Topic

Wood burning stove VS. alcohol for 400 mile half hike of AZT

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedFeb 7, 2010 at 10:59 am

I plan on hiking half of the Arizona trail this summer from phoenix-Utah basically some deserts than mostly ponderosa pine forest back to desert and am debating the choice for cooking. There will be 3 re supply's along the route and I can's decide between alcohol and wood burning. I like the idea of the wood because i can collect fuel on the trail and dont have to worry about carrying alcohol and shipping alcohol in my re supplies but I will be sacrificing speed of starting to cook. Are their any other cons pros I'm missing, I couldn't really find many through hikers talking about using wood and was wondering if i was missing a big con of wood.

P.s. i plan to bring a few esbit tabs for use in GCNP. And my cooking is primarily boiling water.

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedFeb 7, 2010 at 11:25 am

Will,
In the desert sections of your hike, are you sure you'll be able to find enough organic material to burn in your wood stove?

If the answer is yes, then I can't think of a reason why not. If wood stoves get people excited to shed fuel weight for mere weeklong hikes, then your potential weight savings for a thru-hike are just multiplied!

As for speed of cooking — how much time does it take to find wood and start a fire? 5 minutes? 10 minutes? 15 tops if you really have to look hard? And you'll get better at it through the course of your journey.

Also, I've heard people comment that the slower pacing that wood-cooking demands actually turns out to be pleasing and relaxing while out on the trail, especially for a long hike like you're talking about, where the overall rhythm of the trip becomes steady instead of sprint-y.

PostedFeb 7, 2010 at 11:34 am

I am pretty confident in my ability to find fuel in the desert (dead cactus skeletons and dead shrubs seem to litter the desert). I of course will take one on test hikes before the trip to make sure i am comfortable with finding fuel and do plan on having some back up fuel tabs in case of inclement weather.

PostedFeb 7, 2010 at 12:13 pm

Will,

I live in the Mojave Desert and like the idea of a wood burning stove. Lots of dead scrub wood here, especially Mesquite and creosote.

Personally I'd go for the Caldera Cone with the wood burning Inferno conversion. While this may be a bit less efficient in burning fuel than a Bush Buddy (but only a bit) I feel this is more than offset by the Caldera Cone's highly efficient design to CONSERVE that heat.

Plus it is far easier to feed fuel to the CC Inferno than the Bush Buddy. Unlike the CC Inferno the Bush Buddy must be fed fuel constantly.

I'm planning on getting the Titanium version of the Inferno with the little ESBIT cube holder as a backup if wood is unavailable. I'm going to get the Caldera Cone made to fit my 1 liter pot.

David Chenault BPL Member
PostedFeb 7, 2010 at 5:07 pm

The Coconino NF (and sometimes even the Kaibab) often has a fire ban put into effect in early summer. I'm not sure how a stove like the bushbuddy would factor into that, but when the ban is on the rangers are quite militant about it.

No fires in the Grand Canyon, but I presume you'll be through the ditch in a day.

From Phoenix north you'd have no trouble at all finding wood to burn. Maybe, maybe until you get into the Mazatzals, from there on it'd be easy-peasie.

Beware of the "lakes" up on the Kaibab Plateau. They're pretty gross.

A Wilson BPL Member
PostedFeb 7, 2010 at 9:55 pm

I think there's no doubt about the possibility of doing it. And indeed the desert is full of the handfuls of burnable stuff it takes to charge one of these fuel misers.

There's the question of regulations, to be sure; and I bet that fires are banned in summer along much of your proposed route. This ban probably would include alcohol stoves as well. Now each man takes his stand with regard to such laws, but it doesn't do lightweight backpacking any service if its practitioners are considered contemptuous of the law.

Now I know deserts are run over by ORVrs who do more damage in one outing than backpackers in years. But this isn't the point. Beyond the likelihood of illegality and fire danger, the desert (like timberline) remains one of those places where fairly rigid LNT ethics are most applicable.

I'd consider a canister stove, not only for legal reasons, but because it would also show that even lightweight extremists can sacrifice a couple of ounces for the sake of the current consensus (admittedly often draconian) of desert ethics. We may cringe at the thought of being anybody's ambassador, but the fact remains that we are.

Robert Blean BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 12:32 am

> I bet that fires are banned in summer along much of your proposed route.
> This ban probably would include alcohol stoves as well.

My understanding is that some places allow the BushBuddy, even during a fire ban, because it is enclosed. I gather you believe AZ would not?

As to the alcohol — why would the ban include alcohol stoves? Is the issue open fuel, and it would include gasoline stoves as well — i.e. anything other than canisters?

— Bob

A Wilson BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 10:50 am

In burn ban times in Western mountains, alcohol stoves can be nitpicked by certain rangers, because they have no off switch, and if kicked could send flaming liquid everywhere. Enclosed wood fires may fall under different regulations; you'll have to check with the land management areas you'll be traveling in.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...