I am mostly a day (long days) hiker but will be branching out. I am looking to lighten my summer rain-gear load and add an emergency shelter that can double as a real shelter. Currently I carry a pretty light rain jacket and pants, pack cover, and for emergency shelter I carry an AMK Thermo-lite bivvy , and a Heatsheet emergency blanket.
For about 6 months of Northeast weather, I'm thinking just a poncho tarp/shelter and the rain pants (only in weather less than 70 degrees). For the other 6 months the poncho would be just my emergency shelter.
I really like the features of the Gatewood Cape (and bug net) but, from some reviews I've read here, I am concerned it will be far to big for me to use as a poncho. I am a 5' 3" tall woman. Do any short people have any experience with this?
The Integral Designs Sil Poncho also seems really nice, and would likely fit, but it is a tarp. If I went with a tarp, it would be harder to use in buggy weather as a shelter and I could always get a less expensive one like Equinox one and use the extra money for a breathable bivvy with bug-net.
Any opinions or experience is greatly appreciated.
Topic
advice on poncho tarp/shelter
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
I have used the Equinox poncho both as raingear and as a shelter in rain and a snowstorm (the first big one in VA that buried D.C.). I like it but it IS a compromise, its not perfect as raingear or a shelter.
For a lot more background on the subject check out
http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/poncho_tarp_techniques_gear_inclement_conditions.html
I have carried the Gatewood and ID cape(not poncho) at the same time.
I am 5' 11" and although the Gatewood is an excellent weatherproof shelter, the long length has been a minor issue as a hiking cape.
The ID cape has been perfect for me, maybe a little short, but I like that. I'd suspect the ID poncho to be too long and get hung up on things.
When it's raining I like to be able to wear the ID cape around camp while the Gatewood is setup as my shelter.
If I wasn't expecting rain, I'd only bring the Gatewood.
The Gatewood is different in that it acts as a pyramid tarp instead of a flat tarp like other poncho shelters.
This means that the Gatewood has more 360 degree protection from wind blown rain and snow and can be warmer if pitched low to the ground. This would be my choice if I wasn't going be using a bivy.
The flat tarp ponchos have more flexibility in how they can be pitched and can be just as bombproof, but I would tend to want to use these type of shelters with an ultralight bivy.
Hi Lisa.
I used the Gatewood Cape this passed summer. I cannot speak highly enough of its quality and versatility. When wearing as a cape I hitch it up with the attached loops and snaps-that brings the length to knee level. It is about mid-calf length when not hitched up. I am 5’6″. it was a great shelter for me, withstanding pounding rains, winds, and snow ( a freak storm). It does give you 360 degree protection and privacy when needed and there is enough head room to sit up.
No pack cover required and you have access to you pack contents while wearing in the rain. I have also set it up in shelter mode while wearing it and taken it down from the inside. With some practice it’s pretty easy.

I don’t know how much of a problem bugs are in your area. When sitting in my shelter or when sleeping I used the BPL mosquito net over my face and neck. It’s nice to know there is a net available for the cape however.
I hope this is helpful. Good luck with your quest
Following is an earlier post re: my Cape experience
Hi All,
Thanks so much for the replies and the stories! I think I'll be going with the Gatewood (with a little practice). I'll let everyone know how it works for me.
LJ
Become a member to post in the forums.

