Topic

Analysis for my day/gear on the mountain?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedFeb 6, 2010 at 4:35 pm

Hey team,
I moved up to Colorado about a month ago, and today had my first serious winter mountain experience. Went up Mt. Sniktau next to the Loveland Ski area. Short hike, about 3.5 miles round-trip, and 1500 total feet of elevation.

I'm not new to high mountains, but have only done stuff in the summer and dry fall conditions before. Therefore, I didn't know quite what to expect, how my body and gear would do, and took my best guesses, knowing that any serious blunders would be saved by the fact that this is a short, popular hike, with easy car access in case of emergency.

Clothing:
Base layers: OR sequence L/S + generic silkweight poly tights
Windshells: WildThings Epic hooded + Arc'Teryx palisade pants
Insulation: MB down inner parka
Borrowed: Full-zip hardshell pants
Bits and pieces: PolarBuff + OR lightweight beanie + Seirus HyperLite All-weather gloves

Okay, got all that? Here's how the day went . . .

The climb began as a bluebird day — sunny and warm enough that I was comfortable with just the base layers and windshell layers listed above, plus my PolarBuff as a beanie on my head.

By the time we reached the summit, things had gotten much worse, recorded 16* F on top, lots of wind and blowing snow, semi-whiteout conditions I suppose. With my Epic jacket layered over the MB Down jacket, my PolarBuff converted to a full balaclava, and the hardshell pants layered over everything else . . . I was still getting cold. My hiking partners were WAY over-prepared, so I was able to borrow some insulated-hardshell Big Dumb Mitts to slide over my dinky Seirus gloves. At that point, wearing *everything* in as warm a configuration as I could make it . . . I still couldn't survive up on that summit. My partners stayed, but I had to bail and get moving again.

The rough weather continued until the end, but on the descent, once I was moving again, the pieces listed above combined so that I was very comfortable and warm. I even had to ditch the Big Dumb Mitts and vent my jacket layers a little during some of the descent.

So — altogether, I feel like the day was a triumph for my ultralight kit. I carried, in total, probably about 1/3 the oz's of my two partners. I had to borrow those BDMs, but still — my best guesses for this opening duel with the mountains turned out mostly in my favor.

My questions for you — do you all see holes, mistakes, or easy room for improvement in my kit here? What would be the best piece to add to be able to hang out on that summit a little longer, in those conditions? I have confusion about whether down is a good choice in these conditions. Should I get a synthetic piece to layer on top of everything, belay-style?

All commentary welcome. Thanks for helping, team.

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedFeb 6, 2010 at 4:52 pm

Some particular questions:

1) Windpants
Regarding the lightly-lined hardshell pants that I threw on near the summit, it's hard for me to know how much warmth came from insulation value versus simple wind-blocking power. I know that hardshell fabrics are 100% windproof by definition. Anybody want to hazard a guess weather I could have replaced these with an ultralight windpant option like the Montane Featherlites? As I understand it, such layers have basically no insulative value. Thus, my thinking is that such a layer would only help if A) I'm already moving and generating heat, and want to retain that heat better in the wind, or B) I'm idle and hopefully wearing insulative pant layers already, and want to retain that heat better in the wind.

Is that about right? And/or do people have success using something as light as the Featherlite Pants in mountain-winter conditions?

2) Gloves
I've already browsed through BPL's handwear survey from OR Market '08. Lots of choices, not a lot of clarity. If you could disregard my choices for the day — Seirus Hyperlites and hardshell Big Dumb Mitts — what lightweight glove system would you have used?

Thanks.

Konrad . BPL Member
PostedFeb 6, 2010 at 4:55 pm

My take on it, I think you can either improve 1 of 2 things. You could get a better insulation layer, as the MB UL inner parka's comfort range is usually around 30 for most, and around 20 for some warm bodies. A 800 fill down sweater that weighs around 13oz (youre a size small, i remember we were going for the same MB jacket) such as a TNF thunder down jacket, patagonia sweater, or first ascent down sweater should let you push your system down to the 20's and below depending on your activity level. The cheaper solution would be to work on your base layers. I think the OR shirt u have is a silkweight shirt? For really cold weather, i either layer up in 200+ weight merino wool, or my new favorite, anything in polartec power stretch. This applies for your tops and bottoms. This coupled with you current MB jacket, should push you to a more comfortable level too. I'm not familiar with the wind permeability of epic, or your arc pants, but cutting windchill makes you feel substantially warmer…but you already know that

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedFeb 6, 2010 at 4:57 pm

I may be admonished for being old school, but I would have started out a little heavier on clothing. Polypro long underware, army issue wool trousers, and then Goretex rain pants if it got cold. At least one heavy synthetic or wool shirt, maybe that down layer if it got cold, and old school Goretex parka on top. Oh, and two hats, one for sun and one for cold.

I'm not familiar with some of your pieces, but you have to have the ability to vent the shell easily, and then be able to seal it up tightly as soon as the wind gusts.

Lots of people will be hiking around in the mountains on a nice day, and then they don't see it when the storm is approaching until it is too late. By then, they are exhausted and start thrashing around in fresh snow, and before you know it, they've stepped through some snow crust and dunked themselves into the stream, or break a leg bone against a rock. More typically, they have lost their way (lack of GPS), so they waste a lot of time getting out to safety.

Darwin's Law prevails.

–B.G.–

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedFeb 6, 2010 at 5:23 pm

Bob,
Trying to stay ultralight — I came pretty close today to doing perfectly, and that was in some pretty rough weather. All I'm looking to do is increase the margin of my current system, not redo my system entirely with conventional-weight stuff. Thanks though!

Konrad,
Yeah good calls on both.

I've definitely been pushing the limit of the MB UL Down Inner since I came to Colorado. I wonder if, for what I encountered today, the Alpine Light Parka would have been ideal. It seems to be the overall warmth/cost champ in its weight class, and the review was excellent.

Regarding the base layer — yeah, actually I used to have the much-lauded Mountain Hardwear powerstretch zip-T, and it was outstanding. Who knows why I got rid of it, probably trying to get $$s to buy something else. Anybody wanna sell me one in a medium?

I guess the alternative would be a powerstretch-ish hoody base layer like the R1 or any of the other good ones that have been mentioned on these forums. But, those are expensive and in limited options, compared to simple powerstretch Ts.

Good calls, thanks.

Any notes on the windpants and glove layers?

PostedFeb 6, 2010 at 5:32 pm

"what lightweight glove system would you have used?"

My favorite system, at the moment, is possum down gloves as a base layer. If I need a bit of wind protection, I add I'll either throw on the MLD eVent mitts, or Manzella Windstopper gloves (MLD mitts are waterproof when seam sealed, the Manzella gloves are not). If it's really cold, I'll throw on the BPL FeatherLite Vapor mitts.

This is good, so far for me, down to around 5-10 degrees.

PostedFeb 6, 2010 at 5:36 pm

"Any notes on the windpants and glove layers?"

I know nothing of the Arc'Teryx palisade pants, but I swear by my RAB vapor-rise pants. Wearing only those and icebreaker 150 boxers (no long johns), I was good down to like 8 degrees last weekend on a snowy night. I hiked in them all day, stood around in them that evening before bed, and slept in them in my hammock (got down to 3 degrees). Comfortable in all 3 scenarios.

But it wasn't overly windy, so I can't yet attest to that.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...