definitely not as comfortable as an inflatable, and takes up a lot of space on my pack, but lighter and cheaper for the same warmth.