Topic

Tent Decision…

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 21 posts - 1 through 21 (of 21 total)
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 2:43 pm

Hello everyone,

So I've been looking to buy my first backpacking tent, and I've been told that tarptents are the way to go. As for my needs, I'll be using this tent on the West Coast of Canada, mainly in the summer, but using it for all seasons would be nice (I'm thinking of getting into mountaineering at some point, but that isn't a crucial decision for me).

What I'm looking for in the tent is:
Lightweight
Waterproof
Versatile
Stable in Winds
A low fly so that wind doesn't create a draft when I'm in need of more warmth
3+ Seasons
Views never hurt :)
Freestanding

I think I have narrowed it down to the Tarptent Rainbow, Moment, and Scarp 1.

Thoughts?

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 5:49 pm

It's not freestanding, but the Six Moon Designs Vamp appears to be a great tent that meets all of your other requirements and it's super light (27oz) for a double wall tent. I imagine that you are flexible with your freestanding requirement since the Scarp 1 isn't freestanding and both the Rainbow and Moment are only freestanding if you bring additional gear (trekking poles and a extra pole respectively).

http://community.sixmoondesigns.com/photos/vamp_tarp__nettent/picture316.aspx

The SMD Lunar Solo is even lighter (23oz) if you want a single wall.

MLD also sells some nice tarp/net tent combinations that can effectively create a non-freestanding double wall tent. The DuoMid with the DuoMid net inner looks like a great combo. What I like about the SMD offerings though is the wider headroom that using two trekking poles creates. The SMD tents can also be set up with optional poles if you don't use trekking poles.

Where on the West Coast are you planning on hiking?

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 7:54 pm

Scarp is probably the only one of those 3 that could add warmth. The other two can get a little breezy if they're pitched in the wrong location.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 8:07 pm

Being in an extremely humid climate, you may want to consider only double walled shelters as you will have copious condensation on any single walled shelter that you use on the West Coast of Canada. So I would agree with Both Dan and Joe as to their suggestions.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 8:16 pm

Thanks for the quick responses,

I'll be using the tent on Vancouver Island, the mainland somewhat up by Whistler, and possibly in the interior (Rockies). I've never really considered this place to be too humid… Maybe I'm crazy.

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 8:22 pm

And you could get both inners for the Scarp. Or you could buy a bunch of Cuban stuff, and hope you can do enough for your wife that she won't be mad when it finally shows up. Not sure who on here would do anything like that though.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 8:29 pm

There are two inner tents for the scarp? I'm assuming a ones the regular fabric and the other is mesh?

And now wife to worry about ;) Just some nosey roomates.

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 8:50 pm

Yep. Pretty sure you can get a mesh and a solid inner for the Scarp.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 9:06 pm

None of the tents you mention are truly freestanding. The Scarp with the optional poles will be the best at freestanding. But if you have good staking ground the Scarp is great. (I had the 2, not the 1 but it is the same.) It sets up with the inner connected to the fly so it goes up fast and dry inside. Mine had the mesh inner and I had the solid inner on order when I decided to sell it. I still may try the Scarp 1 in the future.

I have not been able to use or even see 1st hand a Moment yet. But from what I see I think this may be the best solo TT yet. Wind is a big concern for me and it looks like it should shed it well.

I have a Rainbow too. Quite honestly I like all my other Tarptents better. Maybe I was expecting WonderTent after everything I read, but it left me missing my Squall 2. And I am NOT knocking it. Great tent for the weight. Plenty of room. Do not like the trekking pole “freestanding” set-up. Ate a lot of dirt in high winds.

Since I have zero knowledge of your area I won’t offer advice for any other tents. But good luck and have fun shopping. Have even more fun using it!

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 9:44 pm

Thanks,

I also forgot to mention that it would be great if the vestibule is big enough to cook in…

I think I've narrowed it down to the Scarp and the Moment… While the Scarp looks great, do you think I could get away with the Moment? For my needs it looks great, the only thing I'm slightly concerned about is its "true" four seasons usage.

. . BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 10:19 pm

Eric,

Don't hesitate to contact Henry Shires @ tarptent – he knows his products inside out and gives honest opinions. He turned me away from getting a Scarp, because I needed a tent that had a fly that goes all the way to the ground for spindrift, etc. I've heard that he may have lowered the edges, so that would be something to check for true 4-season performance. I've been very impressed w/ TT overall.

Since Raymond somehow didn't mention it ;), you may want to look at some of the BA tents as well (Seedhouse SL, Copper Spur + Fly Creek series). I have a Seedhouse SL2 with a solid inner (which was a now discontinued custom option) that really handles wind quite nicely. I've used it on an exposed ridge on Mt. Rainier w/ no problems, although the wind probably didn't top 40mph. It is tough to stay below 4 lbs for a true 4-season, free-stainding tent.

Why do you want free-stainding? I prefer them, as well, but I also have a Hilleberg that is fantastic in the PNW mountains, forrest, + coast!

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 10:19 pm

No, I would not recommend the Moment for 4-season, even shoulder-season use. Although if I had one I would undoubtedly push it close just to see. I have pics of our Squall and Contrails in snow, I am sure this would do better.

I would hesitantly recommend the Scarp (with crossing poles) for true full-on 4-season use. Like I said I may pick up a Scarp 1 but I am comfortable with the limitations of it. (And the pluses.) The clipping system for the crossing poles is not the funnest thing to work with especially when everything is cold and/or frozen. Right now I still run for my 4-season tents, be they double or single wall if I expect big weather.

The Scarp has plenty of room to cook in as long as you don’t have a flame-thrower while priming. Start it while the fly door is open. Be very careful with all of these as silnylon goes up in flames easily and fast. I chose to use my Caldera Cone for its first time in the rain rather than take a chance in the Terra Nova Laser that I was using for the first time also. (I could just see trying to explain how I burnt a tent up in the snow and rain at 34 F…)

Personal note: I love double-wall tents even though I have and have had many single walls. If Henry were to tell me, “Ray, I will give you a Moment or a Scarp 1, pick one”. Even though I am very intrigued by the Moment, the Scarp fits my style much better.

I know, this did not help one bit. Roll the dice, dude. Tell us what you decided on and how the trips went.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 10:31 pm

Ben has me afraid to mention them. Do you think he saw your post…?

;-)

I was just staying on topic. I LOVE the new Fly Creek 2. I have an even better 4-season-pushing light-weight double-wall that I am using right now. I don't know how I can give it it HR without you guys telling me "no-way, too heavy" but I am impressed as heck with it. I think I will jump it up in the queue to share it quicker.

Oops, back to topic.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 10:34 pm

A couple of comments on the Scarp 1
The new version does have the fly down to ground level and two new vents to still allow some air flow.
See it here : http://www.tarptent.com/scarp1rev.html
As for cooking I would also consider the Scarp . You can easily undo a few clips and pull the floor back giving you a much greater area to cook under.
Franco
Scarp vestibule

. . BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 10:54 pm

"Ben has me afraid to mention them. Do you think he saw your post…?"

Well either he hasn't or has some serious constraint at the moment. (pun unintentional) And of course my tent is his old one.

I look forward to hearing more about this new tent when you can!

"Oops, back to topic."


@Franco
– thanks for the pic and link – those look like excellent revisions. Do you know if they will apply to the Scarp 2 also? (Speaking of the Scarp 2, it is even at ~4.5 lbs. as a full 4-season set-up.)

@OP – These two choices (moment vs. scarp) are very different shelters – there is no question that the Scarp fits the bill more for what you listed, but it is also a full pound heavier and $80 more expensive than the other option. Perhaps those will weigh into your decision as well. Keep in mind that there is always the Gear Swap forum here and you can't go wrong with one of Henry's works – either purchasing or selling.

Dean F. BPL Member
PostedFeb 11, 2010 at 9:06 am

Someone posted a pic here a little while ago of their TT Moment under a significant snow load. IIRC Henry popped up on the forum and didn't recommend it. The pole was likely THIS CLOSE to failure, in the picture. I have one, and I'm sure that the long second pole would add significant stability, but I don't think it's a 4-season tent.

That said, it is ALMOST free-standing (if that makes any sense) even without the second pole- you could easily erect it just by running cords to two trees or rocks or whatever. I've set it up in my living room that way. I cannot over-emphasize how quick and easy it is to erect this tent.

Jim Sweeney BPL Member
PostedFeb 11, 2010 at 9:37 am

I'm wrestling with this decision also, looking for a tent primarily for winter/snow use. Here's how I'm looking at it so far, but would welcome further input:

Sublite–lightest, excellent for sun and insect protection, OK for rain as long as you don't have to go in and out of the tent (exposed entry)–so for me, a summer Sierra tent. Not a winter tent.

Sublite sil–better in prolonged heavy rain (but still unprotected entry), heavier, otherwise similar to Sublite (though in the process of revision)(not as good sun protection, probably a low priority for most). Not a winter tent.

Moment–still heavier, great in rain (may want to add more silicone at top), light snow OK, but won't protect against spindrift or raking cold wind (no real inner, just mesh). Great setup speed (just two pegs), and possibly great wind stability.

Scarp 1–heaviest, slowest setup (6 pegs, which seems a lot to deal with in snow), but best protection against raking (horizontal) winter wind, blowing snow.

Not sure of wind stability or snow load comparison between Moment and Scarp 1.

I'd love to come down on the side of the Moment, because of its weight and set-up ease, but wonder if it wouldn't be more prudent to choose the Scarp 1. The biggest downside of the Scarp 1, for me, is the thought of fiddling with 6 anchors to set it up in deep snow (Moment would only require 2).

If there were a Moment with a freestanding nylon/mesh inner(as opposed to the current all mesh inner) , or even a much higher bathtub floor (for wind/spindrift protection), it might be perfect for winter. But there may be good ventilation reasons why this wouldn't work, or would require too much reworking of the current design.

PostedFeb 11, 2010 at 9:51 am

> Someone posted a pic here a little while ago of their TT Moment under a significant snow load. IIRC Henry popped up on the forum and didn't recommend it. The pole was likely THIS CLOSE to failure, in the picture. I have one, and I'm sure that the long second pole would add significant stability, but I don't think it's a 4-season tent.

Yes, I don't recommend the Moment for 4-season use–too much low level mesh and not enough pole structure –but it's not true that the poles were "likely THIS CLOSE to failure". I've had the Moment (with crossing pole) set up all winter with periodic heavy, wet snowfalls (up to 1' of "Sierra cement") and the poles are just fine. The Easton poles will flex and even bend a little to relieve stress but pole failure, i.e snapping, just has not been the case. What I also said was that I would recommend asking us for 9mm substitute poles if you think you're going to experience any significant snowfall. They'll add a few ounces–about 3 ounces for the arch and crossing pole set–but are noticeably stronger and stiffer. I've rated the Moment as a "3+" precisely because it will handle some shoulder season snow.

-H

PostedFeb 11, 2010 at 11:19 am

I agree with James, If there was a Moment that had a mesh/nylon inner such as the Scarp, and if the fly was slightly longer, I would buy that in an instant! But, that might take away from some of the Scarp sales.

PostedFeb 11, 2010 at 11:24 am

I own a Moment and, yes, it's breezy in high winds (35 – 45 mph.) in my experience. But it's extremely stable in those winds due to its canopy design, which is aerodynamic and always pitches taut.
As for obtaining a a "low canopy" with the Moment, that can be easily fixed by digging a little divot for each end of the arch pole. This lowers the canopy.
Yes. I have the crossing pole for camping on rock slabs when sea kayaking but I don't recommend the extra (& unnecessary) weight when backpacking.

For a more versatile tent – but more weight – the Scarp 1 comes with the option of either/or a netting inner tent or a ripstop inner tent for colder, winter weather.

PostedFeb 11, 2010 at 3:43 pm

"@Franco – thanks for the pic and link – those look like excellent revisions. Do you know if they will apply to the Scarp 2 also? (Speaking of the Scarp 2, it is even at ~4.5 lbs. as a full 4-season set-up.)"

I asked Henry about that, he told me that the Scarp2 will get the same revisions as the Scarp 1, and estimated that it would go into production that way in spring.

Viewing 21 posts - 1 through 21 (of 21 total)
Loading...