I'm wrestling with this decision also, looking for a tent primarily for winter/snow use. Here's how I'm looking at it so far, but would welcome further input:
Sublite–lightest, excellent for sun and insect protection, OK for rain as long as you don't have to go in and out of the tent (exposed entry)–so for me, a summer Sierra tent. Not a winter tent.
Sublite sil–better in prolonged heavy rain (but still unprotected entry), heavier, otherwise similar to Sublite (though in the process of revision)(not as good sun protection, probably a low priority for most). Not a winter tent.
Moment–still heavier, great in rain (may want to add more silicone at top), light snow OK, but won't protect against spindrift or raking cold wind (no real inner, just mesh). Great setup speed (just two pegs), and possibly great wind stability.
Scarp 1–heaviest, slowest setup (6 pegs, which seems a lot to deal with in snow), but best protection against raking (horizontal) winter wind, blowing snow.
Not sure of wind stability or snow load comparison between Moment and Scarp 1.
I'd love to come down on the side of the Moment, because of its weight and set-up ease, but wonder if it wouldn't be more prudent to choose the Scarp 1. The biggest downside of the Scarp 1, for me, is the thought of fiddling with 6 anchors to set it up in deep snow (Moment would only require 2).
If there were a Moment with a freestanding nylon/mesh inner(as opposed to the current all mesh inner) , or even a much higher bathtub floor (for wind/spindrift protection), it might be perfect for winter. But there may be good ventilation reasons why this wouldn't work, or would require too much reworking of the current design.