Topic

FUGU + Summerlite =?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
PostedFeb 16, 2010 at 2:25 pm

I know there are a lot of variables in the equation that I can't control for, but I keep wondering how far down I can extend my sleep system wearing a a FUGU inside my Summerlite, assuming the loft isn't compressed beyond the point of diminishing returns.

Anyone care to take a best guess?

Put another way, will I be able to camp in snow in a tent at say North Lake in the Sierra Nevada in early March?

Pads are 1/8" CCF, BMW Torsolite, and Ridgerest; I have a MLD Superlite bivy (with net head), and I have plenty of additional base and mid layers.

John S. BPL Member
PostedFeb 16, 2010 at 4:53 pm

Maybe summerlite rating plus 10 degrees depending on other factors.

PostedFeb 16, 2010 at 5:22 pm

"but I keep wondering how far down I can extend my sleep system wearing a a FUGU inside my Summerlite, assuming the loft isn't compressed beyond the point of diminishing returns."

I'd give some serious thought to my feet and lower body as well, were I you.

Jim MacDiarmid BPL Member
PostedFeb 16, 2010 at 5:26 pm

I took a Nunatak Arc Specialist (comparable to the Summerlite, which is what I traded in when I got the Specialist) down to ~20 degrees wearing a Montbell UL Down Inner Parks + Thermwrap vest. I was a bit chilly but that may have been because I was only on a NeoAir short. Via this chart here by Richard Nisley, I can see that the Down Inner + vest combo is roughly 1/3 as warm as the Fugu. So I’d say 10 degrees additional would be a safe estimate.

Edit:I’d give some serious thought to my feet and lower body as well, were I you.

+1 to that.

PostedFeb 16, 2010 at 6:22 pm

I took a Nike ACG down jacket with a GoLite Ultra 20 (which is probably comparable to the Summerlite) down to 5 in a Montbell Breeze Dry Tec Bivy. I was wearing a midweight base layer and a fleece top and bottom along with a pair of gloves and a balaclava, and 2 pair of wool socks. I was not extremely comfortable, but was able to sleep most of the night. I don't really have a winter kit, so I was making due to get out of the house. That same trip my boots leaked and I ended up with socksickles in the morning. My boots were frozen solid, and it was fun thawing them out let me tell you. I learned that I need a winter kit. I was never in danger of hypothermia, but could have been a LOT more comfortable.

PostedFeb 16, 2010 at 6:37 pm

Ten degrees lower was about what I was guessing–to be safe. And yes, I've thought much about my legs and feet, but wanted to try to keep the question relatively simple and focused on my core–and I just got the FUGU, and the question has intrigued me.

I no longer have a true winter snow camping setup. The last one I had disappeared and/or degraded over the years, but that was all fairly conventional gear, and, over 20 years ago. I've camped very comfortably in snow down to -25f, in blizzards, up to 16,000 ft, but until I can afford serious winter camp gear, I've got to try to make do with what I have, or borrow, for a snow trip coming up in March. Too, most of my gear is built more around desert camping these days, where cold temps don't really get much below freezing.

FWIW, what would you Sierra winter veterans recommend as an ideal bag that's good enough to do the job without having to double-duty your down camp jacket, but serviceably light weight relative to its real world low temperature threshold?

Rod Lawlor BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 4:37 am

I'd give some serious thought to a Downmat too. This would let you shift most of the Summerlite loft to the top, for a much warmer night's sleep. By the time you add your three mats, the weight will be getting close, plus the bulk will be a lot more.

PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 4:50 am

+1 on lower body comment, and don't forget a decent hat.

Haven't used a WM bag yet, but recently took a MHW Phantom 32 down to about 5 deg F, sleeping in the loft of an AT shelter (no wind, but cold). I think I could have gone colder with minor discomfort, but was glad not to find out for sure. I did wear everything but my boots, gaiters and rain gear:

=> feet – liners, VB socks, mid weight wool, Integral Designs Hot Socks
=> legs – Boxerjocks, Cap 1, Warmlite VB pants, BMW cocoon pants
=> top – Cap 2 zipT, Warmlite VB shirt, R1 Hoody, Montbell 1/2 sleeve UL jacket, Puff pullover
=> head – fleece hat, R1 hoody, BMW Cocoon 90
=> Prolite XS, Ridgerest (cut down), blue foam sitpad, pack under my legs
=> MHW Phantom 32
=> MYOG sil/momentum bivy

Got kinda cool around 2 am, so added my trusty Twin Peaks as a blanket and then slept straight through until 0730.

PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 5:00 am

I've slept only a few nights in my new Fugu, but each time I've borrowed my wife's Alpenlite rather than using my Summerlite. The Summerlite doesn't allow the Fugu to loft up to maximum advantage. I've been toasty warm in the Fugu, but then I also had WM Flight pants and FF booties on, and full-length DownMat 7 underneath me. I was inside an extra-wide MLD Superlite bivy.

PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 9:35 am

I would try the fugo over your feet and legs too. Pull it over them like a half bag and inside your other bag. Then use
other upper body layers of top.

PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 10:28 am

"The Summerlite doesn't allow the Fugu to loft up to maximum advantage"

THIS was my main concern. The Summerlite isn't the widest bag I've been in to begin with, and I already have wide shoulders to boot.

After talking with some other people I trust last night, I think I'm going to suck it up and buy something on the order of a Versalite, which is rated to 10f and weighs 2 lbs. I just don't want to end up in a position where I'm suffering through cold nights and cursing myself for trying to save 13 ounces. Not worth the trouble. I'm also going to do the math on pad weights and see if it also just doesn't make sense to get something like an Exped down mat and leave the others at home, as much for simplicity as warmth. This way, I'll have a much warmer base to work with, and the FUGU et al will be more like an insurance policy rather than a necessity.

The Sierra in winter above tree line is just not where I want to screw around with trying to shed every single last ounce. Anyway, where I spend most of my outdoor time–the desert–is where I really need to push hard on lowering weight since you have to carry so much water.

Thanks everyone for helping me think this through.

Jim MacDiarmid BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 10:59 am

I think I'm going to suck it up and buy something on the order of a Versalite, which is rated to 10f and weighs 2 lbs

If I wasn't going to make my own 5 degree quilt, the Versalite is the bag I would buy. I'm not the most experienced winter camper, but I don't think you can go wrong with WM.

I'm also going to do the math on pad weights and see if it also just doesn't make sense to get something like an Exped down mat and leave the others at home, as much for simplicity as warmth.

I kicked around going with a Downmat instead of CCF pads, but for the time being have decided to stick with CCFs.

The only plus for me that a Downmat had over CCFS was comfort.
Now, that's a big plus, but not one I could justify spending the dollars on yet.

Also, I believe I recall someone telling me with the downmat, I should bring at least a torso-length CCF in case the downmat springs a leak I can't patch. I'd need that CCF for sitting on frozen ground while cooking/eating etc anyways.

There aren't really any weight saving for a full size Exped, which weights 31.9oz for an R-Value of 5.9. Plus add in the weight of your CCF sit/emergency pad.

I'm using 3 CCF pads weigh a total of 20.53oz with a total R-Value of 5.869 from my head to just below my hips, and 3.469 from there to my feet. They are a 72" Ridgrest trimmed to mummy shape(9.28oz), a short Ridgerest cut to 40" and trimmed to fit(5.57oz), and a 38"x60" 3/16" thick pad from Oware that doubles as my ground sheet.(5.68oz). And one of the others is used when sitting down.

Definitely not as comfortable as an inflatable, and takes up a lot of space on my pack, but lighter and cheaper for the same warmth.

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...