Topic

Help me pick a pack

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 8:19 am

In my transition to ultralight I've decided to start my acquisitions with a pack. But as a practically unemployed 23 year old I need a versatile pack. I also need one that one bust the bank, or bust itself.

I want larger because I'm still narrowing down my pack weight (from 26 lbs. aiming for around 13 lbs. with a few purchases) and there may be some long trails in my future. I'm also willing to spend a little more to make sure it lasts a long time.

So far I've stumbled upon 3 that I think would work well for my application:

Granite Gear Nimbus Ozone $170
Gossamer Gear Gorilla $180
ULA Circuit $200

They are all approximately the same size, all framed and all durable. I looked at the REI Flash 65 as well and was unsure about it.

What'd I like from you all is some comments on my selection, if you've used the pack. Why you'd recommend it and if you'd have any other packs you'd recommend.

P.S. If you have on you'd like to sell that may settle my decision!

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 8:52 am

Start your transition with a pack? First of all, how heavy is your gear? And how bulky are they?

If your current gear is heavier and more bulky than you like, then start changing those first. Once they have 'stabilized' — then you can pick a nice UL pack to hold them and carry them comfortably.

But if your gear isn't "UL" and you put the cart before the horse — expecting a UL pack to carry your gear just as comfortably — you may very well be disappointed — sorely.

Pick the right tool for the job at hand. Match your pack to your gear — and not the other way around.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 8:57 am

+1 to paring down your other gear first.

Choosing a pack can be, for some, a lengthy and tedious process. Don't exacerbate it by having mismatched equipment. A pack is just as much a part of your entire system as your sleeping bag.

Oh, and one more thing. When you do choose a pack, no matter how comfortable it is on your back, don't forget about your legs (knees especially)! So much emphasis is on how the pack feels, and often we forget that we're adding weight and stress to other parts of our bodies as well. You're 23, so this may not be a big problem for you, but do remember to make sure your body is conditioned to do what you want to.

Jim MacDiarmid BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:01 am

Do you winter camp? Because if you do, that'll determine the max volume and load carrying capacity you need, and that would take the Conduit and probably the Gorilla out of the competition.

Also, I'd replace the GG Nimbus Ozone with the Six Moon Designs Starlite, as it weighs a pound less for the same volume and weight-carrying capacity.

If you just camp 3-season, I'd take buy the Gorilla of those three. I own one and like it alot. It has great volume for 3 seasons, and it'll work for me for winter (though it's not ideal) so long as I'm not looking at sub-zero temperatures. At that point, the loft of the required insulation exceeds the volume of the bag.

And it's probably harder to find a more versatie 3-season pack at the weight. For 1.5lbs, you get a framed pack that should hold all your gear(+ a bear cannister if you need one) on your heaviest trips. I've backpacked with up to 22lbs in it, but tested it on a dayhike for 2 hours with 30lbs comfortably.

For sub-20 lb trips, take out the removeable frame and experiment with frameless backpacking, knocking it down to 1.25 pounds.

For sub-15 lb trips, take off the hip bet and sternum strap as well, and you've got a 1 lb pack.

If you think you can keep your pack weight at 20 lbs or fewer, you might want to look at a frameless pack like the Conduit or a Mountain Laurel Design pack, which gets you the hip belt and a 1 lb pack. You're just limited in how much weight you can carry comfortably.

I've found the durability of the Gorrila fabric to be fine. I have put a small cut in it with probably a stray tent pole, but it patched fine. I'm not sure if dynemma is stronger, but believe it is considered to be.

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:04 am

Thanks for the quick replies:

My current and projected pack weight is in my post but I'll spell it out here.

Currently at 26 pounds total. And quite bulky.

I'm making or buying a 10X10 (or there abouts) silnylon tarp.
I'm replacing my currently sleeping system with a synthetic quilt which I'll either make or buy.

Hopefully get down to around 10-13 lbs. I'm not sure of volume but it will certainly be enough for the packs I listed.

Travis,
I am a Crossfit trainer and I like to think that I am well prepared for the rigors of trail life on my knees.

Jim,
There won't be any winter backpacking down here in Georgia, that may change but I've got my old Gregory to fall back on if I need to. Probably will stick with 3 season with hinge season use.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:10 am

At 26lbs. total (presumably including food and water) — your load is a good candidate for lighter weight packs. Some good ones that come to mind:

Gossamer Gear Gorilla or Mariposa
Six Moon Designs Starlite (mentioned above)
ULA Catalyst

I suggest looking at these because they are light weight, have relatively large capacity, and they have a removable "internal frame" that will help with the load when needed — but can also be removed easily when you have a lighter load (say on a shorter summer trip or after you've swapped out more gear for lighter weight counterparts).

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:13 am

+1 on leave the pack for last, unless you want to purchase several packs as you reduce weight and volume of other items.

My general recommendation to people who are trying to make a low cost transition to ultralight who currently have just heavyweight gear:

1) get input on your list… see if there are things you can just drop.
2) For three season trips consider simple food that just needs boiling and go with a minimalist pot and an alcohol stove. This can save 1-2lb over the traditional whsiperlite and larger pot for just about no cost.
3) In most cases, make a good, long term investment in a quality down bag
4) Consider a tarp or tarptent as a shelter.
5) NOW consider a new pack

As to the packs, these are three very different packs. The Conduit is frameless (some people love frameless, I am in the group that is willing to carry a bit of extra weight to get some sort of frame. The Gorilla is my go to pack. I love it, and recommend it for people carrying less than 25lbs. The gg vapor trail, ula ohm, six moon designs starlite/traveler or it's equiv. The Ozone is designed to carry heavier loads that the rest.

–Mark

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:28 am

I've edited my original post I meant the ULA Circuit, rather than the ULA Conduit. Beg y'alls' pardon.

Ben,
26 lbs was without food and water…

Mark,
I can't afford a down bag (unless I make one) and I personal prefer synthetic despite the weight. I've tried alcohol (in my garage on a sunny day and couldn't get anywhere near a boil) and went back to my pocket rocket/titan kettle. I've made my gear list, weighted everything to the nearest ounce and am making reductions everywhere I can.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:28 am

>Travis, I am a Crossfit trainer and I like to think that I am well prepared for the rigors of trail life on my knees.

Ah, then you're good to go! My comment was obviously made not knowing anything about you, but thought I'd just throw that out there just in case. Good luck!

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:34 am

"26 lbs was without food and water".

That means your total pack weight can be in the low to mid 30's. At that range, most people would want a pack with some kind of frame. My three suggestions above can still work well for you. Ditto for the Conduit, which also has a removable frame.

Curious — what is your current pack?

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 10:04 am

Ben,

For the last couple of years I've used an Dana Designs Astralpane. I've moved back to a 5 lb. 3 oz. Gregory Forester.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 10:12 am

Paul:

Yeah, switching packs will shave a few pounds right there. However, the Gregory is a sweet, sweet pack for 35-40 pounds range. You made a good choice going from Astralplane to Forester — given your total pack weight.

If I were you, I’d hold off spending for now — save up a bit more (if need be) — and invest in a really good UL sleeping bag — which should shave quite a bit of weight — but just as importantly — reduce a lot of bulk as well.

After the bag swapping (and maybe a few others) — you likely can switch to an even smaller and lighter pack! Something like this or this!!

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 10:30 am

As most experienced backpackers here will tell you the Conventional Wisdom says the pack is the last item you should buy, to be sure all your other gear fits in.

Having said that, If you're SURE you want to buy a pack first I'd definitely try to stay below 4,500 cubic inches. You can always add aftermarket side pockets for more volume. I did that on my REI UL 60 pack and it works fine. In fact I prefer side pockets to store things I need quickly like 1st aid or "potty bag".

YAMABUSHI ! BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 10:26 pm

(WITH ALL DO RESPECT)

AS I DO NOT KNOW YOU OR YOUR BACKGROUND, I whole heartedly disagree with the crossfit thing…

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 10:47 pm

With all due respect, if you don't know the guy or his fitness level, how can you disagree with him about crossfit? Do you disagree that he is a crossfit trainer?

I know you've expressed some kind of issue with it in the past, not being for the "ubermensch" but crossfit definitely gives you an elevated level of general fitness and leg strength, especially at 23. Plenty for the backpacking most people do.

six-moon starlite is a great pack. good volume for winter camping, and good load transfer with the stays. Cheers.

YAMABUSHI ! BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 11:18 pm

I am disagreeing with crossfit prepping you for the rigors of the trail. Elevated level for sure… but not ideal for what we do.

He didn’t specify whether he is a trainer OF crossfit or training IN crossfit, so on that I didn’t comment.

FYI: I am not going at anyone, just stating my opinion and hoping people here don’t waste their time.

I'd rather see people do what Nick Gatel does and learn to walk efficiently.

As for packs I’d suggest GG's Alpine Vapor (slightly smaller and you will eventually get a smaller UL pack anyhow, cheaper, lighter, but no frame). With durability as a parameter the Alpine Vapor will definitely meet your expectations with it’s cordura sections. Or go smaller and lighter still and check out the virga.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 6:06 am

Before I respond to the Crossfit comment I'd like to thank everyone who offered some advice on the packs. Sounds like the Gorilla is the way to go as it will downsize with me. Also after reading Will's excellent article. Anyone know when they'll be back in stock?

Yamabushi,

I am a level 1 certified Crossfit trainer with a background in rowing. I've worked for 8 months in a gym teaching this stuff day in/day out, not to mention reading everything I can. So I'm pretty used to vehement disagreements.

I certainly agree with you that it is not ideal training for the trail. The best training for hiking is to hike. Simple as that. People like Andrew Skurka and others have the luxury of being able to perfect their stride over many hours and many miles. But for us in the real world that may not be an option.

Right now I don't have the luxury of having my weekends free to go on a quick 10-20-30 miler. So crossfit with it's under-an-hour warmup/heavy lift/workout/ cool down has helped me:
1)Increase my cardiovascular fitness.
2)Prepare my joints for some of the pounding they'll take when going for mileage
3)Lost weight: 230 lbs-205 lbs. with a bit more to lose.
4)Created an all-around base focused on strength and cardiovascular fitness.
5)rehabbed my busted up knee from back in February '09. The only way I could have carried 50 lbs. In November '09 with some semblance of safety.

I'd argue that for someone consider a longer trail crossfit provides a good baseline from which to work. Is it perfect, no. It's not for everyone, certainly. But for my purpose and life it works very well. I'd have no fear about doing a 100 miler right now, especially with a low pack weight.

You seem to have a little trouble differentiating between General Physical Preparedness (GPP) and Sport Specific physical preparedness (SSPP). Each has their place and time. But recreational hikers have more need of GPP than they do of SSPP. Especially if they do other things in life beyond hiking.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 6:30 am

I'd say that it can cut both ways-it's good to reduce your gear first but on the other hand, a pack can be a pretty tough taskmaster, forcing you to cut your weight. If your going to get the pack first it's really worth spending a bunch of time doing test packing, doing test walks with all the gear but just a few miles close to home- it'll soon show you what is an optional item too far.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 3:38 pm

I recently acquired an Osprey Exos 34 as a combination winter day pack/summer weekend pack. It is very comfortable, versatile and user-friendly. It's light, too.

The frame on the Exos makes me think it might be a good match for you. The series is also a good bridge for those making the jump from palatial backpacking to light (or ultra-light). It has many of the features and conveniences of larger, heavier packs but does a very fine job of eliminating unnecessary weight….without sacrificing comfort.

I'd take a look at the Exos 46 and see how it fits.

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 5:52 pm

If you're going to compare apples to apples, compare the Circuit to the GG Mariposa. Gorilla is quit a bit smaller. But the Circuit will take the abuse of being overloaded better, IMO.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 6:08 pm

>The series is also a good bridge for those making the jump from palatial backpacking to light (or ultra-light).

I can vouch for that. I went from an old Kelty Coyote 4750 to the Exos 58. Ya, the 58 is large, but I sometimes need volume for winter.

And I've got the new SMD Swift pack on order. 18 ounces.

YAMABUSHI ! BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 7:21 pm

I was looking at the conduit today… that might be a good choice but I'd still say give the alpine vapor a hard look over… it's NICCCCeEE, durable, versatile, and smaller which is the direction your going anyhow.

Level 1 I see. It's good that it helps getting you to your goals and increase safety out there. I don’t have any difficulty between GPP & SSPP but once you get to a good base most people (some not all) go on to pick a sport or specialty goal be it a marathon, tri, bike race, or climbing.

For all BPL:

I find it quizzical that some UL peeps are so analytical and discerning when it comes to fabrics, weights, burn times, caloric density, etc. Yet somehow don't get nearly that crazy when it comes to the body that carries it all. That seems exactly like not caring what’s in your pack…

I'm going to stop now, step down off of my small soapbox, because I don’t want to alienate people, seem preachy, or elitist. I just don't want people to think it's the bee’s knees or waste their time.

-T. Horz

p.s. I pm'd you.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 7:38 pm

"I find it quizzical that some UL peeps are so analytical and discerning when it comes to fabrics, weights, burn times, caloric density, etc. Yet somehow don't get nearly that crazy when it comes to the body that carries it all. That seems exactly like not caring what’s in your pack…"

I'd bet if you trolled past threads on the subject you'd find that many people here do pay a lot of attention to training. They just aren't ideological about it, as in pro/anti Crossfit, etc. You can get yourself in pretty good shape with an eclectic, but purposeful, blend of strength and cardiovascular training that doesn't have a brand name and the accompanying hype, pro's, and con's attached to it. I think maybe you are underestimating the folks here. As for folks wasting their time with Crossfit, who are you to say? Work on your own fitness and leave others to do the same in peace.

Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
Loading...