Can you guys provide some insights on the pros/cons of using a Serenity nettent vs. a bivy, both with a tarp?
Mostly I'd be looking at 3 season, northern half of California.
Topic
Become a member to post in the forums.
Can you guys provide some insights on the pros/cons of using a Serenity nettent vs. a bivy, both with a tarp?
Mostly I'd be looking at 3 season, northern half of California.
A bivy will get ice on the inside if it's much below freezing outside.
I use a MLD Serenity with a MLD Grace Duo Tarp. I'm very happy with this setup for 3 season hiking in the southeast. The Serenity will give you a lot more space to move around, etc compared to a bivy. It doesn't give you any wind break and in blowing rain you can get a little wet. If I expect a hard cold wind or bad rain on a trip i take a bivy.
You can see some photos of the Serenity and Grace Duo on my blog.
At the risk of preaching heresy here, why not take both? Use the Serenity unless the conditions are bad enough you would want to use the bivy.
Bivies, obviously, are less breathable than net shelters and can accumulate perspiration inside, but also keep more moisture *out* too. The net shelters are wonderfully open and breathable, plus more roomy, but not where you might want to be in blowing rain.
Serenity is probably best all around, if your tarp provides good coverage.
It wouldn't be as warm as a bivy, but should protect against most splash in an A-frame setup.
It really shines at bug protection and provides far better ventilation.
Another compromise would be an ultralight bivy with big net like the the option on some of the MLD, Ti-Goat and the SMD Meteor bivy. They are more breathable and more comfortable than your typical mountaineering bivy.
Become a member to post in the forums.