Topic

2 pass gravity filter for heavy sediment

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
Brian Vogt BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 1:41 pm

So, I'm heading to the southwest in March for some boating/hiking. I'm inclined to take my gravity filter cause, well, I'm lazy, but also we'll pull from clear tanks whenever possible. I'm fairly certain we'll have to pull some water out of the main stem of a river or two, and expect pretty solid sediment loads in those cases.

Here's my thought: By adding 1 gravity hang bag to my filter kit, I could use a 2 pass gravity system. Here's how it would work:

step 1: Fill prefilter bag with river water. At bottom of bag, a standard Katadyn Hiker-style prefilter will protect the gravity intake hose. The water will then gravity feed through an MSR SiltStopper 5 micron prefilter and flow into prefilter bag #2.

Then once bag #2 is full, I'll route the prefiltered water through my regular .2 micron gravity feed setup.

Plan B: Find a 5 or 10 micron fabric filter bag, as used for biofuels, and permanently sew it into my gravity feed sack. I'd design to be a 2 gallon total system, so 1 gallon would fit in the prefilter chamber, and 1 gallon would fit below the prefilter ready to feed the main filter.

Any thoughts?

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 5:29 pm

In lieu of two passes, why not:

1. Scoop water using a water scoop with integrated prefilter into the “dirty” water bag.

2. Hang and let water pass through (1) 5 micron Siltstopper and (2)reglar 0.2 micron gravity feed filter down into the receiving “clean” water bag?

Brian Vogt BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 5:54 pm

probably foolishly, that the flow rate would be very slow with stacked filters. it would certainly be preferable to do it with one process. I don't supposed you've tried it? great idea.

one benefit of the 2 bag system would be maximizing hydraulic head pressure, which I expect to be needed with the sediment load.

would love to hear if anyone has tried this with desert silt loads.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 6:19 pm

Firstly, there won't be any "sediment load" if you scoop water using my water scoop with prefilter suggestion.

Secondly, I don't think there will be any measurable delay at all — I think the flow rate is determined by the filter with the smallest pore size — adding one with a big pore size "upstream" won't matter much.

Brian Vogt BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 9:07 pm

won't be nullified by any loose screen prefilter. I'm expecting to use several siltstopper filter elements over the course of 2 weeks. this is more akin to glacial milk than just some floaties. I'm talking the kind of "water" that will clog a standard pump filter in 2L or so. really though it's more earth in a moist form than really water lol

So while the idea of the siltstopper inline sounds great with the kind of water where I don't need that 5 micron prefilter, I am inclined to expect that gravity alone may not provide enough force to clear this water. If nobody has first hand experience though, I'll take a varied kit and play with it to see what works best.

Has anyone here tried to gravity filter this kind of water?

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 10:03 pm

I've read about these being used as the first stage of your filter. If you really have that much sediment, it will clog most prefilters quickly. Having the whole cloth bag surface as a filter will be useful in keeping the water flowing. Check some of the bushcraft boards for more info.

I'm not sure I'd use one of these heavy special canvas bags, since you are using something more sophisticated as a next stage. Perhaps a lighter cloth though?

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
Loading...